It's simply not true that Murray at his best has been better than White at his best. Murray had never orchestrated or participated in a high level offense. He only knows how to get his stats as fake-star, and as a result his teams struggle to win games because he?s not good enough.
Meanwhile White has been on multiple all defensive teams, including a first team last year. He?s widely recognized my players as one of the most underrated players in the league, and has participated in Olympic ball because of it.
I agree. I don't think D Murray has ever reached the heights that Derrick White has done.
Dejounte Murray is one of those players that makes a lot of positive contributions to his team but also a lot of negative contributions so his net contribution is lower than raw stats suggest.
D White is the opposite. A low mistake player. He makes a good amount of positive contributions but his main asset is that he makes little negative contributions. Almost everything he does is additive. Or at least it was when he was regularly hitting his 3 pointers. His net contribution has been higher than Murray while D White was at his peak here in Boston.
D Murray's has never had a great peak. His inability to shoot throughout most of his career has dogged his offensive contributions. He not only can't shoot well but he is a high volume shooter. Or at least he was in the past. If he accepted being a 13-14ppg scorer, he would be more valuable than trying to be a 17-20ppg guy.
He is useless off the ball in the offense. He is only valuable when he has the ball in his hands and is creating for others. However, due to his bad shooting and shot happy ways, he would never be a primary creator for a high quality team because there would be better players around him who will command the ball (like Tatum here).
D Murray was a high level defender when he played the PG position back in San Antonio. However, in Atlanta, when he had his best shooting seasons, he was moved off ball to SG where he was at best an average defensive player. So his best defensive seasons and his best offensive seasons never lined up in the same years. And he has been injured most of the time in New Orleans.
I don't think Murray has ever been a top 10 PG or top 10 SG. I don't think he was ever even a top 15 PG or top 15 SG. I'd probably have him in the 15-20 range.
D White has been a top 10 SG here in Boston. The PG position is stacked so not a top 10 PG but in that 10-15 range yes.