A little context on Vince Carter and his inefficient era.
Vince Carter was a superstar definitely on the Raptors, maybe on the Nets, and in 06-07 he had a 50.3% eFG% with a 13.7% defensive rebounding rate and a 17.4% assist rate at SG.
For context and on guys from that era:
-KG?s eFG for his 3 prime Wolves years during this era are 50.4%, 52.9% and 48%. He went #3. Yes KG a better player and a 2 way player, but Vince also went 64 picks later. Vince had a better assist rate.
-DWade?s eFG from his quintessential season is 51.6%. He went 1st round
-Dirks eFG in 10-11 was 54.5%. The 6 prior years it was 49.8%, 49.8%, 51%, 52.9%, 51.5%, 49%. He was a 1st round pick.
-CP3?s eFG from his magical 07-09 NO years, 52.8% and 52.4%. He was a 2nd round pick.
-Pierce?s eFG from 04-09 was 49.9%, 50.9%, 50.2%, 52.9%, 50.8%. He was a 3rd round pick.
Now, these guys range from good to elite defenders, and that?s important.
The issue is if you think that Vince was a high volume chucker, then Vince as your 8th man at pick 67 is a lot less of a problem that one of the above guys as a #1-3 guy at the cost of a top 20-25 pick. They all have comparable usage rates to Vince, so they would all be inefficient chuckers too. Much more expensive ones
Era matters, and all these guys were studs with games that would translate today. Melo too, and hopefully he and Vince would try harder on D because they had the potential to be solid