I don't see that Simmons was proposing any specific trade at all. Just kind of generally stating that it would be nice to get Trey Murphy. We could offer Robinson + Hauser + Picks, but why would NOP do that? Unless we included the PHI/LAC pick.
SF is not a position of need. And I don't buy that Murphy, or Tatum or George can play SG, so I don't get what the #1 line up would be. White, George, Murphy, Tatum, Queta? That does not seem like a good fit to me.
I don't agree with Simmons that Murphy is the missing piece. Tatum and George are the forwards. Queta is the center. White is one of the guards. I think the missing piece is a combo guard, a Jrue Holiday type player. More of a ball handler to take some of that load off White. Not sure who that would be, but it isn't Trey Murphy. I guess Dejounte Murray is more that type of player, just not as good a shooter.
Staying out of the actual mechanics of the trade and just looking at the potential fit of Murphy. In modern basketball and particularly the NBA I have completely moved off of any concern over position. To me its less about 1,2,3,4,5 aka PG,SG,SF,PF,C and more just about primary and secondary creation, floor spacing, and cutting/diving to the rim. Defense is the side of the ball where the traditional positions still have some relevance but for a good team with versatile players it becomes a mute point.
If the Cs trade for and subsequently where to start White,George,Murphy,Tatum, and Queta that line up would have a Primary in JT and three capable secondary creators in White, Murphy and George. All three then provide various degrees of spacing off of Tatum and Queta is the dive man. On D I would have very little concern with that group.
Matching up to other East playoff teams I do not see any glaring matchup issues and depending on who is traded the Cs would likely still have two of the three young wings coming off the bench providing high level perimeter D.
If the speculated trade was Robinson+Hauser+Walsh for Murphy and D Jordan it would in many ways be a consolidation of Hauser and Walsh into Murphy whose skill set covers a lot of what both players provide. Loosing Robinson could prove a mistake come playoff time but Garza, Cenac, and Jordan could be serviceable and the trade would likely push Queta's minutes up.