Who got the better end of this deal? (fantasy football)

[beantownboy171]

Alright im about to make a trade in my fantasy league, just looking to see who you guys thought got the better end of this deal.

This is a standard 10 team, head-to-head espn league.

Team 1 Trades:
Aaron Rodgers
TJ Houshmandzadeh
Chris Cooley
Fred Jackson

Team 2 Trades:
Jay Cutler
Andre Johnson
Kerry Collins
Jeremy Shockey

One other thing, the team that traded cooley has jason witten as their starting tight end.

I'll leave out whose team is whose as to prevent any kind of bias from effecting your decision.

[bucknersrevenge]

Alright im about to make a trade in my fantasy league, just looking to see who you guys thought got the better end of this deal.

This is a standard 10 team, head-to-head espn league.

Team 1 Trades:
Aaron Rodgers
TJ Houshmandzadeh
Chris Cooley
Fred Jackson

Team 2 Trades:
Jay Cutler
Andre Johnson
Kerry Collins
Jeremy Shockey

One other thing, the team that traded cooley has jason witten as their starting tight end.

I'll leave out whose team is whose as to prevent any kind of bias from effecting your decision.

remind me who fred jackson is? i keep thinking fred taylor but that's not who you're talking about is it?

[beantownboy171]

Alright im about to make a trade in my fantasy league, just looking to see who you guys thought got the better end of this deal.

This is a standard 10 team, head-to-head espn league.

Team 1 Trades:
Aaron Rodgers
TJ Houshmandzadeh
Chris Cooley
Fred Jackson

Team 2 Trades:
Jay Cutler
Andre Johnson
Kerry Collins
Jeremy Shockey

One other thing, the team that traded cooley has jason witten as their starting tight end.

I'll leave out whose team is whose as to prevent any kind of bias from effecting your decision.

remind me who fred jackson is? i keep thinking fred taylor but that's not who you're talking about is it?

Backup running back for the bills. Who will be starting the first 4 games due to marshawn lynches suspension

[CelticS 86]

its a close trade...but i think team 2 has the better end of the deal....

[Roy Hobbs]

I'll take Team 2.

[Kwhit10]

I think Rodgers will be a stud QB this year, I think Cutler will fall off. I'd like team 2 also.

[RebusRankin]

I like team 1. Better QB, good receiver, better TE and a rb with upside versus a QB who's a fantasy backup.

[beantownboy171]

I was team one btw, i suppose i was overly infatuated with trying to team up both fitzgerald and johnson on my team because they are as i see it the two best fantasy wr's.

Heres my team:

Jay Cutler
Steve Slaton
Kevin Smith
Derrick Ward
Larry Fitzgerald
Andre Johnson
Jason Witten
Patriots D/ST
Matt Prater

Antonio Bryant
Anthony Gonzales
Felix Jones
Leon Washington
Matt Hasslebeck
Kerry Collins
Jeremy Shockey

I also see tj housh as a very overated wr. Exceptionally inconsitent. He had 3 20 point games last season totalling about 60% of his scoring. In his other 13 games, he only managed a total 40 points.


Also obviously chris cooley wasnt much of a loss for me as well. All that being said i feel very confident with how i drafted, and even if the trade wasn't the best, i like my team.

[Roy Hobbs]

Too bad Jay Cutler isn't throwing to Fitzgerald and Johnson.  A Bears fan can dream, at least.

[beantownboy171]

Got a new trade offered to me.

I get:
Brandon Marshall
Jonathon Stewart

I give:
Steve Smith (nyg)
jonny Knox

It would be a no brainer before the season, and it was offered to me by the league pannicker (theres one in every league) and both j. stew and marshall have gotten off to slow starts. But I just need some affirmation that its a good deal.

[Tw1x990]

not to steal the thread, but I didnt want to make a whole new one ...

heres a deal I just made .. again, I wont say who is who =]

Team 1 trades Garcon and Fred Taylor
Team 2 trade Greg Jennings

[Roy Hobbs]

not to steal the thread, but I didnt want to make a whole new one ...

heres a deal I just made .. again, I wont say who is who =]

Team 1 trades Garcon and Fred Taylor
Team 2 trade Greg Jennings

Team 1.  They traded two waiver pickups for a legit starting wideout.

[yall hate]

not to steal the thread, but I didnt want to make a whole new one ...

heres a deal I just made .. again, I wont say who is who =]

Team 1 trades Garcon and Fred Taylor
Team 2 trade Greg Jennings

thats not even close.  I feel bad for the guy who gave up Jennings.  horrible deal for them

[RebusRankin]

What would you move Roddy White for?