I with agree with the school of thought that these awards typically don't reward the defensive-minded. If he really comes along at light speed offensively to go with what we already see on the other end, then he would still be a dark horse at best but chances would be better.
Frankly, I love that we went for defense first. At times we can get carried away when we watch a McDermott shoot on a good night or see the "potential" in another college great who makes the highlight real on a particular day. However, I don't think we could have asked for better from this high pick. ROY or not, he'll be a solid player for years if he stays healthy.