CelticsStrong

CelticsStrong => CelticsStrong Hall of Fame => Nominees / Discussion => Topic started by: nickagneta on July 13, 2008, 10:40:12 PM

Title: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: nickagneta on July 13, 2008, 10:40:12 PM
I got this idea after giving Roy his 14th and wdleehi his 11th congratulations in the "We have a new star!" thread. They are truly special people here at CB and there are a few others as well.

I recently have just passed my first anniversary of joining Celticsblog, which, by the way, would also be a pretty cool continuous thread to have right along with the "We have a new star" and "100 TP's" threads. But I digress.

So having been here a year and knowing that this site is at least on it's 3rd(is that right) version of itself, technically, software and server speaking and is a couple to a few years old at least, I was wondering.

Is it time for a Celticsblog.com Hall of Fame?

There could be up to five people nominated each year into the Hall with a a month voting period where each blog member with over 250 posts gets to vote voting for a max of 3 people. Minimum 75% of the vote to enter. The numbers could be changed but you all get the idea.

There could be Threads of Fame, Posts of Fame, Subjects of Fame, and Articles of Fame.

There could be a section on This Day in the Chat Room for famous chat discussions the happen on famous days.

There could be archives of the most famous CSL nights each year.

Celticblog could have its own Hollowed Cyber Hall that visitors to the web could look through as we showcase the best of the best that our little community represents.

If it starts to get lots of traffic or regular traffic there could be sponsors who get to advertise there exclusively. Exclusive Sponsor of the Celticsblog.com Hall of Fame.

LOL. Okay so I'm half kidding with that one but you all get the jist.

Of course it would also involve charter members and how Jeff, Bob Day, Roy Hobbs, Master Po, and wdleehi couldn't be those charter members is beyond me.

Of course this would have to involve the approval of the hierarchy and involve some extra work from my second favorite computer expert in the world(sorry Bob, my son is my first), but what does the Celticsblog family at large think of it?

I'm serious here, what do people think of the idea and is it something Jeff would allow and Bob would help us with?
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: cdif911 on July 13, 2008, 10:49:09 PM
I think its a pretty cool idea, creating almost a "history" section of CB, we could try to dig up the first post ever on CB, the first post that Roy had to edit, the first time someone crashed the server, etc.

but the hall of fame, I like it - I don't know if you'd do 5 a year, or 1 a year, or 1 a quarter...who knows - I do think the names you named would all be very very solid candidates, others come to mind as well Redz, Bahku, Scintan, yourself, SShore (though we'd have to bring back his original retired sn), Florida... there's more, but yeah it'd be cool to do, the only thing I'd worry about with doing it as a poll is the politics that might go into it (we all saw the TP pageant) - but I think anyonymous nomination and voting could work... there could be qualifications to get in - like 5000 posts, 300 TPs or something like that, I dunno - but I do like it, I think it would be a nice way to cement those who have contributed in a special way

Now the big question - will they give CB a wing in Springfield? =)

Nice sentiments nick - classy stuff
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Roy Hobbs on July 13, 2008, 10:55:02 PM
I'm pretty sure Jeff is the first inductee.

And Po.  We can't forget Po.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: nickagneta on July 13, 2008, 10:59:36 PM
I'm pretty sure Jeff is the first inductee.

And Po.  We can't forget Po.
I had those guys on my list for sure.

There's no way Jeff, Po, Bob are not in in my mind. I think you and wd should get in initially too as prolific and contributing mods.

But if the first year is only 2 people only, yeah, it has to be Jeff and Po.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: cdif911 on July 13, 2008, 11:03:12 PM
I'm pretty sure Jeff is the first inductee.

And Po.  We can't forget Po.
I had those guys on my list for sure.

There's no way Jeff, Po, Bob are not in in my mind. I think you and wd should get in initially too as prolific and contributing mods.

But if the first year is only 2 guys only, yeah, it has to be Jeff and Po.


yeah they were def. there (which is why I didn't have to include them on mine)
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: jackson_34 on July 13, 2008, 11:11:34 PM
Jeff is without fail the Walter Brown of this proposed Hall of Fame, and that's where it should begin.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Edgar on July 13, 2008, 11:12:23 PM
El Jefe and the Old Lady
count me in supporting the nomination!!  ;D
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Robb on July 13, 2008, 11:43:20 PM
Nice idea.  I'd change it to allow voting from only star posters or posters who have contributed for such a period of time.  250 posts seems a little low.

I think Jeff should be the first inductee, and afterward those who are in the Hall could decide who gets on the ballot.  I think Jeff has enough on his plate that we don't need to saddle him with voting for the Hall of Fame on his own forums, so the invitation is there for him, but I think we can handle this if it's too much work for him.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Stebra on July 13, 2008, 11:46:23 PM
Can I nominate Big John? How's that for a blast from the past...
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Roy Hobbs on July 13, 2008, 11:50:34 PM
Can I nominate Big John? How's that for a blast from the past...

Haha.  I think Big John falls under the Pete Rose category.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Andrew Celtic Nation on July 13, 2008, 11:51:04 PM
Sounds good, where will the induction ceremony be held?  ;D
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Eja117 on July 14, 2008, 12:41:06 AM
This is an original and interesting, if not difficult, concept.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: wdleehi on July 14, 2008, 01:09:19 AM
I just want to know what is planned for the CROTOR wing. 
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Robb on July 14, 2008, 01:31:28 AM
I just want to know what is planned for the CROTOR wing. 

I'm literally shaking with excitement to find out.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: TripleOT on July 14, 2008, 01:43:32 AM
I got a chuckle out of the Celticsblog Hall of Fame idea. 
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: nickagneta on July 14, 2008, 12:39:39 PM
Is this all the love this idea gets?

I know it would be a lot of work, work I for one would be willing to put in.

And this is not a joke.

Come on any further input? If there just isn't the support or people think it's a bad idea just say so. I won't be arguing the point. I just would like to know.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Roy Hobbs on July 14, 2008, 12:45:21 PM
Is this all the love this idea gets?

I know it would be a lot of work, work I for one would be willing to put in.

And this is not a joke.

Come on any further input? If there just isn't the support or people think it's a bad idea just say so. I won't be arguing the point. I just would like to know.

