KungPoweChicken, I want to warn you, what I'm about to write might come off pretty rough. I have no problem with you though, all this is just my opinion solely from what you've written in this thread. Hopefully you take this as constructive criticism. With that being said...
So many red flags are here, I don't know where to start.
I'm a catch.
Yeah, I do message the most attractive women, but that's only because I know what my equal is and I'm not going to settle for less.
While my list height is about 5'9. I'm really only 5'7. It's just harder for me to land the tallies.
Maybe part of the problem is you think too highly of yourself. You think you're a catch, but yet you have to lie in your profile? Part of what you think makes you a catch is that you have a car and a job? What kind of low class, trashy girls are you after that this would impress them?
If you're really the catch you think you are, it's ALWAYS a buyers market for you. Chances are you're not really that much of a catch if nobody is buying what you're selling.
Let's just back it up for a second. This is just what I've observed from you based only on this thread:
1. You think highly of yourself
2. You think you're better than others/too good for others
3. You lie
4. You're superficial
5. You hang out on Celticsblog. (Ok that last one is a joke lol).
You think this is the kind of person people want? I've met a ton of people who fit think like this, and they're never the catch they think they are. You probably know girls like that too, you've already alluded to some already, girls who are "6's", they probably think they're "9's". That list above are turn offs to most people, but that's how you're coming off (at least here).
People with a job, car, hair, and nice body are a dime a dozen. Literally millions of people can claim this. That's not a catch. Is that what you mention in your profile and messages to women? That's not going to impress too many people. Again if anything, mentioning these things is a turn off to a lot of people. A woman can go anywhere and get a guy like that, and if you mention these things you'd come off like a superficial, shallow person.
And how come when you mentioned all your good qualities, you didn't mention anything like sense of humor, personality, down to earth, fun to be around, etc. These are the qualities people really want.
Seriously, ask yourself this, if you think it's a buyers market for woman, if you think they're getting 10-100 messages a day from different guys, what's going to make you stand out? What do you bring to the table that some other dude can't? If a girl gets 20 messages, then at least 10 are going to be from guys with a good looks/car/job/body. Again, that doesn't really make you a catch, what else do you got?
Online dating is a seller's market for women.
Again, it's ALWAYS a buyers market if you're really a catch.
Feeling brave and want some more advice? Link your OKC or POF profile. I bet plenty of us could give you some honest feedback on it.