I would take him over PJ in a heartbeat. I think he has way more potential than Thomas Robinson and possibly Austin Rivers. Maybe better than Noah Vonleh or Mason Plumlee.
I couldn't disagree more. Plumlee has already proven he's better. Vonleh is 19 years old and was injured for most of his rookie season...and he projects to be way better than Bennett.
Bennett ? Well he's just.... absolutely..... terrible.
Wait a second. Plumlee came out after his senior year. He had a fine rookie year, then plateaued. Vonleh....I don't see why he got a free pass for being 19 and injured when that's exactly what Bennet did.
Let me help.
1 - PhysicalsVonleh (6'9", 247 lbs, 7'4" wingspan) has good-to-elite physical attributes for an NBA Power Forward. There have been a number of of guys who have come into the NBA with Vonleh's size (Dwight Howard, Carlos Boozer, David West, Zach Randolph, etc) and have gone on t o became All-Star caliber Power Forwards.
Bennett (6'7", 239 lbs, 7'1" wingspan) has mediocre-to-average physical attributes for an NBA Power Forward. I can only really think of one guy (Paul Milsap) who has been in the NBA in the last 10 years or so with similar physical attributes who has gone on to become an All-Star caliber PF. The next best examples I can think of are Josh Smith (who's athleticism makes this comparison invalid) and Bass (who has been, at best, a borderline starter his whole career).
Fact is, Anthony Bennett has the play style of Carlos Boozer with the physical attributes of Paul Pierce, and that is a combination that rarely works out in the NBA.
2 - OpportunityOur own bigs (Sully and Olynyk) both sucked when they first stepped on an NBA floor, and it wasn't until around midway through their rookie years (about 600 minutes in) that they started to find their comfort zone and started to really show they could make an impact in the NBA.
Bennett has played over 100 games and 1,500 minutes in the NBA, so he has had had more than enough opportunity to adjust to the NBA game and to prove he can play, but so far he's proven nothing.
Vonleh has played only 25 games and just over 250 minutes in the NBA, which is nowhere near enough time to judge him on. He still deserves at least another 300 - 400 minutes in the NBA before we start to judge him.
You can make the same argument for James Young I know, but the difference is that Young even sucked against Summer League competition, whereas Vonleh (17 / 9 / 1 in 29 minutes, along with 55% FG, 50% 3PT and 78% FT) dominated Summer League.