I think it's a fun idea, nick.  I'm sure the staff would support it once folks figured out what type of rules / structure it had.  I don't want to speak for Bob, but it's probably not all that hard to put a section / link that sends us to a page with biographical info related to the inductees.  I'm sure we could also give this some front page attention.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: paintitgreen on July 14, 2008, 12:58:52 PM
Wow, a CB HOF. That's a crazy idea, but just crazy enough to work. Good luck with it. I've only been posting for about 2 1/2 years, don't know how long the blog has been around, so I'm only familiar with the current iteration of CB and one prior version. To me, the two dominant people are Jeff and Roy, I guess I missed out on much of the Po era. Since many of the longtime posters have cited to Po and many like me don't know much if anything about Po, I would agree voting should be limited to the mods for the first few votes, then opened up to 1000+ posters, with greater weight for people who have been around longer. As for my choices, Scintan is also a guy who sticks out to me as somebody who really made this place lively. And Edgar's one of my favorites - seeing him bring in the international flavor always makes me happy. And I'm a big fan of EJPlaya's posts, wdleehi and nick himself. It's not about quantity, but quality to me, and I generally like what those guys have to say.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: SShoreFan 2.0 on July 14, 2008, 01:00:00 PM
We already have

Stars
Titles
Celtic Player Designations
Tommy Point Numbers
Number of Posts


Not to mention
Names,
Pictures
Tag Lines
Tag Lines w/ Pictures


How much more do we need to differentiate people?

(http://www.mises.org/images4/TwoCents.gif)

Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Jeff on July 14, 2008, 01:06:00 PM
I think we'd also have to pay homage to the historical characters

hagrid was my original co-author but life got in the way and he had to pull back

and anyone else from the old Boston.com chatroom, in particular C-Bill, who passed away a couple years ago (may he rest in peace)
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: dark_lord on July 14, 2008, 01:09:54 PM
i think it is a fun idea, but i honestly dont think we should have it.  we have tp's and stars with threads for each for posters to congratulate and recognize posters' contributions.  i think adding a hall of fame could potential create issues for people (not myself, as i think its a fun idea).  people may start to get egos, build resentment towards others, and worst of all....post with an agenda, rather than keeping it real.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Roy Hobbs on July 14, 2008, 01:10:19 PM
I think we'd also have to pay homage to the historical characters

hagrid was my original co-author but life got in the way and he had to pull back

and anyone else from the old Boston.com chatroom, in particular C-Bill, who passed away a couple years ago (may he rest in peace)

Definitely.  HomeRunBaker definitely would need some consideration, too.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Hoops on July 14, 2008, 01:11:27 PM
I like the idea too. Like paintitgreen, I think it should be about quality, not quantity. We already have stars for quantity of posts. I could easily see the HOF as being redudant (i.e., those that have lots of stars are automatically voted into the HOF).

Obviously, one has to post frequently enough that they establish a reputation and familiarity on the blog.  But I would imagine that there are lots of people who are familiar based on their large post counts that aren't necessarily deserving of HOF induction.

Just like the real HOF, there should be a waiting period. For example, you can't become eligible (regardless of post count) until you've been a member for X amount of time (e.g., 2 years.)

As for voting, I think it should definitely not be a mod only voting system. I agree that there should be a minimum post count. On top of that, I think there should be a minimum length of time as a member of the blog. Obviously, that can't go too far back because I imagine it would be too hard to figure out who participated in previous versions of the blog.

Perhaps someone could become a voting member if they have a low post count, but the logs show that person is frequently on the blog, reading posts, etc.

My two cents.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Jeff on July 14, 2008, 01:16:07 PM
you have to admit, you guys really are vain!

(...says the guy who has runs a blog and pleads for attention on a daily basis)

 :P
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: iowa plowboy on July 14, 2008, 01:28:21 PM
Active Bloggers qualify??  I always thought you had to be retired for 5 years before you could be nominated for the hall of fame.

I've seen no crocodile tear-filled press conferences with Blog members announcing their retirements yet.  

and anyone else from the old Boston.com chatroom, in particular C-Bill, who passed away a couple years ago (may he rest in peace)

Billy welcomed me when I stumbled into the Globe's chatroom.  One of the nicest, down to earth people I've known in the Blog/Globe.  A sad loss.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Redz on July 14, 2008, 01:29:22 PM
Would we have to retire from the blog for 5 years to be eligible?

I think I'm leaning with darklord on this one.

Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Steve Weinman on July 14, 2008, 01:32:09 PM
Active Bloggers qualify??  I always thought you had to be retired for 5 years before you could be nominated for the hall of fame.

I've seen no crocodile tear-filled press conferences with Blog members announcing their retirements yet. 


Yeah, we'd pretty much be limiting the pools to banned members...and down the road, BrickJames (if Tony Allen gets a contract)  ;)

Imagine that... a boatload of Laker-Piston trolls as our eligible HOF candidates...might have to keep it open to the active-folk, eh?

-sw
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Chief on July 14, 2008, 01:33:55 PM
Would we have to retire from the blog for 5 years to be eligible?

I think I'm leaning with darklord on this one.



Me too!!!
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Redz on July 14, 2008, 01:38:14 PM
Would we have to retire from the blog for 5 years to be eligible?

I think I'm leaning with darklord on this one.



Me too!!!

That said, if we are going to impose a 5 year wait, I'd like to announce my retirement, effective immediately ;)
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Hoops on July 14, 2008, 01:41:04 PM
Active Bloggers qualify??  I always thought you had to be retired for 5 years before you could be nominated for the hall of fame.

I've seen no crocodile tear-filled press conferences with Blog members announcing their retirements yet. 


Yeah, we'd pretty much be limiting the pools to banned members...and down the road, BrickJames (if Tony Allen gets a contract)  ;)

Imagine that... a boatload of Laker-Piston trolls as our eligible HOF candidates...might have to keep it open to the active-folk, eh?

-sw

Obviously, making people wait for 5 years after retiring doesn't make sense for a blog HOF. You have to include active bloggers, but there should be a waiting period (e.g., minimum of 2-3 years as a blog member).
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: BrickJames on July 14, 2008, 01:41:17 PM
Active Bloggers qualify??  I always thought you had to be retired for 5 years before you could be nominated for the hall of fame.

I've seen no crocodile tear-filled press conferences with Blog members announcing their retirements yet. 


Yeah, we'd pretty much be limiting the pools to banned members...and down the road, BrickJames (if Tony Allen gets a contract)  ;)

Imagine that... a boatload of Laker-Piston trolls as our eligible HOF candidates...might have to keep it open to the active-folk, eh?

