Only with less passing ability, rebounding ability, less athleticism and less scoring ability.
I just don't see what you guys are seeing in OJ Mayo. He does so little for his team outside of scoring (defense, rebounding, passing) and he's not that good of a scorer either. Not prolific (18ppg) or overly efficient (TS% of 54.8%). He's a solid scorer, a nice third option type of threat.
I don't see a star level impact from Mayo during games or mass potential when I watch him play. Too one-dimensional (only above average in his scoring ability). Not enough elsewhere.
You seem to be forgetting the obvious point that OJ Mayo is only half way through his second year in the league, and is only 22 years old.
Ray Allen, through his second year (also 22 years old) put up the following.
16.5 PTS, 4.5 RBS, 3.5 ASST, 43% FG, 37% 3PT, 54% TS, 48.5% EFG, 85% FT
OJ Mayo through his half of 2nd year
18.3 PTS, 3.8 RBS, 4.2 ASST, 44% FG, 38% 3PT, 54% TS, 50% EFG, 86% FT
They seem to be the exact same player.