Watched Death by Lightning. Friends of mine disagree but I thought it wasn?t very good. Maybe it was just not much of a story, or maybe the story was not well told, but i found it to be mundane in general and the characters to be stereotypical and not well acted. Essentially, a mentally ill man with delusions of grandeur decides to go from supporter to murderer overnight while a mild-mannered, unlikely president makes civil rights progress and finds a way to destroy corruption in NYC and the US Senate in a couple of months in office. And this, even as his corrupt, drunken, incompetent, buffoon of a VP (Chester Arthur) works from the inside to maintain the corruption and undermine the president. Arthur changes his ways after Garfield (the president, not the cat) refuses his resignation and gets shot. Of course, after being shot, the on the scene doctor is a black man who warns the white doctor not to risk sepsis as the white doctor takes over and practices unsanitary medicine attempting to retrieve the bullet in Garfield?s body. The scene provides obvious foreboding as Garfield dies a couple of months later of sepsis due to the white doctors malpractice.
The transformation of Chester Arthur occurs during Garfields unsuccessful convalescence when Garfield?s wife slaps the vice president in the face - and suddenly he is a new man, ethical and capable. IDK what is and isn?t accurate in the story, but I didn?t find it compelling and was grateful that it ended mercifully after 4 episodes. I wouldn?t have stuck it out if it had been longer.
But my friends liked it.
I liked it, if only because it told a story that I wasn't familiar with in a digestible way. I think I would only recommend it to people who really like American history though.
I've enjoyed it. It's defiitely not a deep thinker of a show, but like Roy said it tells a tale and it's fun to look at people dressed in period costumes and in those settings. The assassin character seems like someone in a musical who is on the verge of shifting from verse to song, but never does (thankfully). "Hammy" is the best word I can come up with, but I think that's intentional.
I think I?d have liked him better if he broke into song. A *got to pick a pocket or two* type number as he?s contemplating the assassination.
I really enjoyed Death By Lightning-- except for the last episode which was just a long, drawn-out, slow death by Garfield.
The cast was excellent with two guys from Boardwalk Empire: Michael Shannon (President Garfield) and Shea Wigham (excellent in whatever he does as a Senator from New York who controlled the NYC ports like a mobster).
And Bradley Whitford as another senator who was on the side of Garfield.
I loved Nick Offerman as Chester Arthur. I had no idea he was such a big buffoon, basically a barroom bouncer who kicked ass on the ports of NYC.
But the best was Matthew MacFadyen (from Succession) as the assassin Guiteau. He played "crazy" soooo well. You felt sorry for him, and almost believed that he was just an unlucky guy who was no crazier than say Steve Jobs, but just didn't have the luck/connections/social standing.
But then every scene he'd do one little thing, like grab the 1st lady by the wrist just a little too hard, or get just a little too passionate with a speech that he seemed a little obsessed, or say something just a little... odd.
The way he kept trying and trying and then slowly turned into a lunatic was fascinating.
This series really made you feel like, if Garfield had lived that he would have changed the country for the better in so many ways (hey, it's TV, they have to make it "mean more" right?) in the same way Lincoln and Kennedy have been portrayed with their deaths and how the country changed afterwards in their absence (again, TV/Hollywood's spinning of that tale).
It's just also really cool to see how life was when all kinds of technology like electricity, public transportation, the telephone, even... toilet paper came into being.