-sw

See, I'm already in the SW Hall of Fame (or is it Infamy?).  That's enough for me. :)

As for TA, I'm really hoping he gets a deal, for my sanity.  I am a man of my word, after all.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Steve Weinman on July 14, 2008, 01:44:10 PM
TP for making me chuckle, Brick.  And no, it's certainly not infamy...I was just about to post to clarify that I was just messin' with ya....but glad to see that there was no need for that.  Always enjoy chatting.

That being said, the SW HOF would definitely be way too much responsibility for me.  What a burden to bear.  I'd have to hire a selection committee...

-sw
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Chief on July 14, 2008, 01:46:24 PM
Would we have to retire from the blog for 5 years to be eligible?

I think I'm leaning with darklord on this one.



Me too!!!

That said, if we are going to impose a 5 year wait, I'd like to announce my retirement, effective immediately ;)

Active Bloggers qualify??  I always thought you had to be retired for 5 years before you could be nominated for the hall of fame.

I've seen no crocodile tear-filled press conferences with Blog members announcing their retirements yet. 


Yeah, we'd pretty much be limiting the pools to banned members...and down the road, BrickJames (if Tony Allen gets a contract)  ;)

Imagine that... a boatload of Laker-Piston trolls as our eligible HOF candidates...might have to keep it open to the active-folk, eh?

-sw

Obviously, making people wait for 5 years after retiring doesn't make sense for a blog HOF. You have to include active bloggers, but there should be a waiting period (e.g., minimum of 2-3 years as a blog member).

I think he was just joking!!
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Chief on July 14, 2008, 01:47:38 PM
Would we have to retire from the blog for 5 years to be eligible?

I think I'm leaning with darklord on this one.



Me too!!!

That said, if we are going to impose a 5 year wait, I'd like to announce my retirement, effective immediately ;)

(http://www.zen36049.zen.co.uk/CLANGNUTS%20CARTOONS%202007/clang%20retirement.gif)
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: SShoreFan 2.0 on July 14, 2008, 02:22:59 PM
We could also have CelticsBlog Superlatives, you know like they have in high school yearbooks.

Best Looking
Most Popular
Most Athletic
Smartest
Most Likely to Paint His Body Green
Class Clown (is there any doubt on this one??)
Most Likely to Succeed
Most Likely to Live in His Parents Basement for Life
Most Likely to Be Drafted by the NBDL
Most Dramatic
Most Reliable
Biggest Suck Up
Most Shy
Most Likely to be arrested
Most Likely to be a subject of a 60 Minutes segment
Biggest Greg Dickerson Wannabe
Biggest Ego



As I was researching this, I came upon the following link, click on it and read the very last superlative!!

http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/basketball/nba/1998/draft/si/superlatives.html

Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: PlayRyanGomes on July 14, 2008, 02:31:12 PM
While we're at it, why don't we have an indication for how long the person has been a member, I've been coming to CelticsBlog since late 04 or early 05 and I'm relegated to PJ Brown status, like I'm a midseason pick up who hopped on for the championship ride.  That's annoying.  I know I don't post often but I've been a loyal CelticsBlog visitor.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Roy Hobbs on July 14, 2008, 02:33:43 PM
While we're at it, why don't we have an indication for how long the person has been a member, I've been coming to CelticsBlog since late 04 or early 05 and I'm relegated to PJ Brown status, like I'm a midseason pick up who hopped on for the championship ride.  That's annoying.  I know I don't post often but I've been a loyal CelticsBlog visitor.

You can see the date a member registered in their profile (in your case, December 30, 2006).  That's when the current version of CB opened (or thereabouts). 
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: JSD on July 14, 2008, 02:37:54 PM
what happened to Bassthumper?
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Hoops on July 14, 2008, 02:39:49 PM
While we're at it, why don't we have an indication for how long the person has been a member, I've been coming to CelticsBlog since late 04 or early 05 and I'm relegated to PJ Brown status, like I'm a midseason pick up who hopped on for the championship ride.  That's annoying.  I know I don't post often but I've been a loyal CelticsBlog visitor.

You can see the date a member registered in their profile (in your case, December 30, 2006).  That's when the current version of CB opened (or thereabouts). 
I think he was suggesting that the member registration date ought to be included on every post - just like the post count is. It's a good idea.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: BrickJames on July 14, 2008, 03:13:51 PM
We could also have CelticsBlog Superlatives, you know like they have in high school yearbooks.

Best Looking
Most Popular
Most Athletic
Smartest
Most Likely to Paint His Body Green
Class Clown (is there any doubt on this one??)
Most Likely to Succeed
Most Likely to Live in His Parents Basement for Life
Most Likely to Be Drafted by the NBDL
Most Dramatic
Most Reliable
Biggest Suck Up
Most Shy
Most Likely to be arrested
Most Likely to be a subject of a 60 Minutes segment
Biggest Greg Dickerson Wannabe
Biggest Ego



As I was researching this, I came upon the following link, click on it and read the very last superlative!!

http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/basketball/nba/1998/draft/si/superlatives.html



Nice suggestion SS, and good find with the SI article.  TP.

I'll withhold my self nomination for best looking (ahem) and also my picks for other nominations, especially "Most Likely to Live in His Parents Basement for Life".

I'm sure we all have our thoughts :)
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: BrickJames on July 14, 2008, 03:14:50 PM
TP for making me chuckle, Brick.  And no, it's certainly not infamy...I was just about to post to clarify that I was just messin' with ya....but glad to see that there was no need for that.  Always enjoy chatting.

That being said, the SW HOF would definitely be way too much responsibility for me.  What a burden to bear.  I'd have to hire a selection committee...

-sw

NP Steve.  C'mon, you think I'm that much of a softie?

I've been lazy lately - looking forward to the next time I get riled up and have a 2 hr back-and-forth with ya :-D
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Steve Weinman on July 14, 2008, 03:17:27 PM
TP for making me chuckle, Brick.  And no, it's certainly not infamy...I was just about to post to clarify that I was just messin' with ya....but glad to see that there was no need for that.  Always enjoy chatting.

That being said, the SW HOF would definitely be way too much responsibility for me.  What a burden to bear.  I'd have to hire a selection committee...

-sw

NP Steve.  C'mon, you think I'm that much of a softie?

I've been lazy lately - looking forward to the next time I get riled up and have a 2 hr back-and-forth with ya :-D

Amen.  Count me in, too.  The last go-around was my pleasure.

-sw
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: EJPLAYA on July 14, 2008, 03:22:54 PM
One little problem you may have not considered. If you nominate these guys for people to say all these nice things about (well deserved) you also open it up to people arguing AGAINST them being in the HOF (often well deserved too). This then becomes a personal attack on their comments/intelligence/opinions. Since that is not allowed on here, then it really becomes a forum of nominating everyone with no one able to contradict their worthiness.

