Over unders.
Pick a game, over or under the over under number.
Who ever picks the proper over under and is the biggest distance from it wins.  
Example
If you picked under on the Browns/Bills game, you would have won
Cleveland (#20, 1-4)     6        Under 41.5     
at Buffalo (#26, 1-4)    3          
41.5 - 9 = 32.5  
This way each game can have two players, one over, one under.