Not sure where to post this question, but who gets your vote for the biggest surprise this year:
Queta
Garza
Shiereman
Walsh
Hugo
JB
JT
I had a very similar thought; I was thinking of starting a poll, but never got around to it. My question was a little different but similar. My question was who made the biggest impact to the unexpected success, which is a little different than who individually was the biggest surprise.
It is tough question and I don't have a solid answer. Queta clearly was a big surprise, at least to me. He went from 3rd string bench guy to indispensable starter. So he is both a big surprise but also a big contributor to success. Then a look at Brown, to me, he was the biggest contributor to the success but maybe not as much of a surprise. He was better than I expected, but not like he came out of nowhere.
Then I group Scheierman, Walsh, and Gonzalez all together. I am very surprised at how well all of them played. I was not expecting anything from any of them. So they are big surprises but their contribution to winning is not at the same level as Queta or Brown. Maybe collectively you could say they contributed as much as Queta, but even that may be a stretch. Scheierman may have a bigger impact in the playoffs, the way he is going lately.