My reply to all of this:
www.celticsblog.com/2014/10/21/6847457/avery-bradley-contract-will-look-like-a-bargain-when-its-all-said-and-done-nba-boston-celtics
You lost me at the "massive" contracts of Meeks ($6.3 million per annum) and Miles ($4.5 million per year). Both of them are providing Avery Bradley type of production for a fraction of what we're paying Avery Bradley.
you raise a good question on whom ainge was bidding against. but on the comparisons above, are there enough differences with bradley that significant to warrant this much concern and vexation on the overpay?
bradley makes $7.2 million this year, which compared to meeks is just under a million dollars extra. bradley is 3 years younger than meeks. recent scoring is almost a wash, though bradley's other stats are marginally better. so, ainge's choice for bradley in this context could be understood. similar stats, bradley 3 years younger and already at meeks' production, bradley has POTENTIAl to improve since he has not yet reached his best years...in theory. plus, i dont know meeks' defense, but bradley is pretty good.
on miles, you have a stronger case. miles makes almost $3 million less than bradley. now we are talking an amount that might be important. though again, miles is 3 years older than bradley. their stats are comparable, though bradley nudges ahead in recent scoring. i confess ignorance on miles' defense as well. but, again, we know bradley on defense.
so, the differences in salary among bradley, miles, and meeks varies from small to significant. the countable stats i looked at are roughly comparable. but edge to bradley in being 3 years younger and matching miles/meeks stats at an earlier age.
final point to consider is defense, which i cant speak too for miles and meeks. are they roughly comparable in their defense? if not, then another edge to bradley.
so, yeah, they all are comparable in many ways, but i still do not see a stunning difference that shouts bradley is a dramatically bad overpay by comparison. no one here denies bradley, for now, is getting more money than he should. i think the discussion has evolved into how dramatic and impactful the over pay is.