I just read your part B of the Seattle breakdown, and I am actually very surprised... You don't see Tim Duncan vs. Al Jefferson as a win for Seattle? I can follow your reasoning for Howard v. Young as an advantage (and still disagree with it, I think you underrated Thaddeus Young), but there's no way that's a larger deficit then Jefferson v. Tim freaking Duncan. Also, I'm not taking the leash off Dahntay Jones and letting him just chuck. I'm saying over the course of an 82 game season I expect more then 17 three point attempts when he shot 64% from distance. He will shoot more, not he will shoot nonstop until I forcibly remove him from the floor.
Reading your assessment and knowing mine, I think we've reached a point with our comparisons where it's going to have to be agree to disagree, and I feel the same way with Utah and Portland. The only way to settle these things would be in an actual series, which we unfortunately will never get. Can't tell you how much I would pay to see an actual season of this played out for real, not just 2K10.