Author Topic: Bill Simmons' trade target  (Read 2020 times)

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

Re: Bill Simmons' trade proposal
« Reply #15 on: November 19, 2026, 09:21:52 AM »

Offline LilRip

  • Tiny Archibald
  • *******
  • Posts: 7102
  • Tommy Points: 421
I would love to have Trey Murphy here alongside JT/PG. I would hate to give up Robinson though because even as bad as he has looked, we need size. I dont trust Garza at all.

I dont know what decent backup big is out there.
- LilRip

Re: Bill Simmons' trade proposal
« Reply #16 on: November 19, 2026, 12:35:07 PM »

Online DefenseWinsChamps

  • Tiny Archibald
  • *******
  • Posts: 7317
  • Tommy Points: 875
Simmons trade idea involved keeping all three centers.

It would have to be cobbled together with Hauser and a couple lower salary guys like Hugo, Baylor, Harper, or Cenac. Then Murphy is traded in to the TPE.

I'm too in on Hugo and Cenac to be ok trading either of those guys. But if it happened, I would talk myself into an ultra-long, switchy wing tandem that can all shoot.

Re: Bill Simmons' trade proposal
« Reply #17 on: November 19, 2026, 12:39:58 PM »

Offline Roy H.

  • Forums Manager
  • James Naismith
  • *********************************
  • Posts: 65389
  • Tommy Points: -25326
  • Optionality: Cope Springs Eternal
Simmons trade idea involved keeping all three centers.

It would have to be cobbled together with Hauser and a couple lower salary guys like Hugo, Baylor, Harper, or Cenac. Then Murphy is traded in to the TPE.

I'm too in on Hugo and Cenac to be ok trading either of those guys. But if it happened, I would talk myself into an ultra-long, switchy wing tandem that can all shoot.

I'm not sure if Simmons knows how trade / salary rules work, if that's the case.  That approach not only takes us well beyond the tax line, but it also is hard to do without exceeding the first apron.  One of the issues is that you're cobbling the salaries together with guys who make close to the minimum, but you still need to replace their roster spots without exceeding the first apron (we're hard-capped).
« Last Edit: November 19, 2026, 12:46:14 PM by Roy H. »
I'M THE SILVERBACK GORILLA IN THIS MOTHER... AND DON'T NONE OF YA'LL EVER FORGET IT!

Re: Bill Simmons' trade target
« Reply #18 on: November 19, 2026, 01:46:33 PM »

Online Vermont Green

  • Reggie Lewis
  • ***************
  • Posts: 15844
  • Tommy Points: 1135
I don't see that Simmons was proposing any specific trade at all.  Just kind of generally stating that it would be nice to get Trey Murphy.  We could offer Robinson + Hauser + Picks, but why would NOP do that?  Unless we included the PHI/LAC pick.

SF is not a position of need.  And I don't buy that Murphy, or Tatum or George can play SG, so I don't get what the #1 line up would be.  White, George, Murphy, Tatum, Queta?  That does not seem like a good fit to me.

I don't agree with Simmons that Murphy is the missing piece.  Tatum and George are the forwards.  Queta is the center.  White is one of the guards.  I think the missing piece is a combo guard, a Jrue Holiday type player.  More of a ball handler to take some of that load off White.  Not sure who that would be, but it isn't Trey Murphy.  I guess Dejounte Murray is more that type of player, just not as good a shooter.

Re: Bill Simmons' trade target
« Reply #19 on: November 19, 2026, 02:47:51 PM »

Offline Roy H.

  • Forums Manager
  • James Naismith
  • *********************************
  • Posts: 65389
  • Tommy Points: -25326
  • Optionality: Cope Springs Eternal

SF is not a position of need.  And I don't buy that Murphy, or Tatum or George can play SG, so I don't get what the #1 line up would be.  White, George, Murphy, Tatum, Queta?  That does not seem like a good fit to me.

I think he can play SG.  He's played it in New Orleans about 1/3 of the time.  His two most common lineups involve him sharing time with a player that would traditionally be considered a SF (Jones, Bey), and he's been good defensively there, so I wouldn't be worried. 

Our base lineup has Walsh-George-Tatum at the 2-4 spots.  I think Murphy can play SG better than any of those three.

I'M THE SILVERBACK GORILLA IN THIS MOTHER... AND DON'T NONE OF YA'LL EVER FORGET IT!

Re: Bill Simmons' trade target
« Reply #20 on: November 19, 2026, 03:16:47 PM »

Offline CFAN38

  • Rajon Rondo
  • *****
  • Posts: 5118
  • Tommy Points: 453
I don't see that Simmons was proposing any specific trade at all.  Just kind of generally stating that it would be nice to get Trey Murphy.  We could offer Robinson + Hauser + Picks, but why would NOP do that?  Unless we included the PHI/LAC pick.

