Oh, please, the arbitrary values you assign are totally random and not at all indicative of anything. Part of your argument is that the regular season doesn't matter, yet you mention regular-season MVPs. Larry only had 2 finals MVPs and 3 championships (as compared to Duncan's 3 and 4), but no one in their right mind would even begin to argue that Duncan is more valuable than Larry in any sense, particularly in the playoffs/NBA finals.