Author Topic: Roster composition  (Read 5804 times)

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

Roster composition
« on: August 08, 2014, 09:43:14 AM »

Offline OhioGreen

  • Jaylen Brown
  • Posts: 686
  • Tommy Points: 55
Just some thoughts on the direction I would like to see the C's go in this year regarding their roster!

These guys are players that need to go.  They're players who either have some trade value, are veterans that are holding up younger players, or players who are pretty much irrelevant to are team(or a combination).  Get what you can for them! Picks or players with 2 yrs or less in the league, that show SOME potential.

Rondo
Green
Bass
Wallace
Thornton
Anthony
Bogans

The next group is our keepers(for this year, anyway).  They all have four or less years in the league, and have some to major upside to possibly reach!

Zeller
Sully
KO
Turner
AB
Smart
Young
Pressey
Vitor
CJohnson
Babb

The last group is players not on the roster that I'd like to see with the team this year.  They all have potential, and/or fit a need for the team this year.

Dairus Bertans
Mike Moser
Colton Iverson

The last two groups would give us 14 players, so with trades from the first group they could all not make the roster---so---the final group is in order the players I would eliminate to make room for additions:

Babb
Iverson
CJohnson
Pressey
Vitor

It would make us very young, but intriguing to watch.  They would not be very good, record wise, but that is the direction we want, no---improve, collect more assets, and be in good draft position to use our current wealth of picks!
You just know that if the Rondo's, Wallace's, Thorton's, and Bass's are still on this team that BS is going to play them major minutes, and that's the thing about rebuilding I hate.
Guys like Sully and Zeller are going into their third years and it's where players usually make big leaps in their careers---if they're ever going to.  Excited to see how they play.  Could Sully be the perennial allstar in the making, right before our eyes?  Even KO, when you look at his first year, had a truly GOOD year, comparing it to other stars first seasons!
Anyway, just some of my thoughts on another slow offseason day!



Re: Roster composition
« Reply #1 on: August 08, 2014, 10:18:49 AM »

Offline slamtheking

  • NCE
  • Walter Brown
  • ********************************
  • Posts: 32970
  • Tommy Points: 10176
My 2 cents: looks like a knee-jerk "toss almost everyone who's not on a rookie deal and keep everyone who is or was recently signed".  bad approach

First, Rondo.  He's a keeper.  period.  all the trades being kicked around are trying to bring in players of his caliber.  we already have one such player.  smart move is to keep him.

No issue with trying to move the mediocre players on the roster.  easier said than done at this point.
Green, Bass, Wallace, Thornton, Anthony, Turner
All guys that will either be off the books after this year or next.  No real building blocks but guys that could be valuable to a contender at the deadline looking for that final piece of the puzzle OR as salary filler in a deal to bring in a really good player.
No real crisis if they can't be traded.  Just accept the cap relief as it becomes available if that's the case. 

Bogans, Babb, CJ.
non-guaranteed deals to hopefully be used to facilitate a deal for a good player.  players to be cut before the season in a worst-case scenario.  Bogans will never wear green again and Babb/CJ have many better players ahead of them on the depth chart now.  they won't be on the opening roster

Youth to develop:
Zeller, Sully, KO, AB, Smart, Young, Pressey, Vitor
Vitor and Pressey would be a stretch at this point to expect big improvements.  if they're even here for the season opener, their playing time this year will be limited.  Young will most likely spend the year in Maine developing.  while I like these guys, I don't see an all-star here and would be open to trading them if it brought in someone better.

and this part - ugh
"The last group is players not on the roster that I'd like to see with the team this year.  They all have potential, and/or fit a need for the team this year."
Dairus Bertans
Mike Moser
Colton Iverson
-->um, these guys are scrubs.  was hoping Iverson would show he could be a backup for this year but he was awful in summer league.  I expect he'll be back in Europe this year and the C's to eventually cut ties with him.  The other 2 are D-leaguers that should not make this roster.  Why you think they're deserving of a roster spot is beyond me.  what need to they fill--player not dressed for game?


