No, it is not saying something. You are completely ignoring that our complete core (Rondo, KG, Pierce) was playing last year. You say we had a change to make the playoffs, yet Pierce, Allen, Stiemsma and Pietrus were all injured. Bradley, Green, Wilcox etc. weren't even playing and the rest of the bench was nonexistent (it scored a combined two points in game 7).
This year, we had a complete team with a much better bench that was actually producing but one of our core players, Rondo, wasn't even playing. The only thing this year proved was how much valuable Rondo is to this team.
You completely ignored Rondo. They couldn't make it out of first round because one of our best players, Rondo, wasn't even playing. If you take Rondo out of the Celtics, obviously they won't do good. Just like if you take LeBron out of the Heat, Durant out of Thunder, CP3 out of Clippers, Kobe out of Lakers etc.
None of those teams will do as well without their best or one of the best players.
If you are going to just start ignoring the most obvious things to try to prove your decision, then I can alter the reality to prove my point too.
Its like taking a2 out of the Pythagorean Theorem (a2+b2=c2)
[/quote]
Last year, we had a healthy Rondo and we still couldn't get past Miami in the Eastern Conference finals. I also don't think Rondo has the same effect on the Celtics that a Durant or Lebron has on their respective teams. Rondo is talented but I don't think he's an elite NBA player.Regarding injuries, that's something to pin on Ainge 100%.
It's the GM's job to foresee injuries and provide the team with proper depth as injuries happen to all teams.
Regarding Pierce and KG, my feeling is if you bring them back, at this point they are nothing more than role/bench players.
Bringing them back is not necessarily a bad idea, BUT you can not rely on them to carry you. You need younger, more atheltic players in their prime to replace them in the starting line up.
I am not necessarily saying we should axe Pierce/KG. But, if we play our cards right, I also don't think our team will be an embarrasment without them.