SF is not a position of need.  And I don't buy that Murphy, or Tatum or George can play SG, so I don't get what the #1 line up would be.  White, George, Murphy, Tatum, Queta?  That does not seem like a good fit to me.

I don't agree with Simmons that Murphy is the missing piece.  Tatum and George are the forwards.  Queta is the center.  White is one of the guards.  I think the missing piece is a combo guard, a Jrue Holiday type player.  More of a ball handler to take some of that load off White.  Not sure who that would be, but it isn't Trey Murphy.  I guess Dejounte Murray is more that type of player, just not as good a shooter.


Staying out of the actual mechanics of the trade and just looking at the potential fit of Murphy. In modern basketball and particularly the NBA I have completely moved off of any concern over position. To me its less about 1,2,3,4,5 aka PG,SG,SF,PF,C and more just about primary and secondary creation, floor spacing, and cutting/diving to the rim. Defense is the side of the ball where the traditional positions still have some relevance but for a good team with versatile players it becomes a mute point.

If the Cs trade for and subsequently where to start White,George,Murphy,Tatum, and Queta that line up would have a Primary in JT and three capable secondary creators in White, Murphy and George. All three then provide various degrees of spacing off of Tatum and Queta is the dive man. On D I would have very little concern with that group.

Matching up to other East playoff teams I do not see any glaring matchup issues and depending on who is traded the Cs would likely still have two of the three young wings coming off the bench providing high level perimeter D.

If the speculated trade was Robinson+Hauser+Walsh for Murphy and D Jordan it would in many ways be a consolidation of Hauser and Walsh into Murphy whose skill set covers a lot of what both players provide. Loosing Robinson could prove a mistake come playoff time but Garza, Cenac, and Jordan could be serviceable and the trade would likely push Queta's minutes up.   




   
Mavs
Wiz
Hornet

Re: Bill Simmons' trade proposal
« Reply #21 on: November 19, 2026, 10:53:15 PM »

Online DefenseWinsChamps

  • Tiny Archibald
  • *******
  • Posts: 7317
  • Tommy Points: 875
Simmons trade idea involved keeping all three centers.

It would have to be cobbled together with Hauser and a couple lower salary guys like Hugo, Baylor, Harper, or Cenac. Then Murphy is traded in to the TPE.

I'm too in on Hugo and Cenac to be ok trading either of those guys. But if it happened, I would talk myself into an ultra-long, switchy wing tandem that can all shoot.

I'm not sure if Simmons knows how trade / salary rules work, if that's the case.  That approach not only takes us well beyond the tax line, but it also is hard to do without exceeding the first apron.  One of the issues is that you're cobbling the salaries together with guys who make close to the minimum, but you still need to replace their roster spots without exceeding the first apron (we're hard-capped).

It didn't look quite right to me either, but he wasn't suggesting Mitch Robinson in the trade.

I think giving up Robinson would be a mistake. We already saw that big rotation last year. I think you'd be banking on Queta taking another huge step forward and Cenac being able to give us some spot minutes.

I love Murphy. I love the three-headed combo of George-Tatum-Murphy. I love doubling down on the strengths of superstars on your team.

But I just don't see a way to do the trade that makes our team better. Maybe White and picks for Murphy, but then we lose our only defensive guard (all defensive first team guard) and 1 of our 2 main ball-handlers.

Re: Bill Simmons' trade proposal
« Reply #22 on: Yesterday at 10:07:11 PM »

Offline Larry for 3

  • Jaylen Brown
  • Posts: 616
  • Tommy Points: 51
  • Believe in Boston
Simmons trade idea involved keeping all three centers.

It would have to be cobbled together with Hauser and a couple lower salary guys like Hugo, Baylor, Harper, or Cenac. Then Murphy is traded in to the TPE.

I'm too in on Hugo and Cenac to be ok trading either of those guys. But if it happened, I would talk myself into an ultra-long, switchy wing tandem that can all shoot.

I'm not sure if Simmons knows how trade / salary rules work, if that's the case.  That approach not only takes us well beyond the tax line, but it also is hard to do without exceeding the first apron.  One of the issues is that you're cobbling the salaries together with guys who make close to the minimum, but you still need to replace their roster spots without exceeding the first apron (we're hard-capped).

It didn't look quite right to me either, but he wasn't suggesting Mitch Robinson in the trade.

I think giving up Robinson would be a mistake. We already saw that big rotation last year. I think you'd be banking on Queta taking another huge step forward and Cenac being able to give us some spot minutes.

