Yeah, Tatum has developed into a terrific player. Top 5 in the league, MVP discussion worth, all that is fair and great for the Celtics. But Bird had something extra. I don't know how to quantify that with advanced stats or whatever, but I am old enough to have been able to watch Bird and he simply was better, could do more. Was harder to stop.
Now to compare Tatum to Pierce or Havlicek, sure, that is fair. I think Tatum has now passed these guys in terms of individual performance. It is always hard to compare players from different eras and that is what we are trying to do here. Even my memory of Havlicek is a little foggy. Anything before him is even harder for me.
IT is not in the same league in my mind. He had one season that was right there with pretty much any season anyone had. But all these others had 10 or more seasons like that (Tatum will soon enough).