Rondo plays at a high level most of the time, especially in the playoffs. Part of the reason people don't always see this is because he doesn't have a set role on the team, which is unique among players of his caliber. He's also primarily a distributor, which means he can get his team good shots but look unproductive if they miss those shots.
But beyond that, Rondo's evaluated by a much different standard than other players on his level. Rondo's played 14 playoff games thus far. He's scored 13 or more 12 times. He has 5 or more rebounds 9 times, 4 or more 12 times. He has 10 or more assists 11 times. In 8 of his 14 games he's had more assists than any other player's had in any single game in the playoffs this year. He's leading the league (in the playoffs) in minutes, assists and triple doubles, he's tied for the lead in double doubles, he's 3rd in steals per game, he's leading all point guards in rebounding and he's in the top 20 for scoring in the playoffs.
But that's not considered playing at a high level or being consistent because he'll have a few bad defensive possessions in his 40+ minutes or because he'll have a quarter or two during the game where he isn't very productive. Does Chris Paul keep his man in front of him on almost every possession? Does Durant ever have a quarter or a half when he isn't very productive? Does Wade ever go through stretches where he just isn't playing with the same energy that he has when he take over games for stretches? I think that most people here don't really notice when those things invariably happen to anyone else, but when they happen to Rondo it will be the main point of discussion no matter how solidly he plays the rest of the game.
I agree with pretty much everything you say here, I just believe he needs to be the #1 guy and take over games offensively like he did in game 2. That is the Celtics only shot at winning games in this series because the old men are playing like old men (aside from KG, though he even can't go full bore the whole game). Rondo needs to be a 25/8 type player for Boston to have any shot, not a 12/12 type player. That was the guy he was in game 2 where he was looking to shoot and drive as a first option and pass as the second option. With this team as it is construed, Rondo needs to score first and pass second. Sad, but just the way it is. If he has that mentality and goes for it (even if he misses shots), then Boston can win games and frankly I'd be less inclined to move him going forward than I currently am. I just don't know if he has it in him.
I don't think it's just Rondo. I think Doc needs to see this as well. If you look at the Heat, they're designed to let James and Wade do as much as they can and the rest of the team (including Bosh) complement them. The Celts, to a certain extent, are set up to try and have Rondo wring as much production as possible out of the big three. Rondo needs to change his mindset, so does Doc.
So does PP, btw, to accept a more complementary role on offense the way Ray and KG have.
Surprisingly, I disagree with you on this. I still think this team is at its best when Rondo is getting everybody involved and everybody is hitting shots. If the rest of the guys are unable to get to a place where they are bringing consistent offense, then we'll be ending the season as Eastern Conference Finalists and definitely not as Eastern Conference Champions.
I also think that we still need Pierce to be a guy with the ball in his hands who creates offense off the dribble at times. If you look at the other teams left in the playoffs, none of them have only one guy who is a real threat with the ball in his hands.
I'm not interested in seeing this just turn into the Rondo show. He can probably continue to get big numbers for himself, but I don't think we are advancing that way either. I think he's got to keep trying to "wring production" out of the big three, and everybody else for that matter.
Those who are critical of Rondo seem to not like him because they don't think he can lead a team to a title by himself. I think it's pretty clearly established, however, that there's no player in the league these days good enough to win a title by himself.
To me, if we want to have a shot at building a team that can compete for championships eschewing the superstar model and using the total team model instead, then Rondo is the perfect guy to start with to try to accomplish that. That's what I want to see going forward (and for the rest of these playoffs.)