Author Topic: Dejounte Murray  (Read 2460 times)

SparzWizard and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

Re: Dejounte Murray
« Reply #30 on: Today at 11:00:16 AM »

Online snively

  • Paul Silas
  • ******
  • Posts: 6109
  • Tommy Points: 514
I think Mikal Bridges is he best proxy for Trey Murphy III.

Do folks think Mikal Bridges is better than D White?

I'd give the edge to White for his ability to play PG.

But gotta like Murphy's age.
2025 Draft: Chicago Bulls

PG: Chauncey Billups/Deron Williams
SG: Kobe Bryant/Eric Gordon
SF: Jimmy Butler/Danny Granger/Danilo Gallinari
PF: Al Horford/Zion Williamson
C: Yao Ming/Pau Gasol/Tyson Chandler

Re: Dejounte Murray
« Reply #31 on: Today at 12:05:42 PM »

Online Roy H.

  • Forums Manager
  • James Naismith
  • *********************************
  • Posts: 65387
  • Tommy Points: -25326
  • Optionality: Cope Springs Eternal
I think Mikal Bridges is he best proxy for Trey Murphy III.

Do folks think Mikal Bridges is better than D White?

Are we using 2026 and prior Bridges, or this year's version?

I haven't followed NY closely; what's up with Bridges' major drop in production?
I'M THE SILVERBACK GORILLA IN THIS MOTHER... AND DON'T NONE OF YA'LL EVER FORGET IT!

Re: Dejounte Murray
« Reply #32 on: Today at 12:08:55 PM »

Online Roy H.

  • Forums Manager
  • James Naismith
  • *********************************
  • Posts: 65387
  • Tommy Points: -25326
  • Optionality: Cope Springs Eternal
Yeah I would only be interested in this if we were getting legit draft capital back from them.

Now a package built around White for Trey Murphy is a bit more interesting.


Murray and Murphy for White, Robinson, and Hauser works in the trade machine. Celtics would probably have to give up a first round pick or two as well.

Starters: Murray, Murphy, George, Tatum, Queta
Bench: Pritchard, Scheierman, Hugo, Walsh, Cenac Jr, Garza

Now that is a contender. Get it done, Brad!

That's a terrible trade for the Celtics. Murray is a negative value contract right now. Derrick White is the best player in the trade and was an all-defensive 1st team guy last year.

Why is everyone so down on our players? 6 months does not change how good Robinson and White are.

Murphy is clearly the best piece in that trade package. Derrick White is averaging 12ppg. He has never averaged more than 16ppg for a season. What are you talking about..  ???

I think folks are just too attached to our guys who've been here for a while therefore they are untouchable.

White's days dominating for the Celtics are over. We miss the Derrick White of 2023. He isn't even playing like a #3 player on the team.

I don't think in general it's attachment to our players.  I think it's that people don't want to trade a solid role player for a worse player, and that's the clear risk with Murray.

But Murphy vs. White, straight up?  Murphy is the better player, although positionally it would leave us quite weak at PG.

I'M THE SILVERBACK GORILLA IN THIS MOTHER... AND DON'T NONE OF YA'LL EVER FORGET IT!

Re: Dejounte Murray
« Reply #33 on: Today at 12:13:12 PM »

Online Who

  • James Naismith
  • *********************************
  • Posts: 56010
  • Tommy Points: 2634
I think Mikal Bridges is he best proxy for Trey Murphy III.

Do folks think Mikal Bridges is better than D White?

Are we using 2026 and prior Bridges, or this year's version?

I haven't followed NY closely; what's up with Bridges' major drop in production?

Yeah, we'll skip past this season's performance. Seems like a confidence. He has always been a guy prone to ups and downs. Take his previous 2 years with the Knicks as the proxy.

That is one good thing about Trey Murphy over Mikal Bridges. Murphy has a legit scorer's mentality. He likes to put up shots. He looks to shoot. Mikal Bridges has always been prone to stretches of passivity.

Re: Dejounte Murray
« Reply #34 on: Today at 12:16:36 PM »

Online Who

  • James Naismith
  • *********************************
  • Posts: 56010
  • Tommy Points: 2634
I think Mikal Bridges is he best proxy for Trey Murphy III.

Do folks think Mikal Bridges is better than D White?

I'd give the edge to White for his ability to play PG.

But gotta like Murphy's age.

Yeah, that is where I am too. D White is probably still better. For the here and now I take D White but given the age gap I would do happily do that trade. Trey Murphy the better long term asset.

D White does more glue guy type things that make team more cohesive on both ends of the court. Trey Murphy is more individualistic. He takes care of his own end of things but he doesn't do much to improve those around him. Similar to Mikal Bridges in that respect.

Re: Dejounte Murray
« Reply #35 on: Today at 12:26:49 PM »

Online Vermont Green

  • Reggie Lewis
  • ***************
  • Posts: 15843
  • Tommy Points: 1135
I think Mikal Bridges is he best proxy for Trey Murphy III.