Re: Roster composition
« Reply #2 on: August 08, 2014, 11:34:23 AM »

Offline OhioGreen

  • Jaylen Brown
  • Posts: 686
  • Tommy Points: 55
Don't think it's knee jerk at all.  It's pretty apparent, unless DA does something miraculous in the next month or so, that this is going to be another "lost season"!  While I don't suggest just giving our decent vets away, what is the point of keeping them on the roster?  Win a handful more games? Take playing time away from our youngsters! 
They're good players on a contending team---not ours currently!  RR surrounded by two or three other allstars would be awesome---but not on our team.  MSmart is not a 2, and trying to play him a little here and a little there between 1 and 2 just makes his transition more difficult!  Give him the reigns and let him go!

I would agree on Bogans and Babb, but believe CJ is worth a spot!

On a completely rebuilding team, as I suggest, Moser and Iverson are worth a shot.  Iverson doesn't have much upside, but he's a BIG boy and loves to bang, something we are in short supply of!  With Moser you roll the dice, and maybe they come up looking good.

Bertans, is where I really disagree.  He looks very much like a player!  International experience and very composed!  Good shooter!  Of all the non roster players and quite a few of the marginal roster guys, he's one I think we should really sign!















Re: Roster composition
« Reply #3 on: August 08, 2014, 12:41:58 PM »

Offline slamtheking

  • NCE
  • Walter Brown
  • ********************************
  • Posts: 32970
  • Tommy Points: 10176
what you call a 'lost' season is what I call a developmental year where the team helps its young players develop and improves itself either by acquiring better player, better trade assets and/or better cap/financial flexibility.  If NONE of that occurs, then I'd agree it was a lost year.  I suspect at a minimum the young players will develop and 1-2 trades will occur that will improve the cap and either add to the current arsenal of trade assets or improve the financial flexibility of the team going forward.

couldn't disagree more on your desire to trade Rondo.  only reason to do that is to go into full tank mode and race Philly to the bottom of the standings.  why unload the one player on the roster that actually is the quality of player you're hoping to bring in?  rather pointless from where I stand.

I like CJ but the kid's D-league level player.  he started off well last year then fizzled.  wish him well but time to move on. Besides, answer this--in your move to get young players playing time to develop, who would you take minutes away from to give to CJ?  Smart? AB, Young? Turner?  Pressey?  all 5 ahead of CJ on the depth chart and all, except Turner, could use the playing time to develop since, in your own words, they're "keepers".  CJ should never see the court and I wouldn't tie up a roster spot for a guy that could be replaced by a half dozen other guys out of the d-league or went undrafted this year.

Same issue with Moser--kid is D-league material and shouldn't see the court.  Bertans too.  which better player are you proposing to take playing time from to watch a guy that shouldn't be on an NBA roster much less an NBA team's playing rotation?

You're swapping out proven NBA players for guys that shouldn't be in the NBA.  I don't get this mentality.  I'm all for trading the role-player quality vets if a deal beneficial to the C's comes along but not for the sake of filling their roster spot with D-league scrubs.

Iverson is a summer league disappointment.  was rooting for him to show he was ready to be a back up but he looks like anything but.  no spot for him.  you even advocate dumping.  not sure why you're advocating dumping Fav when he's shown a little something when given playing time.  particularly since you want to fill his spot with a scrub.

Re: Roster composition
« Reply #4 on: August 08, 2014, 02:53:43 PM »

Offline OhioGreen

  • Jaylen Brown
  • Posts: 686
  • Tommy Points: 55
Slam, to reply to each comment:

Your first point is, I believe, just semantics.  I said in my OP that the year would be to improve, collect assets, and position to be able to use our hoard of picks to good advantage.  We just said basically the same, differently.

I'm actually ambivalent on Rondo.  If I KNEW Danny could pull off the big deal at the trade deadline, or next off season, I'd be alright with keeping him.  I know it only takes one other GM to tango, but he just can't seem to get that big one done!  Keeping RR around "just incase" we can make a move to put a couple of superstars around him------well the odds just seem stacked against it.  I think it's RR or Smart at PG! Get rid of Rondo, and start new, or get rid of Smart and other young players, and try to build something quickly and beat your brains out butting heads with the Cavs and Bulls for the next 3-5 years.
We really don't know what Danny is thinking, so we're all just throwin' stuff out there!

On CJ----hey you gotta fill out a roster, and I see many a player on other teams that hustle alot less, and shoot alot worse than him.  I also mentioned he'd be one of the players I would let go if something better was acquired!

