Average (at best) point guard skills, and has virtually no chance of becoming a legitimate consistent scorer.
His defense and passing are pretty good, and both are positional skills, so go back to the drawing board on that one. Yes, his offense is poor, but they do not have a measurable stat for winning plays that Marcus makes time and time again.
I don't expect him to score, anything he gives in that regard is a bonus.
The one thing he does best, is make his team mates play harder.
Does he ever make "losing plays" , do other players on the team make "winning plays" or is just Marcus?
Two things I will agree about Marcus. He does seem to propel some of his teammates to play harder.
He also is a decent passer.
He is a good player to start a few games when things are going bad. Good jump star so to speak.
Things I think are completely FALSE imo is when the team starts playing well, people will always point to Marcus being the catalyst. It can never be the team just playing well. It has to be Smart's "heart" that is the reason.
Smart also isnt as good as a defender as people thing. He can make defensive plays, and he can annoy the hell out of a player for a good 3 minute stretch. Hes done that to Curry , Klay, hes good at that, but he cannot stay in front of guys as good as people think, and he has gotten lit up many times by quick guards. Although who hasnt got lit up no matter how good a defender you are in todays NBA.
Hes an important part of the team it seems, and thats enough for me , im not in that locker room, so my opinion is worthless if i have to tell people that he isnt this or that.