The nice thing about the TP's, is that you can give Kudo's to someone about one comment, while thinking another is absolutely wrong.


Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: nickagneta on July 14, 2008, 03:25:37 PM
I think a lot of you are somewhat missing the point and looking at this as a status thing and not a history preservation project.

I know not who C-Bill or hagrid or Crotor are. Until this very thread I didn't know Celticsblog started as a Globe/blog project. I'm sure these are things I would love to read about.

Younger members already ask who Celticthug is/was, the deli rumor guy, and have no idea what Redz original name was. How long does one have to be on the blog to remember those things.

This blog and the internet will not be disappearing anytime soon. Why not preserve our history.

Honestly, I think the first several years of inductees probably wouldn't even have a posting member be inducted that is current.

Wouldn't the originators, the first famous mods, the first tech people and authors and contributors, historic posts, threads, articles and days in CB history be the first additions to such a Hall.

I don't happen to think this should be a mod controlled piece of the blog. So get that out of a lot of your heads. I don't think this is a way of once again recognizing posters, although eventually I think posters would get into the Hall. I think the deciding committee would of course be headed by Jeff, other Hall members willing to participate, and a small committee. They would have final say based on the yearly candidates that are voted forth from the membership. Or something like that.

And it should be very, very difficult for a regular poster to get in. Hence yearly entrance and small amounts of people.

Apparently it has been leaked that TP totals can indeed by doctored and some look upon them as status symbols. The Hall would not be something that a poster thinks he or ahe can attain by cheating the system or trying to booster their ego.

It is history preservation. Some day NBA.com is going to want to have the game thread of game 4 of the the first Celtic cyberera NBA World Championship. On the internet that game thread could become "Havilcek stole the ball" for generations as people read how Celticsblog went from utter dispair to unbridled jubilation.

How many sports based blogs are going to have the ability to say they have preserved such history for the world to see?
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Chris on July 14, 2008, 03:30:11 PM
One little problem you may have not considered. If you nominate these guys for people to say all these nice things about (well deserved) you also open it up to people arguing AGAINST them being in the HOF (often well deserved too). This then becomes a personal attack on their comments/intelligence/opinions. Since that is not allowed on here, then it really becomes a forum of nominating everyone with no one able to contradict their worthiness.

The nice thing about the TP's, is that you can give Kudo's to someone about one comment, while thinking another is absolutely wrong.




This is a good point.  When we think about Hall of Fames, generally, its about sports, where you can look at numbers and championships, and things like that.  For this, unless you are basing everything on things like post count or TPs, you are going to be getting into a huge gray area of opinion. 

So what is a hall of famer?  Is it someone who is knowledgeable?  Is it someone who is articulate?  Is it someone who is "notorious" (for lack of a better word)?

Although I think it is a funny idea in theory, I do think having a "Hall of Fame" for people, who are simply sharing their opinions is a bit unnecessary.

Especially when you consider that this is supposed to be a community that encourages intelligent discourse, I don't know if encouraging the vain attempt to gain recognition is the best way to promote it.

But that is just my two cents...I bet you all wish we still had negative TP's, don't ya?
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: nickagneta on July 14, 2008, 03:32:52 PM
One little problem you may have not considered. If you nominate these guys for people to say all these nice things about (well deserved) you also open it up to people arguing AGAINST them being in the HOF (often well deserved too). This then becomes a personal attack on their comments/intelligence/opinions. Since that is not allowed on here, then it really becomes a forum of nominating everyone with no one able to contradict their worthiness.

The nice thing about the TP's, is that you can give Kudo's to someone about one comment, while thinking another is absolutely wrong.



The CB Hall of Fame would in my opinion not be an interactive area where such things as people denigrating people would be allowed. The mods have enough work to do without having to patrol a Hall of Fame.

It would be a place to browse through CB history and find info on the greats of this site, whether that be threads, posts, articles, CSL interviews, mods, site contributors and managers, and authors, or posters whom I believe would have to be somewhat extraordinarily special to make the Hall.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: EJPLAYA on July 14, 2008, 03:39:16 PM
One little problem you may have not considered. If you nominate these guys for people to say all these nice things about (well deserved) you also open it up to people arguing AGAINST them being in the HOF (often well deserved too). This then becomes a personal attack on their comments/intelligence/opinions. Since that is not allowed on here, then it really becomes a forum of nominating everyone with no one able to contradict their worthiness.

The nice thing about the TP's, is that you can give Kudo's to someone about one comment, while thinking another is absolutely wrong.




How about a "Ring of Honor" then that only Jeff can place people in. You could have a nice little area that you could see the information you are talking about. Then there is no issue...
The CB Hall of Fame would in my opinion not be an interactive area where such things as people denigrating people would be allowed. The mods have enough work to do without having to patrol a Hall of Fame.

It would be a place to browse through CB history and find info on the greats of this site, whether that be threads, posts, articles, CSL interviews, mods, site contributors and managers, and authors, or posters whom I believe would have to be somewhat extraordinarily special to make the Hall.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Cman on July 14, 2008, 04:00:29 PM
Nick, I think this is a good idea, but I think it should be kept fun -- that is why we all come on here and make comments on a daily basis -- we love the Celtics, have fun talking about the Celtics, etc.  We take the Celtics seriously, but we shouldn't take ourselves too seriously.

So, when you suggested the following:

There could be Threads of Fame, Posts of Fame, Subjects of Fame, and Articles of Fame.

It immediately came to mind that we could also have Threads of Shame or Subjects of Shame
(ie: any thread after NBA 2008 Finals Game 6 that has to do with bringing back Gerald Green or Antoine Walker).

Also, a quick note regarding the amount of time someone has been a member of Celticsblog -- it is not entirely accurate to look at when their current profile was registered because some of us have changed names (I used to go by rcs34red -- and I suspect others have undergone name changes as well).
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Edgar on July 14, 2008, 05:52:14 PM
well sorry for all who will dare to be against me on good looking category  ;D

Two Categories but not necesary hall of famer worthy
Biggest Man crush on a Cs player ( there almost all are banned)
Biggest Man crush on a Cs Blog Mod ( There we still have a couple active)

 ;D ;D


Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: cdif911 on July 14, 2008, 06:09:10 PM
i think it is a fun idea, but i honestly dont think we should have it.  we have tp's and stars with threads for each for posters to congratulate and recognize posters' contributions.  i think adding a hall of fame could potential create issues for people (not myself, as i think its a fun idea).  people may start to get egos, build resentment towards others, and worst of all....post with an agenda, rather than keeping it real.

