His floor is Aaron Gordon's contract, which comparably under this salary cap would be 24 million descending each year, or about 90 million total over 4 years.
His ceiling is the max, which is 170 million over 5 years.
I would give it to him. I would offer the full 5 year.
Nope, sorry. With both Simmons and Murray getting 5 year 170 million dollar contracts there's no way Brown re-ups for less than that.
Hopefully the Celtics agree with your stance that he deserves the max, since they're definitely going to lose him for nothing in free agency if they try to low-ball him. Certainly no team is going to trade for him knowing they could just outbid the Celtics for his services in free agency.
He's a restricted free agent. We can't be outbid, at least not next offseason.
I love Brown and his potential, but this isn't a floor, it's the max, so it's the ceiling. And although Brown may indeed wind up getting the max and may turn out to be a better player than Murray, Murray was the #2 man on a team that lost by an eyelash in the 2nd round of the playoffs and won 54 games, while Jaylen was a 6th man. Whether or not it hurts Jaylen's feelings, Murray has shown a little more, and when it comes to Simmons, there really is no comparison to be made.
Their draft positions mean nothing w/respect to what each is now worth.
Did the playoffs 2 years ago never happen? You know, when Jaylen Brown was the 2nd leading scorer of a team that was one game away from the finals? Does that not count? That feat is far more impressive then anything Jamal Murray has done.
2 seasons ago is 2 seasons ago.
What happened this season is more relevant. And what happens in the 19-20 season will be far more important than either.
Denver & Philly are all in on their 2 guys. The Celtics are keeping their powder dry with good reason. We're likely going to have to max Tatum in a year or two, and probably want to make sure we have flexibility for 2 years from now FA class, plus or minus Gordon somewhere in between.
Jaylen isn't there (max contract) yet. You can argue that Murray isn't either and I wouldn't make the case that he is, but that's not relevant to the Celtics, they have to make their own decisions. Murray is obviously their guy, he plays more minutes than anyone on their team, and is obviously their 2nd best player. At no point has Brown been even the 3rd best player on a healthy Celtics team. As for Simmons, shooting limitations or not, no one can make the case Philly shouldn't have gone max on Simmons.
Personally, I wouldn't give Jaylen a max extension now, he hasn't earned it. He's looks like he's on the way to being that caliber of player, and I'm hoping he gets there.