Do folks think Mikal Bridges is better than D White?

I'd give the edge to White for his ability to play PG.

But gotta like Murphy's age.

A 26 year old Forward/Wing (Murphy) could be a better player for some teams, maybe a lot of teams.  A cagey vet guard (White), with championship pedigree is better for other teams.  My point is that based on roster timeline, positional needs, and so on, I am not convinced that Murphy is a better player for BOS right now.  Murphy probably is a better player for NOP right now, which is why I can't imagine why either team would make this trade.

Re: Dejounte Murray
« Reply #36 on: Today at 12:27:49 PM »

Online Roy H.

  • Forums Manager
  • James Naismith
  • *********************************
  • Posts: 65387
  • Tommy Points: -25326
  • Optionality: Cope Springs Eternal
I think Mikal Bridges is he best proxy for Trey Murphy III.

Do folks think Mikal Bridges is better than D White?

Are we using 2026 and prior Bridges, or this year's version?

I haven't followed NY closely; what's up with Bridges' major drop in production?

Yeah, we'll skip past this season's performance. Seems like a confidence. He has always been a guy prone to ups and downs. Take his previous 2 years with the Knicks as the proxy.

That is one good thing about Trey Murphy over Mikal Bridges. Murphy has a legit scorer's mentality. He likes to put up shots. He looks to shoot. Mikal Bridges has always been prone to stretches of passivity.

Yeah, under those circumstances, it's a solid comparison.  And, I think regarding team building, I wouldn't trade White for 2026 Bridges.  I *would* trade Hauser, Robinson and a pick or two for a 26 year old version of 2026 Bridges, though.

The point of trading for Murphy would be to put him next to our existing starters and make a better team.  White is still a big part of that.

Murray would be an interesting reclamation project next to White.  If ownership wasn't so budget conscious, I'd probably pull the trigger on Robinson and Hauser for Murray. 

Queta
Tatum
George
White
Murray / Pritchard

That's got the potential to be a really good team, but there would be significant holes on the bench, it would put us over the tax, and the window would be seemingly quite short.
I'M THE SILVERBACK GORILLA IN THIS MOTHER... AND DON'T NONE OF YA'LL EVER FORGET IT!

Re: Dejounte Murray
« Reply #37 on: Today at 12:36:30 PM »

Online Vermont Green

  • Reggie Lewis
  • ***************
  • Posts: 15843
  • Tommy Points: 1135
I think Mikal Bridges is he best proxy for Trey Murphy III.

Do folks think Mikal Bridges is better than D White?

Are we using 2026 and prior Bridges, or this year's version?

I haven't followed NY closely; what's up with Bridges' major drop in production?

Yeah, we'll skip past this season's performance. Seems like a confidence. He has always been a guy prone to ups and downs. Take his previous 2 years with the Knicks as the proxy.

That is one good thing about Trey Murphy over Mikal Bridges. Murphy has a legit scorer's mentality. He likes to put up shots. He looks to shoot. Mikal Bridges has always been prone to stretches of passivity.

Yeah, under those circumstances, it's a solid comparison.  And, I think regarding team building, I wouldn't trade White for 2026 Bridges.  I *would* trade Hauser, Robinson and a pick or two for a 26 year old version of 2026 Bridges, though.

The point of trading for Murphy would be to put him next to our existing starters and make a better team.  White is still a big part of that.

Murray would be an interesting reclamation project next to White.  If ownership wasn't so budget conscious, I'd probably pull the trigger on Robinson and Hauser for Murray. 

Queta
Tatum
George
White
Murray / Pritchard

That's got the potential to be a really good team, but there would be significant holes on the bench, it would put us over the tax, and the window would be seemingly quite short.

Are you suggesting that NOP would trade Murphy for Hauser + Robinson or is this purely hypothetical?  I would not do that trade if I was NOP.  Hauser and Robinson don't help them.  It would be a bad trade for NOP, unless BOS included draft picks (plural).

I would like this trade in terms of value, Murphy > Hauser + Robinson, and I think positionally, BOS could make this would, but I don't think you would be getting the full value out of Murphy forcing him to play as a 3rd forward on the floor.  I don't think this best suits White either.

Re: Dejounte Murray
« Reply #38 on: Today at 12:45:27 PM »

Online Roy H.

  • Forums Manager
  • James Naismith
  • *********************************
  • Posts: 65387
  • Tommy Points: -25326
  • Optionality: Cope Springs Eternal
I think Mikal Bridges is he best proxy for Trey Murphy III.

Do folks think Mikal Bridges is better than D White?

Are we using 2026 and prior Bridges, or this year's version?

I haven't followed NY closely; what's up with Bridges' major drop in production?