We should have poster of the month, like employee of the month, so everyone gets a turn, that way no ones feelings get hurt

on an unrelated note, holy crap the ice cream man is outside, I've never heard him here before, that's awesome
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Siggy on July 14, 2008, 06:11:16 PM
CROTOR is not a who...

Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: EJPLAYA on July 14, 2008, 06:12:24 PM
i think it is a fun idea, but i honestly dont think we should have it.  we have tp's and stars with threads for each for posters to congratulate and recognize posters' contributions.  i think adding a hall of fame could potential create issues for people (not myself, as i think its a fun idea).  people may start to get egos, build resentment towards others, and worst of all....post with an agenda, rather than keeping it real.

We should have poster of the month, like employee of the month, so everyone gets a turn, that way no ones feelings get hurt

on an unrelated note, holy crap the ice cream man is outside, I've never heard him here before, that's awesome

Maybe we can have the NBA champions rotate every year so no one's feelings get hurt...
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Dybdal on July 14, 2008, 06:18:33 PM
i think it is a fun idea, but i honestly dont think we should have it.  we have tp's and stars with threads for each for posters to congratulate and recognize posters' contributions.  i think adding a hall of fame could potential create issues for people (not myself, as i think its a fun idea).  people may start to get egos, build resentment towards others, and worst of all....post with an agenda, rather than keeping it real.

We should have poster of the month, like employee of the month, so everyone gets a turn, that way no ones feelings get hurt

on an unrelated note, holy crap the ice cream man is outside, I've never heard him here before, that's awesome

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7sc6Uk-IJO8

Was what i thought about when i read the part about the icecream man! (being easily distracted)
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: cdif911 on July 14, 2008, 06:25:42 PM
lol got a good laugh out of that one dybdal!
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: wdleehi on July 14, 2008, 07:03:35 PM
Poster most likely to take over the blog:  Edgar


Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Chris on July 14, 2008, 07:44:35 PM
Poster most likely to take over the blog:  Edgar




As in taking over as Jeff retires, or hostile takeover?
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: wdleehi on July 14, 2008, 07:50:30 PM
Poster most likely to take over the blog:  Edgar




As in taking over as Jeff retires, or hostile takeover?



I get the feeling Edgar isn't that patient.   ;)


Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Dybdal on July 14, 2008, 07:52:42 PM
Poster most likely to take over the blog:  Edgar




As in taking over as Jeff retires, or hostile takeover?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CSe38dzJYkY

Something like that i suppose :P - ITS THE SPANISH INQUISITION!! CONFESS...
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: GroverTheClover on July 14, 2008, 07:55:41 PM
well sorry for all who will dare to be against me on good looking category  ;D

Two Categories but not necesary hall of famer worthy
Biggest Man crush on a Cs player ( there almost all are banned)
Biggest Man crush on a Cs Blog Mod ( There we still have a couple active)

 ;D ;D




High54life wins that hands down for his gargantuan man-crush on Gerald.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Chris on July 14, 2008, 07:58:56 PM
well sorry for all who will dare to be against me on good looking category  ;D

Two Categories but not necesary hall of famer worthy
Biggest Man crush on a Cs player ( there almost all are banned)
Biggest Man crush on a Cs Blog Mod ( There we still have a couple active)

 ;D ;D




High54life wins that hands down for his gargantuan man-crush on Gerald.

A certain Rondo "fan" would have something to say about that.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: rickyfan3.0... on July 14, 2008, 07:59:50 PM
I'm a lock for allowing CB to report the KG trade before any print or elctronic media outlet in the WORLD!!
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Edgar on July 14, 2008, 08:35:37 PM
Poster most likely to take over the blog:  Edgar




As in taking over as Jeff retires, or hostile takeover?



I get the feeling Edgar isn't that patient.   ;)




Is it me My Lord?  ;D

well sorry for all who will dare to be against me on good looking category  ;D

Two Categories but not necesary hall of famer worthy
Biggest Man crush on a Cs player ( there almost all are banned)
Biggest Man crush on a Cs Blog Mod ( There we still have a couple active)

 ;D ;D




High54life wins that hands down for his gargantuan man-crush on Gerald.

A certain Rondo "fan" would have something to say about that.

Exactly  ;D


Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Mr October on July 14, 2008, 09:34:33 PM
We already have

Stars
Titles
Celtic Player Designations
Tommy Point Numbers
Number of Posts


Not to mention
Names,
Pictures
Tag Lines
Tag Lines w/ Pictures


How much more do we need to differentiate people?


I agree with this and this:

Quote
i think it is a fun idea, but i honestly dont think we should have it.  we have tp's and stars with threads for each for posters to congratulate and recognize posters' contributions.  i think adding a hall of fame could potential create issues for people (not myself, as i think its a fun idea).  people may start to get egos, build resentment towards others, and worst of all....post with an agenda, rather than keeping it real.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: bostonfan23 on July 15, 2008, 12:45:41 AM
I forgot about Hagrid. I liked reading his stuff.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Edgar on July 15, 2008, 10:41:25 AM
I forgot about Hagrid. I liked reading his stuff.

yes  Hagrid  the eye.
before becoming a mod, I was mad at him sometimes because I thought he always was "regañandome" ( sorry i dont know the word for that its like when a dad call his children for doing things wrong) but then I understand his role and after that I always look his Mod. method and learn from there.
I admitt I use the thing he used with me a couple of times.
I miss his contributions and posts here.

 :(
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Roy Hobbs on July 15, 2008, 10:53:29 AM
I forgot about Hagrid. I liked reading his stuff.

yes  Hagrid  the eye.
before becoming a mod, I was mad at him sometimes because I thought he always was "regañandome" ( sorry i dont know the word for that its like when a dad call his children for doing things wrong) but then I understand his role and after that I always look his Mod. method and learn from there.
I admitt I use the thing he used with me a couple of times.
I miss his contributions and posts here.

 :(


Yeah, I miss hagrid, as well.  He was definitely the strictest mod, but his philosophy was important in keeping this place family friendly. 

By the way, I think the "I forgot about hagrid" thing is why nick is proposing a HOF.  Yes, it's honorary, but more than anything I think nick is trying to preserve the history around here a bit.  There have been various incarnations of this blog, and a lot of the site history has been lost and/or forgotten over time. 

