So I guess George woke up. Took 4 playoff games but since Game 5 of the Mavs series he's been great.
B-b-but he's just an above average offensive player who is a fringe All-Star at best! He's a known choker who's inefficient come playoff time with average playmaking! He's clearly worse than Tatum! Hot takes from a few playoff games never get old 
I feel like if his shoulders don't stop bothering him he could age poorly (he's already 30, when did that happen!), but he's definitely inefficient come playoff time with a career playoff eFG% of 49% and not a great TO:assist ratio.
I think PG is defensively ahead of Tatum (particularly 1v1), but I think I'd rather have Tatum for his efficiency both in shooting and turnovers. He's also a superior rebounder and a much improved passer, I'd say right near on the level of PG