Yeah, we'll skip past this season's performance. Seems like a confidence. He has always been a guy prone to ups and downs. Take his previous 2 years with the Knicks as the proxy.

That is one good thing about Trey Murphy over Mikal Bridges. Murphy has a legit scorer's mentality. He likes to put up shots. He looks to shoot. Mikal Bridges has always been prone to stretches of passivity.

Yeah, under those circumstances, it's a solid comparison.  And, I think regarding team building, I wouldn't trade White for 2026 Bridges.  I *would* trade Hauser, Robinson and a pick or two for a 26 year old version of 2026 Bridges, though.

The point of trading for Murphy would be to put him next to our existing starters and make a better team.  White is still a big part of that.

Murray would be an interesting reclamation project next to White.  If ownership wasn't so budget conscious, I'd probably pull the trigger on Robinson and Hauser for Murray. 

Queta
Tatum
George
White
Murray / Pritchard

That's got the potential to be a really good team, but there would be significant holes on the bench, it would put us over the tax, and the window would be seemingly quite short.

Are you suggesting that NOP would trade Murphy for Hauser + Robinson or is this purely hypothetical?  I would not do that trade if I was NOP.  Hauser and Robinson don't help them.  It would be a bad trade for NOP, unless BOS included draft picks (plural).

I would like this trade in terms of value, Murphy > Hauser + Robinson, and I think positionally, BOS could make this would, but I don't think you would be getting the full value out of Murphy forcing him to play as a 3rd forward on the floor.  I don't think this best suits White either.

Two concepts discussed there. 

1.  Murphy for "Hauser, Robinson and a pick or two".  Depending on the picks, NOP would have interest I think.   For further discussion regarding that concept see the Bill Simmons trade target thread.

2.  Murray for Hauser, Robinson

I think NOP would do this without picks.  Should we?  I don't think we would because it's not budget neutral; "there would be significant holes on the bench, it would put us over the tax, and the window would be seemingly quite short"
I'M THE SILVERBACK GORILLA IN THIS MOTHER... AND DON'T NONE OF YA'LL EVER FORGET IT!

Re: Dejounte Murray
« Reply #39 on: Today at 12:54:08 PM »

Online Vermont Green

  • Reggie Lewis
  • ***************
  • Posts: 15843
  • Tommy Points: 1135
I think Mikal Bridges is he best proxy for Trey Murphy III.

Do folks think Mikal Bridges is better than D White?

Are we using 2026 and prior Bridges, or this year's version?

I haven't followed NY closely; what's up with Bridges' major drop in production?

Yeah, we'll skip past this season's performance. Seems like a confidence. He has always been a guy prone to ups and downs. Take his previous 2 years with the Knicks as the proxy.

That is one good thing about Trey Murphy over Mikal Bridges. Murphy has a legit scorer's mentality. He likes to put up shots. He looks to shoot. Mikal Bridges has always been prone to stretches of passivity.

Yeah, under those circumstances, it's a solid comparison.  And, I think regarding team building, I wouldn't trade White for 2026 Bridges.  I *would* trade Hauser, Robinson and a pick or two for a 26 year old version of 2026 Bridges, though.

The point of trading for Murphy would be to put him next to our existing starters and make a better team.  White is still a big part of that.

Murray would be an interesting reclamation project next to White.  If ownership wasn't so budget conscious, I'd probably pull the trigger on Robinson and Hauser for Murray. 

Queta
Tatum
George
White
Murray / Pritchard

That's got the potential to be a really good team, but there would be significant holes on the bench, it would put us over the tax, and the window would be seemingly quite short.

Are you suggesting that NOP would trade Murphy for Hauser + Robinson or is this purely hypothetical?  I would not do that trade if I was NOP.  Hauser and Robinson don't help them.  It would be a bad trade for NOP, unless BOS included draft picks (plural).

I would like this trade in terms of value, Murphy > Hauser + Robinson, and I think positionally, BOS could make this would, but I don't think you would be getting the full value out of Murphy forcing him to play as a 3rd forward on the floor.  I don't think this best suits White either.

Two concepts discussed there. 

1.  Murphy for "Hauser, Robinson and a pick or two".  Depending on the picks, NOP would have interest I think.   For further discussion regarding that concept see the Bill Simmons trade target thread.

2.  Murray for Hauser, Robinson

I think NOP would do this without picks.  Should we?  I don't think we would because it's not budget neutral; "there would be significant holes on the bench, it would put us over the tax, and the window would be seemingly quite short"

OK, I understand.  Murphy for for Hauser, Robinson, Picks is interesting, for sure, but I am not quite sold.  Murray for Hauser, Robinson probably does not fly due to salary, as you say.

You could put these together and trade White, Hauser, Robinson for Murray and Murphy.  BOS still probably need to add a pick or picks, but this is closer.  Assume Murray is healthy of course.  I think a healthy Murray is a better guard fit than White with a line up of (3) forwards and a Center.