I have never been a fan of a big man that can't rebound, play defense and battle hard under the glass. For that reason, I would have no problem off loading Olynyk this off season. He pretty much proved most of what I said against him when he came out of college. I said he would struggle offensively against PFs that were strong and athletic. I said he just wouldn't be able to have the strength or athleticism to be any type of defender. I said he was a poor rebounder.
After two years, he has done nothing to change that.
He has almost always been most consistent and most productive when the C's were playing their worst as a team and not being taken seriously by their competition. That is a poor sign.
I just see no way Olynyk suddenly grows longer arms, gets to jump higher and faster on his second jump, gets to move faster laterally, learns the basics of boxing out, significantly increases his strength at his base or any of the other things that would have to happen for KO to become a much better player than he has shown.
He can shoot when he has confidence. He can run the floor once he gets a head of steam up. He is a good passer. But is is soft. He is a horrid defender. And he can't rebound. He is probably a good 8th - 10th man off the bench to give you some offense from the front court and that's all he is going to be. At 24-25 years old, I just see no more ceiling to grow into for KO. That Stevens had to bench him in the final two games of a playoff series because he could not get a defensive rebound is extremely telling to me.