I think with an elite target, Mac Is a top 10 or 13 qb. He doesn't have the tangible elite qualities, but his brain is impressive. He just has nothing to work with to quote Moranis. I'd love to see him with one game breaker. His upside with that given is in the ball park of Cousins. He's a cannon that needs to be primed with talent. That terrifies me.
I don't think he'd be that good, but he could certainly put up those kind of numbers. They needed Hopkins, or someone like him. He'd have have just opened everything up. JuJu, Bourne, Thornton would all just be so much better with a real #1. It would also create more lanes for Hunter and Gesicki and give bigger holes to Stevenson. A true top end pass catcher just does so much for a offense and Mac may not have the biggest arm, but he is certainly accurate. The offense just needs a guy that is THE guy. They don't have that and couple that with a terrible OL and poor pass catchers (as a whole) and solid but unspectacular RB"s and they just aren't going tonscore enough to be a good team. Defense is good, so they won't be terrible, but good they are not.
Hopkins was a non-starter for NE and Belichick. He doesn't practice. What other #1 was available?
I also think they need a #1, but you're making it sound like it was an easy thing to acquire.
The Patriots were rumored as the front runner to land Hopkins, but then Tennessee upped their offer and New England didn't match. The Patriots should have paid the money and signed him. It was a glaring need for them. Now I don't think Hopkins is the player he once was, but he is still a #1, just not one of the handful of best WR's in the league like he once was. The Patriots cheaped out, when they had a need and the money. That has been happening basically for 25 years though. In my opinion, it is the main reason Brady left. He was tired of taking discounts only for the team to cheap out.
I also don't necessarily believe that Hopkins chose the Titans over the Patriots because he thought the Titans had a better chance to win, I think it was purely money driven, but if that rumor is true, it does support a lot of what I've been saying about Mac and the teams future. Again, I think Hopkins chose the money and had the Patriots offered more, he would have gone there and said the same thing i.e. he went to the team that offered him the best chance to win.