d. Kevin O'Conner has studied Saric quite a bit, and has a considerably higher opinion than you, Roy, of Saric's current skill set, on both sides of the ball. I know he is no Bird, but you seem to be very skeptical of Saric's prospects. Wondering why.
Kevin's just one of many, many amateurs with an opinion.
I think skeptical is the right word. Every year, there are a few guys who play against inferior competition who always seem to shoot up draft boards. What's the success rate on foreign players who haven't played in the NCAA since, say, the Darko draft?
2003 - Darko (bust), Pietrus (solid), Cabarkapa (bust), Pavlovic (disappointment), Pavlovic (bust), Barbosa (solid)
2004 - Podkolzine (bust), Khryapa (bust), Monia (bust), Vujacic (solid), Udrih (solid)
2005 - Vazquez (bust), Korolev (bust), Petro (disappointment), Mahinmi (solid)
2006 - Bargnani (disappointment), Sene (bust), Pecherov (bust), Freeland (solid)
2007 - Jianlian (bust), Bellinelli (solid), Fernandez (disappointment), Splitter (solid), Koponen (bust)
2008 - Gallinari (solid), Ajinca (disappointment), Ibaka (star), Batum (solid)
2009 - Rubio (solid), Claver (bust), Casspi (disappointment), Beaubois (bust)
2010 - Seraphin (disappointment)
2011 - Valanciunas (TBD), Vesely (bust), Biyombo (disappointment), Motiejunas (disappointment), Mirotic (TBD)
2012 - Fournier (TBD)
2013 - Adetokoubo (TBD, looks good), Nogueira (TBD), Schroeder (TBD), Karasev (TBD), Gobert (TBD), Jean-Charles (TBD), Nedovic (TBD)
In the last 11 years, that's 46 foreign players taken in the first round. None have been all-stars, and only three have been above-average: Ibaka, Gallinari and Batum.
So, part of my skepticism comes from the track record, and the failure of scouting. The other part comes from Saric's game: he appears too slow to be a SF, and too weak to be a PF. He's not a great outside shooter, he's not particularly athletic, and he turns the ball over too much. In the Eurocup, against mediocre competition, he was mediocre. He shined in the Adriatic league, but that's the 9th best league in Europe, and beneath the quality of the NCAA.
Until I see him prove himself regularly against decent competition, I will continue to be a skeptic. I think the hype is much too high.