Moser looked intriguing in SL.  Bertans, is proven international talent!  I'm not saying he'd be a star, but looks like a guy who contribute right away and he's only 24!

Lastly, CI is a big physical guy that we don't have now!  He's got the size to bang with anyone and loves to do it!  As an end of the bench third string C, I think he' be OK!  And never did I advocate dumping Vitor, as he' be my backup C after Zeller----again at the end I said unless through trade we'd acquire something better!

Re: Roster composition
« Reply #5 on: August 08, 2014, 06:56:33 PM »

Offline Jailan34

  • Jaylen Brown
  • Posts: 721
  • Tommy Points: 30
I think we all agree Rondo is the type of player we are hoping Ainge brings in, except he's too old. Rondonis in the middle of his prime and we in all likelihood won't be contending for 3 years. Rondo would be over 30 at that time and we don't know how his game will hold up with age, while he will always be an effective passer his production and athletisicm will have taken a noticeable hit. Which is why many fans would like to see him moved for some kind of young player or picks.
You can't reason someone out of a position they didn't reason themselves into.

Re: Roster composition
« Reply #6 on: August 08, 2014, 07:48:45 PM »

Offline Future Celtics Owner

  • Ray Allen
  • ***
  • Posts: 3097
  • Tommy Points: 191
  • Celtic's only raise championship Banners
I was always optimistic about keeping Rondo, even though there is a chance he takes more money in FA. But when we drafted Smart my gut told me that was the last straw and Rondo would at some point be traded. The only thing...theres not a lot out there to trade him for.

Re: Roster composition
« Reply #7 on: August 08, 2014, 07:49:10 PM »

Offline mgent

  • Tiny Archibald
  • *******
  • Posts: 7567
  • Tommy Points: 1962

Lastly, CI is a big physical guy that we don't have now!  He's got the size to bang with anyone and loves to do it!  As an end of the bench third string C, I think he' be OK!  And never did I advocate dumping Vitor, as he' be my backup C after Zeller----again at the end I said unless through trade we'd acquire something better!
Don't forget Joel Anthony.  I think it's extremely unlikely we enter the season with 1 backup C (Zeller) and 3 different third string Centers on top of Sully and Olynyk who will probably eat all the Center minutes.  With our injury luck it wouldn't be the worst idea, but I don't expect Iverson to make the team over Pressey and Bogans.
Philly:

Anderson Varejao    Tiago Splitter    Matt Bonner
David West    Kenyon Martin    Brad Miller
Andre Iguodala    Josh Childress    Marquis Daniels
Dwyane Wade    Leandro Barbosa
Kirk Hinrich    Toney Douglas   + the legendary Kevin McHale

Re: Roster composition
« Reply #8 on: August 08, 2014, 08:22:38 PM »

Offline cletus1985

  • Jayson Tatum
  • Posts: 822
  • Tommy Points: 408
I understand why people want to go full blown youth movement and get them time on the court to see what they've got and learn in action, but the reality becomes negative. The veterans want to win and keep the youngins focused. Also they teach them so much through practice and sharing experiences and knowledge. If you gut the roster of your vets you'll end up seeing playground basketball with a group of guys that learn to accept losing as their reality and become selfish worrying about stats and trying to up their value for a big payday.

You have to have veteran warriors who don't accept losing and will battle for wins even though they don't have the talent the other teams do. Young players follow leaders and try to improve and give their all for vets with that attitude, but if you take it all away and let them determine how things should be you'll end up like the Sixers last year, no heart, no passion, and MCW putting up inefficient gaudy numbers at the expense of cohesion to up his value in the league.

I for one would rather see them fight to win, and try to prove to the vets that they belong and strive to get better. Although there are definitely some vets that could go if we were able to get any value for them, I don't think shipping them all out helps the rebuild process at all.

Re: Roster composition
« Reply #9 on: August 09, 2014, 12:29:26 AM »

Offline Future Celtics Owner

  • Ray Allen
  • ***
  • Posts: 3097
  • Tommy Points: 191
  • Celtic's only raise championship Banners
I don't think it helps to get rid of EVERY SINGLE VETERAN.

I know we just signed Avery but I kinda like this starting lineup:

Marcus Smart
Evan Turner
Jeff Green
Sully
KO

I think that would be a fun lineup to watch.

