FWIW, and I know no one cares about my opinion, but I wouldn't vote Jeter into the HOF, myself.
My criteria is that a player should have dominated or transformed some aspect of the game for an extended period. Was the player ever one of the overall best players in baseball? Was he ever the best at his position in baseball for an extended period? Was he ever one of the best hitters in baseball for an extended period?
Jeter stayed healthy and has some impressive inning, game and plate appearance totals (and some seasons with large counting totals as a result). And his teams were so dominant that he played in a ton of post-season innings as well. So kudos for staying healthy, and being a well-above average player on a dominant team in baseball's biggest market.
If that's enough for others to vote him in, that's fine. I just don't agree. *shrug*