Hali is a cookie on defense, lol. Can't guard anything. He'll jump a passing lane off ball once in a while but anything that targets him is too much for him.
The more I watch guys around the league, the more I am thankful that we have two superstar players who ALSO can play defense, and at an elite level.
Doncic, Haliburton, even a few others like Kyrie/SGA/Brunson/Mitchell, etc. they are MVP-caliber and hyped up but typically they are poor defenders. I mean SGA is solid but not great defensively. But still...
Eh, I think there's a few different groupings there.
Doncic and Haliburton are in a league of their own. Not only are they poor defenders, but they clearly give little to no effort on that side of the ball regularly.
I think players like Kyrie, Brunson, Mitchell, etc. are poor defenders, but they generally give good effort and actually try defensively.
I think SGA's defense is greatly overrated to inflate his overall MVP candidacy, but he's at least an average defender who generally tries on defense.
That's fair. It's just a luxury that our superstar players can also play elite defense. Not many like that in the league. Lebron, Kawhi, prime PG13, Giannis, there are a few others but not many.
Lebron ? His defensive effort is VERY inconsistent depending on his mood.
I have a friend who is a Laker fan who hates Lebron for several reasons, one being his insistence on a max contract when he could easily take a discount to help them add rotational players to the roster. He talks big about being all about the championships, but clearly his bottom line is more important. Kobe did the same thing to his team his last few seasons.
That's hilarious, I literally have a Lakers friend who says the same thing

He also vows that Lebron will never be bigger than Kobe in the LA market.
The defense part is true, but I can't deny that in his peak days with the Cavaliers and Heat he could be an elite defender, and yeah it wasn't always consistent as you say but the skillset was there. He did obviously have some huge defensive plays in his career like the block on Iggy in the Finals Game 7. And I mean... he's Lebron. Not many like him in the entire NBA history.