philly atlanta mix-it-up trade

[wiley]

http://www.realgm.com/src_tradechecker/3/

Atlanta gets Iggy, Speights, Holiday and Lou Williams 
Philly gets Horford, Bibby and Marvin Williams

Atlanta organizes themeselves a bit better and improves the backcourt.
Philly gives Evan Turner the ball (Bibby won't mind, he'll shoot a bunch of 3's)

Bibby, Turner, Marvin Williams, Horford, Brand
Thaddeus Young, Hawes, Nocioni, sign a backup PG.

Holiday, Iggy, Joe Johnson, Josh Smith, Pachulia
Speights, Lou Williams, Crawford, Collins, Powell (trade Teague, maybe to Philly)


Philly gives up more talent but gets the best big by far and allows Evan Turner to lead.  He's going to be a star, bumpy start be danged.

[action781]

http://www.realgm.com/src_tradechecker/3/

Atlanta gets Iggy, Speights, Holiday and Lou Williams 
Philly gets Horford, Bibby and Marvin Williams

Atlanta organizes themeselves a bit better and improves the backcourt.
Philly gives Evan Turner the ball (Bibby won't mind, he'll shoot a bunch of 3's)

Bibby, Turner, Marvin Williams, Horford, Brand
Thaddeus Young, Hawes, Nocioni, sign a backup PG.

Holiday, Iggy, Joe Johnson, Josh Smith, Pachulia
Speights, Lou Williams, Crawford, Collins, Powell (trade Teague, maybe to Philly)


Philly gives up more talent but gets the best big by far and allows Evan Turner to lead.  He's going to be a star, bumpy start be danged.

One thing I'll say about this is that if Pachulia was a stone defender and Josh Smith had a little more offensive game, Atlanta's starting lineup would resemble the 2008 Celtics a bit.

[Fafnir]

http://www.realgm.com/src_tradechecker/3/

Atlanta gets Iggy, Speights, Holiday and Lou Williams 
Philly gets Horford, Bibby and Marvin Williams

Atlanta organizes themeselves a bit better and improves the backcourt.
Philly gives Evan Turner the ball (Bibby won't mind, he'll shoot a bunch of 3's)

Bibby, Turner, Marvin Williams, Horford, Brand
Thaddeus Young, Hawes, Nocioni, sign a backup PG.

Holiday, Iggy, Joe Johnson, Josh Smith, Pachulia
Speights, Lou Williams, Crawford, Collins, Powell (trade Teague, maybe to Philly)


Philly gives up more talent but gets the best big by far and allows Evan Turner to lead.  He's going to be a star, bumpy start be danged.

One thing I'll say about this is that if Pachulia was a stone defender and Josh Smith had a little more offensive game, Atlanta's starting lineup would resemble the 2008 Celtics a bit.

Except that Josh Smith is not the same sort of consistent defensive factor that KG is/was.

Pachulia is just bad.

[Donoghus]

Atlanta would be nuts to give up Horford in this trade.  Their frontcourt just got more thin.  I don't see why they'd pull the trigger on this.