Thing is I am still not 100% convinced Harden is superstar. He might be All-Star good but not superstar good.
Yeah, that is where I would rate Harden. As such, I think he's worth the max.
All-Star caliber player and quality building block but not a franchise player / superstar.
Well they've got Durant for that already, and Westbrook (maybe) so no reason not to pay Harden unless you can't hack the tax.
I agree. You also have to look at it from a VORPish (Value Over Replacement Player, to steal from baseball) perspective.
If they can truly get great value for him in a trade, maybe things change. But right now they'll probably get something less than him (given that teams know their situation) or they potentially lose him in for nothing in free agency, and be left trying to replace him with an MLE player.
So yes, I agree that he's not worth max money in the grand scheme of things, but given what OKC already has, I think it's worth it.