As nick related to me via a PM (hopefully he won't mind if I disclose this), 20 years from now, hopefully Celticsblog will be thriving.  However, it's unlikely that all of our most influential members will still be around.  There may be a time when people ask "Who was Bob Day?", much like some have no familiarity with hagrid and others.  A little section of the site where some of that can be preserved is, to me, a good thing.

I'm not all that concerned with people's egos, I guess.  We're all adults here, and if somebody's hurt feelings are the cost of preserving this site's legacy over time, it's something I think we should be willing to sacrifice.  I would ask people to take a step back and recognize that this isn't meant as a slight towards anybody, but is rather a way of remembering the highlights of an earlier time.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: nickagneta on July 15, 2008, 10:56:59 AM
Could you guys, not right away but in time, PM me with anything you might have on Hagrid, C-Bill, Master Po, and some other tidbits on days gone by. I would greatly appreciate it.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: indeedproceed on July 15, 2008, 11:11:15 AM
Poster most likely to take over the blog:  Edgar




As in taking over as Jeff retires, or hostile takeover?



I get the feeling Edgar isn't that patient.   ;)



Vive la Révolution

wait...thats french...
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: celticmaestro on September 04, 2008, 12:49:33 PM
Just read through this thread, it seems like a good idea. I missed it initially, but did everyone decide against it or what?
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: ACF on September 04, 2008, 01:13:05 PM
SShoreFan wrote this on July 14th:

We already have

Stars
Titles
Celtic Player Designations
Tommy Point Numbers
Number of Posts


Not to mention
Names,
Pictures
Tag Lines
Tag Lines w/ Pictures


How much more do we need to differentiate people
?




I agree with him.
I'm not against a CB Hall of Fame
but I see no great need for it  :)

Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Redz on September 04, 2008, 01:17:05 PM
Perhaps we finally have our reason for a couple of our key contributors absence - they're waiting out the retirement period to be eligible for the H.O.F.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: nickagneta on September 04, 2008, 01:25:09 PM
Quite honestly when I envisioned this it had very little to do with distinguishing actual members. It was more of an idea to preserve the CB history if you will. The internet being what it is, who knows what Celticsblog could morph into some day or if the people who currently run it will be running it.

I thought it would be cool for once a year we induct maybe two people, a famous thread, a famous post, a famous article, a famous interview, a famous game thread. The people thing wouldn't even see non staff or non officers of Celticsblog being inducted for years to come.

I thought it would be a cool place for new members or people who are thinking of joining to browse through to get an idea of who and how this site was put together and some of it's finest stuff.

It was a well intentioned thought that had nothing to do with distinguishing members. I did ask for some stories and such from the staff and mods, openly in this forum but got next to nothing in response.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Redz on September 04, 2008, 01:37:26 PM
Quite honestly when I envisioned this it had very little to do with distinguishing actual members. It was more of an idea to preserve the CB history if you will. The internet being what it is, who knows what Celticsblog could morph into some day or if the people who currently run it will be running it.

I thought it would be cool for once a year we induct maybe two people, a famous thread, a famous post, a famous article, a famous interview, a famous game thread. The people thing wouldn't even see non staff or non officers of Celticsblog being inducted for years to come.

I thought it would be a cool place for new members or people who are thinking of joining to browse through to get an idea of who and how this site was put together and some of it's finest stuff.

It was a well intentioned thought that had nothing to do with distinguishing members. I did ask for some stories and such from the staff and mods, openly in this forum but got next to nothing in response.

Nick,

It doesn't seem like the time or energy is going to be drummed up for any official section for a Hall of Fame, but really none of the other accolades dished out here have any official CB sanctioned place either - they were just started up and carried on.  The pages for 1000 posts and 100 TPs were just started and carried on.  Hell, I felt like a TP Pageant would be a great idea, so I went with it, and we had some fun.

I guess what I'm saying is, if you (or someone) wants to start the process of making a CB Hall of Fame, just start a thread in the Forums, make some parameters and see what happens.  Plenty of worse ideas have been met with plenty of enthusiasm and participation. (7 pages of discussion on Apples and Oranges  ;D )

I just don't know that we're going to see a home page section devoted to the CB Hall of Fame or something like that.

My two cents on the idea.

Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Edgar on September 05, 2008, 09:34:45 PM
Quite honestly when I envisioned this it had very little to do with distinguishing actual members. It was more of an idea to preserve the CB history if you will. The internet being what it is, who knows what Celticsblog could morph into some day or if the people who currently run it will be running it.

I thought it would be cool for once a year we induct maybe two people, a famous thread, a famous post, a famous article, a famous interview, a famous game thread. The people thing wouldn't even see non staff or non officers of Celticsblog being inducted for years to come.

I thought it would be a cool place for new members or people who are thinking of joining to browse through to get an idea of who and how this site was put together and some of it's finest stuff.

It was a well intentioned thought that had nothing to do with distinguishing members. I did ask for some stories and such from the staff and mods, openly in this forum but got next to nothing in response.

Nick,

It doesn't seem like the time or energy is going to be drummed up for any official section for a Hall of Fame, but really none of the other accolades dished out here have any official CB sanctioned place either - they were just started up and carried on.  The pages for 1000 posts and 100 TPs were just started and carried on.  Hell, I felt like a TP Pageant would be a great idea, so I went with it, and we had some fun.

I guess what I'm saying is, if you (or someone) wants to start the process of making a CB Hall of Fame, just start a thread in the Forums, make some parameters and see what happens.  Plenty of worse ideas have been met with plenty of enthusiasm and participation. (7 pages of discussion on Apples and Oranges  ;D )

I just don't know that we're going to see a home page section devoted to the CB Hall of Fame or something like that.

My two cents on the idea.



yup I second it
and help u take care of it if u want
I have my lock for first member or inducted
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: zerophase on September 05, 2008, 10:24:00 PM
I'm down with an hall of fame. Why not make yearly all-star teams as well?
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Edgar on September 06, 2008, 02:06:56 AM

lol that should be fun...lol
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: ACF on September 06, 2008, 02:12:03 AM
Ah, shucks.
I changed my mind...
Let's see where this could go.
At the very least it'll be
something to do in the long
days of summer  :)
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Redz on September 06, 2008, 09:34:16 AM
Anyone else visualize the crowd during the first induction speech looking a bit like this (switch the red shirts to green)

(http://www.swampie.net/Portals/0/Ohio%20State%20Crying%20man.JPG)
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: nickagneta on September 06, 2008, 09:40:37 AM
Well my vote for first inductees would be without question Jeff and Master Po.