I love Murphy. I love the three-headed combo of George-Tatum-Murphy. I love doubling down on the strengths of superstars on your team.

But I just don't see a way to do the trade that makes our team better. Maybe White and picks for Murphy, but then we lose our only defensive guard (all defensive first team guard) and 1 of our 2 main ball-handlers.

I hear ya but White is on the decline and it?s coming quick. Did you know this the 3rd straight year his 3 point percentage has gone down. He?s shooting 30 % form 3 this year. Not good. Did I mention he?s 32 years old? His value is dropping like a stone. If you can turn White into Murphy who?s on a great contract btw , you do it. Pritchard can handle the ball. You figure that part out.
"They forgot about Larry Bird"--- Danny Ainge, 1987

"What happened to the Lakers??!!"--- Wyc Grousbeck, 6/17/08

Re: Bill Simmons' trade proposal
« Reply #23 on: Yesterday at 10:33:57 PM »

Online DefenseWinsChamps

  • Tiny Archibald
  • *******
  • Posts: 7317
  • Tommy Points: 875
Simmons trade idea involved keeping all three centers.

It would have to be cobbled together with Hauser and a couple lower salary guys like Hugo, Baylor, Harper, or Cenac. Then Murphy is traded in to the TPE.

I'm too in on Hugo and Cenac to be ok trading either of those guys. But if it happened, I would talk myself into an ultra-long, switchy wing tandem that can all shoot.

I'm not sure if Simmons knows how trade / salary rules work, if that's the case.  That approach not only takes us well beyond the tax line, but it also is hard to do without exceeding the first apron.  One of the issues is that you're cobbling the salaries together with guys who make close to the minimum, but you still need to replace their roster spots without exceeding the first apron (we're hard-capped).

It didn't look quite right to me either, but he wasn't suggesting Mitch Robinson in the trade.

I think giving up Robinson would be a mistake. We already saw that big rotation last year. I think you'd be banking on Queta taking another huge step forward and Cenac being able to give us some spot minutes.

I love Murphy. I love the three-headed combo of George-Tatum-Murphy. I love doubling down on the strengths of superstars on your team.

But I just don't see a way to do the trade that makes our team better. Maybe White and picks for Murphy, but then we lose our only defensive guard (all defensive first team guard) and 1 of our 2 main ball-handlers.

I hear ya but White is on the decline and it?s coming quick. Did you know this the 3rd straight year his 3 point percentage has gone down. He?s shooting 30 % form 3 this year. Not good. Did I mention he?s 32 years old? His value is dropping like a stone. If you can turn White into Murphy who?s on a great contract btw , you do it. Pritchard can handle the ball. You figure that part out.

Except he was all-defensive 1st team last year. That was the best defensive accolade of his career. And that was in a year when more offense was put on him.

From what I've seen in the NBA, shooting normally isn't part of "decline." Shooting is the last thing that goes. Defense, rebounding, free throws, finishing all go, but not shooting.

Re: Bill Simmons' trade target
« Reply #24 on: Yesterday at 10:44:48 PM »

Online DefenseWinsChamps

  • Tiny Archibald
  • *******
  • Posts: 7317
  • Tommy Points: 875
Not sure most realize that Murphy is averaging 15ppg this year. He shoots a lot of threes, but is not a knock-down shooter. He's a good shooter, but not a great shooter.

Also, his defense is much more theoretical than it is actual. The idea of his length and switchiness is exciting. In reality he's much more like De'Andre Hunter than he is Miles Bridges.

I do think we need a 5th starter, but the combination of his salary, one-way play, and NOP's absurd asking price makes him very unlikely.

Re: Bill Simmons' trade proposal
« Reply #25 on: Yesterday at 11:59:14 PM »

Offline Goldstar88

  • JoJo White
  • ****************
  • Posts: 16322
  • Tommy Points: 1877
Simmons trade idea involved keeping all three centers.

It would have to be cobbled together with Hauser and a couple lower salary guys like Hugo, Baylor, Harper, or Cenac. Then Murphy is traded in to the TPE.

I'm too in on Hugo and Cenac to be ok trading either of those guys. But if it happened, I would talk myself into an ultra-long, switchy wing tandem that can all shoot.

I'm not sure if Simmons knows how trade / salary rules work, if that's the case.  That approach not only takes us well beyond the tax line, but it also is hard to do without exceeding the first apron.  One of the issues is that you're cobbling the salaries together with guys who make close to the minimum, but you still need to replace their roster spots without exceeding the first apron (we're hard-capped).

It didn't look quite right to me either, but he wasn't suggesting Mitch Robinson in the trade.

