I have the first pick also, so I have this dilemma too. Here's the thing, we have a keeper league but we just reset so we pick from scratch this year. I can keep on player 3 times after this year. Thinking long-term, I am leaning to picking AP.
Besides, I rode the LT train to 2 straight title game losses (I'm the Bills of my league) so I think I've squeezed him for all he's worth to me
I haven't decided yet, but the other thing that might sway me is the fact that I traded for 2 second rounders - so I can back AP up with more stable backs