Tatum is a great player but he hasn't yet reached elite status and may never get there.
There are 5 no brainer all time elite players in the league right now. Lebron, Durant, and Curry are past their prime and then Jokic and Giannis.
Injuries harmed Kawhi's elite starts but he is arguable as is Embiid.
Paul is right on the cusp where I could see arguments for or against. Same with Davis, Harden, Westbrook, and Lillard.
Then there are a handful of guys that have shown the talent to get there if they keep progressing. That is where Tatum is along with Doncic, SGA, and Booker.
Edwards, Banchero, Zion, and Wemby all appear talented enough to get there as well, but need to stay healthy and continue to improve.