I think giving up Robinson would be a mistake. We already saw that big rotation last year. I think you'd be banking on Queta taking another huge step forward and Cenac being able to give us some spot minutes.

I love Murphy. I love the three-headed combo of George-Tatum-Murphy. I love doubling down on the strengths of superstars on your team.

But I just don't see a way to do the trade that makes our team better. Maybe White and picks for Murphy, but then we lose our only defensive guard (all defensive first team guard) and 1 of our 2 main ball-handlers.

I hear ya but White is on the decline and it?s coming quick. Did you know this the 3rd straight year his 3 point percentage has gone down. He?s shooting 30 % form 3 this year. Not good. Did I mention he?s 32 years old? His value is dropping like a stone. If you can turn White into Murphy who?s on a great contract btw , you do it. Pritchard can handle the ball. You figure that part out.

Except he was all-defensive 1st team last year. That was the best defensive accolade of his career. And that was in a year when more offense was put on him.

From what I've seen in the NBA, shooting normally isn't part of "decline." Shooting is the last thing that goes. Defense, rebounding, free throws, finishing all go, but not shooting.

White got absolutely torched by DeMar DeRozan the other day. it does look like he is on the decline.
Quoting Nick from the now locked Ime thread:
Quote
At some point you have to blame the performance on the court on the players on the court. Every loss is not the coach's fault and every win isn't because of the players.

Re: Bill Simmons' trade target
« Reply #26 on: Today at 09:01:59 AM »

Online Vermont Green

  • Reggie Lewis
  • ***************
  • Posts: 15844
  • Tommy Points: 1135
I don't see that Simmons was proposing any specific trade at all.  Just kind of generally stating that it would be nice to get Trey Murphy.  We could offer Robinson + Hauser + Picks, but why would NOP do that?  Unless we included the PHI/LAC pick.

SF is not a position of need.  And I don't buy that Murphy, or Tatum or George can play SG, so I don't get what the #1 line up would be.  White, George, Murphy, Tatum, Queta?  That does not seem like a good fit to me.

I don't agree with Simmons that Murphy is the missing piece.  Tatum and George are the forwards.  Queta is the center.  White is one of the guards.  I think the missing piece is a combo guard, a Jrue Holiday type player.  More of a ball handler to take some of that load off White.  Not sure who that would be, but it isn't Trey Murphy.  I guess Dejounte Murray is more that type of player, just not as good a shooter.

Staying out of the actual mechanics of the trade and just looking at the potential fit of Murphy. In modern basketball and particularly the NBA I have completely moved off of any concern over position. To me its less about 1,2,3,4,5 aka PG,SG,SF,PF,C and more just about primary and secondary creation, floor spacing, and cutting/diving to the rim. Defense is the side of the ball where the traditional positions still have some relevance but for a good team with versatile players it becomes a mute point.

If the Cs trade for and subsequently where to start White,George,Murphy,Tatum, and Queta that line up would have a Primary in JT and three capable secondary creators in White, Murphy and George. All three then provide various degrees of spacing off of Tatum and Queta is the dive man. On D I would have very little concern with that group.

Matching up to other East playoff teams I do not see any glaring matchup issues and depending on who is traded the Cs would likely still have two of the three young wings coming off the bench providing high level perimeter D.

If the speculated trade was Robinson+Hauser+Walsh for Murphy and D Jordan it would in many ways be a consolidation of Hauser and Walsh into Murphy whose skill set covers a lot of what both players provide. Loosing Robinson could prove a mistake come playoff time but Garza, Cenac, and Jordan could be serviceable and the trade would likely push Queta's minutes up.   

I get what you are saying about the traditional positions, and I don't disagree, I just look at it a little differently.  There has been a lot of discussion of SAS playing with (4) guards and Wemby.  There are advantages and disadvantages to that.  To me, it is not that one of the guards is playing PF, it is just that they are playing (4) guards and no forwards.  If BOS got Murphy, the main line up would be (1) guard, (3) forwards, and (1) center.  There would be pros and cons to that as well.  Some mis-matches would favor us and some would not.  But overall, it does get more talent on the floor, same as why SAS plays their (4) guards.

I see Murphy as a natural forward, he is not a natural guard but we could get by with him on the floor even if the other team plays (2) guards.  I don't see Tatum as a natural PF either, but he can rebound and defend well enough that it works.  And I think White is at his best when he is not the primary ball handler, he was at his best playing with Holiday.  I think teams would go small against this line up, pressure full court, force more ball handling, and this would wear down our players.  We would have a size advantage in that case, making it easier to shoot over people, but overall, the line up would lack speed and quickness.