The great thing about James is that he can fit with either of my preferred MLE choices: Mike Miller or Tyrus Thomas. The Miller/James combo greatly boosts our offensive potency while significantly bolstering our defensive rebounding. James/Thomas provides a massive boost to our latent transition game, rebounding and defensive pressure/endurance.
Do you think there is any playing time for James if the Celtics sign Mike Miller?
It's hard to see James getting any court time once Ray, Paul and Miller get theirs ... 5-10 minutes in the regular season but once the playoffs begins it's hard to see James getting on the court.
On another note, it would be interesting to let Ray leave and go big on the wing with Miller, Pierce and James. That would be a big boost to the club's rebounding. An excellent rebounding PG + excellent rebounding SG + excellent rebounding backup wing + a good rebounding backup PG (Nate) and excellent rebounding backup guard (TA). That would be a huge amount of rebounding help from the perimeter players.
Good shooting (Miller, Pierce, James, Nate = 4/6 of the main rotation players) and defensive contributions too (Rondo, Pierce, James, TA = 4/6ths). Although, Pierce would have to take more defensive responsibilities to make for Mike Miller's lack of defensive play which would tire him out more than with Ray(dodgy stamina already). Still, it is a very interesting balance of skills (without Ray Allen).
I think of James as more of a 4 with Mike Miller and more of a 3 with Ty Thomas.
He has the capability of earning minutes at either position. His length (his standing reach is comparable to those of the "legit" 4s in the draft: Ed Davis, Patrick Patterson and Ekpe Udoh), hops and rebounding ability make him a better option at the 4 than Sheed or Baby, who are better suited to playing the 5 anyway. I think the rotation could evolve into something similar to what we saw in 08/09, where Posey, Powe, Davis and Scal all got minutes at the 4 depending on the match-up. I'm confident that James would rise to pre-eminence at the back-up 4 spot by the playoffs, thanks to his transition game, his range shooting and his general hustle.
My ideal rotation would be the existing starting 5, with 6 bench roles: scoring from the point (Nate), lockdown defense from the wing (TA), shooting from the wing (either Miller or James), athleticism/rebounding at the 4 (James or Thomas), perimeter shooting from the 4/5 (Sheed) and extra beef, i.e. an additional capable 4/5 available in times of injury or foul trouble (Baby).
So essentially, James would get Baby's (or I guess Sheed's) minutes in the Miller scenario and Finley's minutes plus some of Ray/Pierce's in the Thomas scenario.
Of final note, I agree it would be interesting to outright replace Ray Allen with Miller, but as long as ownership is willing to spend on both, I'd much rather have both. The combination of Ray and Miller would propel us back to the heights our offense achieved in 2009 with Ray and Eddie as two game-changers from deep.