So where'd you end up going, Roy?
The anniversary isn't until 4/23; I'm just trying to plan ahead of time.
I'm still weighing my options. Lots and lots of great suggestions, which fits in with the "it's hard to find bad Italian in the North End" reputation (although that's not always true, of course).
I'm ideally trying to keep my budget around $150 for dinner, and am trying to find something nice, but "traditional". My wife tends to like red sauces (although sometimes white); she's a chicken parm type of girl (although on our honeymoon to Italy she did just fine). Seafood-heavy places are also something I'm steering clear of, just because it's not a personal favorite.
That said, I'm weighing four or five places right now. I thank everybody for the suggestions, and I'll reward everybody with TPs soon.