LA Lakers
PG: Magic
SG: Jerry West
SF: LeBron
PF: AD
C: Kareem
I take this Lakers squad just as you have it (as much as it hurts). My only hesitation is that LeBron and AD are both kind of ring chasers, not as much of true Lakers as some of the others (Kareem was traded too I guess). Not sure how many season would be needed to qualify for this type of all time team status.
The more I think about it, I don't think AD should be on the team, here is my modified version
PG: Magic
SG: Jerry West
SF: Baylor
PF: LeBron
C: Kareem
I have both Magic and LeBron as top 3 all time. I know I have Magic higher than most but to me, he is right there with Jordan and LeBron. You could put in Kobe for West, I would be fine with either. And I definitely have Kareem over Shaq in any era.