Brown has not been better than Tatum this year and people really need to stop pushing that false narrative.
Its not a false narrative. Brown has been more consistent, efficient and also 2 way. The stats back this up. Tatum has been near bottom in true shooting among our rotation players, only ahead of Smart. It is not good when combined with his blackhole tendencies.
Team-based metrics show Tatum clearly has a bigger impact on winning. Tatum also has an ability to take over games on offense Brown does not and is the better defender.
Brown shoots a higher percentage because he gets easier shots, due to being less of the focal point of the offense.
Tatum is better, period. Coaches, players, and media, league-wide, agree. It's really only a few weird Celtics fans that think otherwise.
I don't think people are necessarily saying Brown is a better player, I think mostly people are saying that Brown is having a better year.
Brown is having the better defensive year. Tatum can play the passing lanes and be great on pick and rolls because he is largely guarding the weakest offensive 2-3-4 on the floor while Jaylen generally gets the toughest assignment, whether that be guarding the other team's best offensive player at the 2-3-4 or guarding the other team's power forward or doing both at the same time.
And while Tatum can get red hot and show what he will be, he still was terribly inefficient the 1st two months of the season and awfully inconsistent.
Brown has been much more efficient and consistent while putting up the same stats and being the better defender and taking on the tougher defensive assignments.
Clearly, an argument can be made Brown is having the better season, but because Tatum is doing what he is doing at 21, he is, most probably, the better player.
I think they were equally deserving but because the Celtics don't have a record as good as the Bucks, they were never going to get 3 guys in the game, no matter how deserving. Happy for Tatum. Well, earned. But Jaylen was as deserving, if not more so, because he is having, arguably, the better season.