Author Topic: Bill Simmons' trade target  (Read 2320 times)

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

Re: Bill Simmons' trade target
« Reply #30 on: Today at 11:15:16 AM »

Offline DefenseWinsChamps

  • Tiny Archibald
  • *******
  • Posts: 7318
  • Tommy Points: 875
I think the guy we need to target is Naz Reid. Not only is his contract better, but I think he is the better player. I?d rather give up what the Pelicans are asking for Murphy to the Hornets for Naz.

I?ve always loved his on court play. I?m a bit worried that the Wolves traded him for some unsaid interpersonal reason, and that those same issues are coming up in Charlotte. But if he is a good guy in an otherwise bad Charlotte situation, he?d be an awesome fit. We need a guy who is just a touch selfish offensively.

Re: Bill Simmons' trade target
« Reply #31 on: Today at 11:28:19 AM »

Offline Vermont Green

  • Reggie Lewis
  • ***************
  • Posts: 15848
  • Tommy Points: 1135
Yeah, I get it, you can call it whatever you want, but if White is your only ball handler on the court, and your wings are Murphy, George, and Tatum, I don't think that is ideal.  It would better if your lone ball handler was more of a Brunson type player, but I don't think White would thrive in that role.  White's production and efficiency have dropped since he was forced into being the lone ball handler on the court more often.  It can be fine to play 3 wings, but if all three are the same kind of big wing, it is not ideal even if your one ball handler is a true natural ball handler type.  If the 3 wings that BOS put out there were Murphy, George, Tatum, I think you would see Murphy's production and efficiency drop from what it is now playing on NOP, especially if White was the lone ball handler.

I think there is a difference between a guard type wing (I see Brown as an example of that) and a forward type wing (which I think all of Tatum, George, and Murphy are examples of).  And just like there were "tweeners" back when everyone was being fit into the traditional positions (a combo guard vs. a true PG or SG), now there are tweeners between being a true ball handler and a ture wing, which I think I think is the case with White.  Or between true wings and true bigs (maybe Randle is an example of this).

Re: Bill Simmons' trade target
« Reply #32 on: Today at 11:47:11 AM »

Online LilRip

  • Tiny Archibald
  • *******
  • Posts: 7106
  • Tommy Points: 422
Tatum, for better or worse, is our best ball handler and playmaker.

I honestly think a more effective way to deploy JT would be to move him off ball so he can get in easier positions to score, and he can create from there, but until we have a real playmaker (White is not it. Neither is Pritchard), I just don?t see it happening. And acquiring Murphy (or Reid) only puts more playmaking duties on JT, which again he is good at but I think he is a more gifted scorer than playmaker.
- LilRip

Re: Bill Simmons' trade target
« Reply #33 on: Today at 11:51:16 AM »

Offline Who

  • James Naismith
  • *********************************
  • Posts: 56016
  • Tommy Points: 2634
Yeah, I get it, you can call it whatever you want, but if White is your only ball handler on the court, and your wings are Murphy, George, and Tatum, I don't think that is ideal.  It would better if your lone ball handler was more of a Brunson type player, but I don't think White would thrive in that role.  White's production and efficiency have dropped since he was forced into being the lone ball handler on the court more often.  It can be fine to play 3 wings, but if all three are the same kind of big wing, it is not ideal even if your one ball handler is a true natural ball handler type.  If the 3 wings that BOS put out there were Murphy, George, Tatum, I think you would see Murphy's production and efficiency drop from what it is now playing on NOP, especially if White was the lone ball handler.

I think there is a difference between a guard type wing (I see Brown as an example of that) and a forward type wing (which I think all of Tatum, George, and Murphy are examples of).  And just like there were "tweeners" back when everyone was being fit into the traditional positions (a combo guard vs. a true PG or SG), now there are tweeners between being a true ball handler and a ture wing, which I think I think is the case with White.  Or between true wings and true bigs (maybe Randle is an example of this).

Tatum is a good enough ball-handler and playmaker to be the 2nd ball-handler on the floor. Then PG13 is 3rd ball-handler. Trey Murphy would be 4th.

Tatum is a good enough ball-handler and playmaker that the team does not require a ball-handling SG. They can cope just fine without one. We see that with Jordan Walsh, Sam Hauser, Hugo Gonzalez. Baylor offers a little ball-handling and passing but not much. Trey Murphy is an upgrade over the first 3 guys and maybe Baylor as well. Not as good a ball mover as Baylor but more comfortable attacking off the bounce.

I loved having two ball-handlers in the backcourt with Jrue and D White. It is still my first preference. But I don't see it as a necessity. And the reason for that is how good of a ball-handler & playmaker Tatum is.

Re: Bill Simmons' trade target
« Reply #34 on: Today at 12:07:56 PM »

Offline Who

  • James Naismith
  • *********************************
  • Posts: 56016
  • Tommy Points: 2634
I think the guy we need to target is Naz Reid. Not only is his contract better, but I think he is the better player. I?d rather give up what the Pelicans are asking for Murphy to the Hornets for Naz.

I?ve always loved his on court play. I?m a bit worried that the Wolves traded him for some unsaid interpersonal reason, and that those same issues are coming up in Charlotte. But if he is a good guy in an otherwise bad Charlotte situation, he?d be an awesome fit. We need a guy who is just a touch selfish offensively.

I don't think Naz Reid is anywhere near as good as Trey Murphy.

I rate Trey Murphy as a top 10 SF or thereabouts. I have Naz somewhere around 20th among PFs and lower in the 20-25 range among centers.

Trey Murphy is a quality two way player. An above average defender and a good to very good scorer. More of a 3rd option type of offensive threat. He is better off-ball than he is creating on-ball.

Minnesota's defenses would fall apart when Naz played center instead of Gobert. Naz is a low IQ team defender. This is why he is limited as a starting option at center. His team D is too poor. This is why he is better either as a 6th man or a PF next to a defensive center.

When Naz plays PF, his defense is adequate. Nothing more. He does better than average against bigger physical PFs but worse than average against all the other PFs in the league which is the majority. Again, his team D is only so-so and reliant on being protected by his center.

On offense, Naz is well above average for a center but much close to average at PF. His scoring repertoire, his shooting ability, his ability to put the ball on the floor and drive to the rim is extraordinary for a center. It is a major offensive advantage. However, at the PF position, it closer to the norm. Most PFs can do those things. And most PFs can also pass the ball at a higher level than Naz can. When he plays the PF, defenders are better equipped to cover him on the perimeter than when he is defended by opposing centers. He doesn't have as much of an advantage.

I agree with Naz as a good possible trade target for BOS. He could fit back into that 6th man role here. Maybe offer the team more than M Robinson will. Be an upgrade on M-Rob. But I do not see him anywhere near Trey Murphy.