Second I think the Game 4 game thread vs the Lakers has to be without a doubt the best game thread this site may have ever seen. The downs and ups and amount of response and the pure emotion involved made it just an unreal thing.

Third, Roy's article on the salary cap might just be the most referenced and informative article I've ever read on the front page of this site. Considering the amount of times that cap questions come up, it was as educational a piece as any I've seen here.

How the 100 Tommy Point thread couldn't be elected as a thread is beyond me. It celebrates the accomplishments of our membership, is outlandishly funny at times, and is probably the most prolific in CB history with no end in site.

Just my 2 cents on the matter.

Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Jeff on September 06, 2008, 10:05:53 AM
I like the idea of expanding it to not just members but posts, threads, moments, etc.

I'm a little selfish in that regard because there are some posts that I wrote that I wish had more shelf life, but then again, this is a blog, so it is what it is ;)

In past versions of the blog I used categories like "classic" to try to tag articles I loved, but that was so self-congratulatory that it even made an attention fiend like me blush

so I'm all for a place in the forums dedicated to CB HOF - maybe we can even make you a sub-forum to cover these items, I don't know - I'll let you guys and the mod staff work that out

p.s. when time comes, I'll probably nominate a few "living legends" in Bob Day, Roy Hobbes, and FLCeltsFan.  Plus that kid Steve Weinman has a great future ahead of him ;)
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: nickagneta on September 06, 2008, 10:30:54 AM


p.s. when time comes, I'll probably nominate a few "living legends" in Bob Day, Roy Hobbes, and FLCeltsFan.  Plus that kid Steve Weinman has a great future ahead of him ;)
That's exactly where I would go as well....great minds must think alike. ;D

Jeff, or anyone else for that matter, is there CSL interview that sticks out in your mind as being exceptionally famous or well done. I have to admit, I've never listened to one.

(I know, I know. Shame on me!!)

Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: SShoreFan 2.0 on September 06, 2008, 01:02:39 PM
Anyone else visualize the crowd during the first induction speech looking a bit like this (switch the red shirts to green)

(http://www.swampie.net/Portals/0/Ohio%20State%20Crying%20man.JPG)

I am a spitting image of that guy in the middle!! ;)
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Edgar on September 06, 2008, 06:02:30 PM
Well my vote for first inductees would be without question Jeff and Master Po.

Second I think the Game 4 game thread vs the Lakers has to be without a doubt the best game thread this site may have ever seen. The downs and ups and amount of response and the pure emotion involved made it just an unreal thing.

Third, Roy's article on the salary cap might just be the most referenced and informative article I've ever read on the front page of this site. Considering the amount of times that cap questions come up, it was as educational a piece as any I've seen here.

How the 100 Tommy Point thread couldn't be elected as a thread is beyond me. It celebrates the accomplishments of our membership, is outlandishly funny at times, and is probably the most prolific in CB history with no end in site.

Just my 2 cents on the matter.



I second all of this
And want to add the "We have a new star " thread too, the guy that start that one have to be a genious!!!  ;D ;)
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Schupac on September 09, 2008, 05:09:37 PM
As far as anyone I know who is a Cs fan is concerned, Celticsblog is the premiere online Celtics reference. Saving some of that for posterity can't be a bad idea.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Roy Hobbs on September 09, 2008, 05:11:45 PM
We're going to give this a go, I think.  It's a matter of working out logistics, though.  If anybody has any thoughts on that aspect of things, please, feel free to help us brainstorm.

Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Jeff on September 09, 2008, 05:14:02 PM
forgive me for forgetting the following

Master PO (just for being himself)
Master PO's interview with Bill Russell

(just wanted to get that down on "paper" before I forgot ...again)
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: celticmaestro on September 09, 2008, 05:19:17 PM

We're going to give this a go, I think.


As I've previously stated, I think this is a good idea.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: nickagneta on September 09, 2008, 05:44:41 PM
I willing to help anyway I can. Just PM me and anything I can do I will.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: hwangjini_1 on September 09, 2008, 06:18:48 PM
hey, dont forget some other important records that need to be noticed.

for example...

- longest to get to 1000 posts.

- lowest TP to post ration.

- slowest to get to a TP star.

heck, these are categories i would dominate in a second. and greatness comes in many forms, shapes, and sizes.

open up those CB HOF doors, i'm knocking!!!  ;D
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Roy Hobbs on September 09, 2008, 06:30:37 PM
I willing to help anyway I can. Just PM me and anything I can do I will.

Thanks, nick.  For right now, what would be helpful is things like:

1) ideas for the nomination process
2) how voting is done
3) in the event of Hall of Fame threads, are these archived, or kept active?

... and any other ideas people may have. 

What my preliminary thoughts are (building off the ideas of Jeff, Bob, you, and others) is to have a sub-forum dedicated to the Hall of Fame, where only staff members can start new threads.  I'm trying to figure out if we want to do it like our Announcements forum (where only staff members can post in threads) or keep it like a normal interactive forum.  Ideally, I think we'd have some threads that are interactive and some that are not.  The easiest way to do this, of course, is to just lock the threads we don't be interactive.  However, our software purges locked threads after a certain period of time, so that's not necessarily the greatest option.

Anyway, I'm bringing some of these thoughts out into the public to show that just because the staff isn't *acting* on an idea, doesn't meant they're not *thinking* about it.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Schupac on September 09, 2008, 07:42:19 PM
I think the first few batches of inductees can just be accepted by general consensus.  There are some pretty obvious candidates.

Maybe one first big inductee class of 5-6 people, followed by a smaller yearly class.  Remember, this is for some of the great contributors.  Being around for awhile isn't enough, and being active isn't enough.  Heck, even making great posts isn't enough.  You have to do it all consistently.

I think the yearly class could be nominated by any posters, but only voted on by current active members.  If someone is respected enough to be voted in the HOF, they are respected enough to decide the votes.



As for particular threads, definitely archive them.  It wouldn't be the same if people were still posting in it.  Some truly great articles or interviews of course should also be archived for everyone.

I lack any software knowledge so cannot offer to help with anything on the technical side, sadly.


On a side note, I normally prove every Friday and Saturday night that thought and action don't have to have anything to do with each other.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: nickagneta on September 09, 2008, 08:21:03 PM
Just some ideas:

I thought about having a vote to see who would make the initial group of inductees and then I thought, isn't that being a bit presumptuous. This is Celticsblog and it is someone's baby, so to speak. So besides inducting Jeff I think it should be Jeff who decides who are the first group or two or three groups to be inducted. After his choice of inductees the initial time maybe the inductees decide together who to nominate and Jeff decides who is inducted.

