Who wins in this presidential round robin one on one?

[Eja117]

Barkley just trashed the president's game.  Al Gore needs to shed some pounds.  I'm giving Barak the benefit of the doubt for now

[KCattheStripe]

Poor Bill bradley and his inept campaign staff.

[Roy H.]

Of the guy's listed, I'd go with Obama, although I know George H. W. Bush was a heck of an athlete.

Historically, though, I'm taking Abe Lincoln.  Sure, it would take him awhile to get used to the game, but he was the tallest U.S. President (6'4"), and he was a very good athlete (a wrestler, I believe). 

Also, don't sleep on Gerald Ford.  He's in the upper third of height (6'0"), and he was an All-American athlete.

[Eja117]

I didn't think of it in terms of being in their prime. I mean that is different.  In that case Taft would surely be horrid.  I'm sure Washington with his rotten teeth could just breathe on people to get the defense to sag

[Brendan]

BHO would be the best and I voted for him. I expect this to be the first and last time I ever say that.

[RebusRankin]

I have a historical sleeper: Teddy Roosevelt.

[soap07]

I vote for Andrew Jackson to play the "Ron Artest" role.

[guava_wrench]

I didn't think of it in terms of being in their prime. I mean that is different.  In that case Taft would surely be horrid.  I'm sure Washington with his rotten teeth could just breathe on people to get the defense to sag

Wooden teeth don't stink.

[Eja117]

I didn't think of it in terms of being in their prime. I mean that is different.  In that case Taft would surely be horrid.  I'm sure Washington with his rotten teeth could just breathe on people to get the defense to sag

Wooden teeth don't stink.

Is there a dentist in the house?