Re: Roster composition
« Reply #10 on: August 09, 2014, 03:10:04 PM »

Offline Csfan1984

  • Don Nelson
  • ********
  • Posts: 8919
  • Tommy Points: 291
Well the roster has a lot of playoff type players and also youth with growing players. Biggest issue is the highest caliber player is a 3 option go to guy in Rondo. We don't have a elite 1 or 2 scoring option. Nor does the team have a game changing defender. And on top of that there are FG%, FT%, TO%, REB#s and 3FG% issues with a large portion of the roster. A lot of the guys have gaping holes in their game.

That said I look at each guy in 3 terms. Term 1 player is a Building, Playoffs, Building/Playoffs, or Outside 10th Man Rotation (O10MR). Term 2 is playing time left or years till developed for a run. Term 3 is player role level on a team (ie is he franchise 1 player, a solid 2 guy, or a 3rd/4th option).

PGs
Rondo= Playoffs, 4-6 year run, 3 option player but 2 level with elite scorers.
Smart= Building, 3 years away,  5 option that projects to a 2nd option.
Pressey=O10MR, 1 year run, Roster filler

SGs
AB= Building/Playoffs, 6-10 year run, 5th option that is better in a six man type role.
Thorton= Playoffs, 2-4 year run, 7/8th guy. A okay off the bench player.
Young= Building, 3 years away, 8/9th guy now. Projects to a 3 option/good scoring player.
Bogans=O10MR, 0 year run, Cap asset.

SFs
Green= Playoffs, 4-6 year run, 4th option player
Turner= Building/Playoffs, 6-10 year run, 6th man. 3rd/4th option possibly if develops.
CJ= O10MR, 1 year run, Roster filler
Babb= O10MR, 0 year run, Roster filler?
Wallace= O10MR, 0 year run, Cap asset next year

Bigs
Sully= Building/Playoffs, 6-10 year, 5th option, Projects 4th option.
Bass= Playoffs, 3-5 year run, 7/8th guy. A okay player off the bench.
Olynyk= Building, 2 years away, 7/8th guy, Projects to 4th option.
Zeller= Building, 1 year away, 7/8th guy, Projects to 5th option.
Anthony= O10MR, 1 year run, Roster filler.
Fav= O10MR, 0 year run, Roster filler.
Iverson=O10MR, 1 year run, May crack the roster be default.

C's best established and potential player are both at PG. Overall there is way too many bench types and 4/5th option guys. There is no #1 guy and looks like C's are three or four years away from developing an impact player to help Rondo.

Re: Roster composition
« Reply #11 on: August 09, 2014, 05:20:42 PM »

Offline freshinthehouse

  • Don Chaney
  • *
  • Posts: 1629
  • Tommy Points: 159
I like what you are going for Ohio Green, but I think we need to keep at least one good locker room vet on the team.  Even if it is a guy that doesn't see the court, I think the kids need an example guy who can show them what kind of preparation and dedication you need to have a successful career in the NBA.  A good example is Kevin Ollie on those early OKC teams.  Durant still talks about how much he helped that team grow and mature, even though he rarely saw the court.

Re: Roster composition
« Reply #12 on: August 11, 2014, 09:09:07 PM »

Offline Surferdad

  • Reggie Lewis
  • ***************
  • Posts: 15299
  • Tommy Points: 1039
  • "He fiddles...and diddles..."
Just some thoughts on the direction I would like to see the C's go in this year regarding their roster!

These guys are players that need to go.  They're players who either have some trade value, are veterans that are holding up younger players, or players who are pretty much irrelevant to are team(or a combination).  Get what you can for them! Picks or players with 2 yrs or less in the league, that show SOME potential.

Rondo
Green
Bass
Wallace
Thornton
Anthony
Bogans

The next group is our keepers(for this year, anyway).  They all have four or less years in the league, and have some to major upside to possibly reach!

Zeller
Sully
KO
Turner
AB
Smart
Young
Pressey
Vitor
CJohnson
Babb

The last group is players not on the roster that I'd like to see with the team this year.  They all have potential, and/or fit a need for the team this year.

