dang, i was about to post a comprehensive stat comparisons of Smart vs. the guys' you mentioned then my pc went off.

anyway I kinda redid it, and here goes:
*(all of the stats below are from their rookie seasons).
Marcus Smart
poor fg% compared to the other guys. Might be because brad insisted him to shoot the 3 so much, i don't know. I hope our kid focus on taking it to the basket soon.
vs. Chauncey Billups
Solid.
vs. Alvin Robertson
never saw this guy play, but career-wise he's solid.
vs. Tony Allen
not the same position as marcus . I also didn't know he shot the 3 ball 38.7% with his broken shot. o_o
vs. Joe Dumars
although not the same position as marcus, I see similarities from him and this bad boy. Hope our kid doesn't turn out to be a sucky GM, though.
vs. Gary Payton
The Glove had a lackluster rookie campaign, shooting the 3ball at 7.7%. Goes to show that you can't predict a players career based on rookie stats. (why I still continue to post, we'll never know). Long story short, Gary Payton will continue his career to be one of the best two way point guards in NBA history.
vs Lindsey Hunter
slightly better than MS stat-wise.
vs. Bruce Bowen
This guy's an SF. to compare him to a PG is moot.
vs. Dwayne
This guy is better than Marcus when it comes to hurting people that's for sure.
heart, grit, leadership, and nut punching aren't shown on these stats, but I'll leave you guys to discuss.
Edit: gah, I couldn't get the stats to align I'm sorry. It turned out to be a jumbled mess so I left it out.