it was essentially the same roster last year. Isn't it kind of an indictment on the players if they cant play defense unless the coach is yelling at them to?
No.
Coaching has a huge impact on your team defense. One on one defense is more about effort. Team defense is about drilling & emphasis. Getting everyone and keeping everyone on the same page throughout the season. Positive reinforcement of defensive principles and negative feedback when those principles are not being adhered to.
And it wasn’t really the same team. We started White over RWill. RWill only played, I think, 35 games. Very different team defensively.
True, but then again White was our only player to make an All-Defensive team, so it's hard to really point to him starting as an issue.
White wasn't the issue at all. Smart took a big step back, not sure if that was an effort issue because he was in his feeling about Ime or if he's starting to decline - which is possible with his style of play. But he wasn't the same level of defender the year before when he was the head of the snake. Then you double down on that with the issue of Rob not being there to clean up mistakes because he was out or working his way back into shape.
This. Plus Horford lost another step as he gets older. Getting Porzingis as a Horford replacement and moving Horford to the bench is huge.
I am not saying that White is the problem, what I was saying is that it is not true that it was the same team defensively as the previous season. Defense is not just the collection of individual defenders, it is about team defense. If you take out a center and put in a guard, all things equal, you are not going to be as good on defense. In the case of the Celtics, you took out a very good defensive center and put in a very good defensive guard, but that is still a net decline in your overall defense. It changes how the entire team has to play defense.
This coming season, I expect we will start Porzingis and RWill or Porzingis and Horford, along with White, Brown, and Tatum. Our defense should be excellent, even considering we are losing a very good individual defender in Marcus Smart. As compared to the 2021-22 team that was so good, we take out Smart but replace him with White. And then we are going to have Porzingis and RWill probably instead of Horford and RWill. Smart and Horford were really good but I think White and Porzingis are fine.