Dairus Bertans
Mike Moser
Colton Iverson

The last two groups would give us 14 players, so with trades from the first group they could all not make the roster---so---the final group is in order the players I would eliminate to make room for additions:

Babb
Iverson
CJohnson
Pressey
Vitor

It would make us very young, but intriguing to watch.  They would not be very good, record wise, but that is the direction we want, no---improve, collect more assets, and be in good draft position to use our current wealth of picks!
You just know that if the Rondo's, Wallace's, Thorton's, and Bass's are still on this team that BS is going to play them major minutes, and that's the thing about rebuilding I hate.
Guys like Sully and Zeller are going into their third years and it's where players usually make big leaps in their careers---if they're ever going to.  Excited to see how they play.  Could Sully be the perennial allstar in the making, right before our eyes?  Even KO, when you look at his first year, had a truly GOOD year, comparing it to other stars first seasons!
Anyway, just some of my thoughts on another slow offseason day!
Nice post, one problem:  without knowing who is coming back for all those "tradeable" assets, there is no way to comment. Frankly I think you just want to tank for another year.

Re: Roster composition
« Reply #13 on: August 11, 2014, 09:25:44 PM »

Offline Jailan34

  • Jaylen Brown
  • Posts: 721
  • Tommy Points: 30
Just some thoughts on the direction I would like to see the C's go in this year regarding their roster!

These guys are players that need to go.  They're players who either have some trade value, are veterans that are holding up younger players, or players who are pretty much irrelevant to are team(or a combination).  Get what you can for them! Picks or players with 2 yrs or less in the league, that show SOME potential.

Rondo
Green
Bass
Wallace
Thornton
Anthony
Bogans

The next group is our keepers(for this year, anyway).  They all have four or less years in the league, and have some to major upside to possibly reach!

Zeller
Sully
KO
Turner
AB
Smart
Young
Pressey
Vitor
CJohnson
Babb

The last group is players not on the roster that I'd like to see with the team this year.  They all have potential, and/or fit a need for the team this year.

Dairus Bertans
Mike Moser
Colton Iverson

The last two groups would give us 14 players, so with trades from the first group they could all not make the roster---so---the final group is in order the players I would eliminate to make room for additions:

Babb
Iverson
CJohnson
Pressey
Vitor

It would make us very young, but intriguing to watch.  They would not be very good, record wise, but that is the direction we want, no---improve, collect more assets, and be in good draft position to use our current wealth of picks!
You just know that if the Rondo's, Wallace's, Thorton's, and Bass's are still on this team that BS is going to play them major minutes, and that's the thing about rebuilding I hate.
Guys like Sully and Zeller are going into their third years and it's where players usually make big leaps in their careers---if they're ever going to.  Excited to see how they play.  Could Sully be the perennial allstar in the making, right before our eyes?  Even KO, when you look at his first year, had a truly GOOD year, comparing it to other stars first seasons!
Anyway, just some of my thoughts on another slow offseason day!
Nice post, one problem:  without knowing who is coming back for all those "tradeable" assets, there is no way to comment. Frankly I think you just want to tank for another year.

Nothing wrong with a player development season, the team tried the quick rebuild and it didn't work out. Trade Bass, let our young guys play and develop.
You can't reason someone out of a position they didn't reason themselves into.

Re: Roster composition
« Reply #14 on: August 11, 2014, 09:58:15 PM »

Offline Vermont Green

  • Cedric Maxwell
  • **************
  • Posts: 14281
  • Tommy Points: 1053
Most of the players mentioned as needing to go are expiring contracts.  Rondo, Green (by virtue of player option), Thornton, Bass, and Anthony are all expiring and total about $41M.  I think it is very likely that none of these players will resign with the Celtics after what is likely another bad, rebuilding season.

So there are two options; one is let them all expire and plan to sign other better FAs to replace them.  Or you trade some or all and get what you can.  I don't think the prospect of attracting or retaining FAs is going to be very good after this coming season (rock).  I also think that for the most part (excepting Rondo), the trade value of the group is pretty low (hard place).

So by my calculation, the best bet is to trade Rondo (since we can actually get something for him) and let the rest expire since what we would get back probably is not going to be all that good anyway.  I guess DA will try to trade any of them as he should but no trades just to trade.

I think Evan Turner is a good example of a low cost, short term contract player with some potential upside.  Trading for that type of situation would be fine with the Bass/Thornton/Anthony contracts but I don't see that many cases for that type of trade.  Rondo should be able to get us some decent value back and Green somewhere in the middle.