My reasoning here is that the guy at the top, Jeff, knows better than anyone else who has been most important to this site and who deserves such honor. Heck, there could be someone behind the scenes who none of us have ever heard of who could be instrumental in Celticsblog being what it is today that needs recognition. Jeff, more than anyone knows who these people deserving such credit are. Also, there could be people involved at earlier stages of Celticsblog that are no longer a part of this community that few here remember of know about. Jeff would know who those people are.

Also, I'm not a huge fan of turning this into some sort of popularity contest. It should be filled with contributors who Jeff and maybe later on others truly helped to shape, preserve, and nuture CB into what it is.

I don't think I can stress this enough. I think it would be a huge mistake to put the nominating and voting of members into the hands of the membership.

Something that might be interactive for the membership could be the nominating of posts, threads, articles, and interviews and then possibly the voting on the most deserving of those pieces. There could be an area where there would now be posts of the year, thread of the year, article of the year and interview of the year. A thread could remain open all year for people to nominate these pieces. The Hall membership could narrow it down to three and then membership could vote.

Then, each year, just as everyone is returning to CB for opening game, Celticsblog could reveal its newest inductees and the results could be announced for the yearly awards.

Anyway, just a few ideas.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Steve Weinman on September 09, 2008, 09:55:51 PM

p.s. when time comes, I'll probably nominate a few "living legends" in Bob Day, Roy Hobbes, and FLCeltsFan.  Plus that kid Steve Weinman has a great future ahead of him ;)

Too kind, as always...but much thanks.

I'm amazed by the initiative Nick has taken here and looking forward to seeing where this project goes...and I'm hoping to lobby for a place on the committee that nominates for awards along the lines of "Most infamous post-championship trade idea that involved moving one of the Big 3 so that we could start Tony Allen" and "Most amusing incidence of fans hopping off the edge when the future was mortgaged for that middle-of-the-road fella from 'Sota..."

Just kidding, of course.  Great stuff, folks...the finished or at least 'ongoing' product should be amazing.

-sw
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: zerophase on September 09, 2008, 10:44:02 PM
Just some ideas:

I thought about having a vote to see who would make the initial group of inductees and then I thought, isn't that being a bit presumptuous. This is Celticsblog and it is someone's baby, so to speak. So besides inducting Jeff I think it should be Jeff who decides who are the first group or two or three groups to be inducted. After his choice of inductees the initial time maybe the inductees decide together who to nominate and Jeff decides who is inducted.

My reasoning here is that the guy at the top, Jeff, knows better than anyone else who has been most important to this site and who deserves such honor. Heck, there could be someone behind the scenes who none of us have ever heard of who could be instrumental in Celticsblog being what it is today that needs recognition. Jeff, more than anyone knows who these people deserving such credit are. Also, there could be people involved at earlier stages of Celticsblog that are no longer a part of this community that few here remember of know about. Jeff would know who those people are.

Also, I'm not a huge fan of turning this into some sort of popularity contest. It should be filled with contributors who Jeff and maybe later on others truly helped to shape, preserve, and nuture CB into what it is.

I don't think I can stress this enough. I think it would be a huge mistake to put the nominating and voting of members into the hands of the membership.

Something that might be interactive for the membership could be the nominating of posts, threads, articles, and interviews and then possibly the voting on the most deserving of those pieces. There could be an area where there would now be posts of the year, thread of the year, article of the year and interview of the year. A thread could remain open all year for people to nominate these pieces. The Hall membership could narrow it down to three and then membership could vote.

Then, each year, just as everyone is returning to CB for opening game, Celticsblog could reveal its newest inductees and the results could be announced for the yearly awards.

Anyway, just a few ideas.

why no voting? i mean thats how all-star teams are decided.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Steve Weinman on September 10, 2008, 12:04:16 AM
Just some ideas:

I thought about having a vote to see who would make the initial group of inductees and then I thought, isn't that being a bit presumptuous. This is Celticsblog and it is someone's baby, so to speak. So besides inducting Jeff I think it should be Jeff who decides who are the first group or two or three groups to be inducted. After his choice of inductees the initial time maybe the inductees decide together who to nominate and Jeff decides who is inducted.

My reasoning here is that the guy at the top, Jeff, knows better than anyone else who has been most important to this site and who deserves such honor. Heck, there could be someone behind the scenes who none of us have ever heard of who could be instrumental in Celticsblog being what it is today that needs recognition. Jeff, more than anyone knows who these people deserving such credit are. Also, there could be people involved at earlier stages of Celticsblog that are no longer a part of this community that few here remember of know about. Jeff would know who those people are.

Also, I'm not a huge fan of turning this into some sort of popularity contest. It should be filled with contributors who Jeff and maybe later on others truly helped to shape, preserve, and nuture CB into what it is.

I don't think I can stress this enough. I think it would be a huge mistake to put the nominating and voting of members into the hands of the membership.

Something that might be interactive for the membership could be the nominating of posts, threads, articles, and interviews and then possibly the voting on the most deserving of those pieces. There could be an area where there would now be posts of the year, thread of the year, article of the year and interview of the year. A thread could remain open all year for people to nominate these pieces. The Hall membership could narrow it down to three and then membership could vote.

Then, each year, just as everyone is returning to CB for opening game, Celticsblog could reveal its newest inductees and the results could be announced for the yearly awards.

Anyway, just a few ideas.

why no voting? i mean thats how all-star teams are decided.

Is that meant in favor of voting?

-sw
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: nickagneta on September 10, 2008, 04:26:41 AM
Just some ideas:

I thought about having a vote to see who would make the initial group of inductees and then I thought, isn't that being a bit presumptuous. This is Celticsblog and it is someone's baby, so to speak. So besides inducting Jeff I think it should be Jeff who decides who are the first group or two or three groups to be inducted. After his choice of inductees the initial time maybe the inductees decide together who to nominate and Jeff decides who is inducted.

My reasoning here is that the guy at the top, Jeff, knows better than anyone else who has been most important to this site and who deserves such honor. Heck, there could be someone behind the scenes who none of us have ever heard of who could be instrumental in Celticsblog being what it is today that needs recognition. Jeff, more than anyone knows who these people deserving such credit are. Also, there could be people involved at earlier stages of Celticsblog that are no longer a part of this community that few here remember of know about. Jeff would know who those people are.

Also, I'm not a huge fan of turning this into some sort of popularity contest. It should be filled with contributors who Jeff and maybe later on others truly helped to shape, preserve, and nuture CB into what it is.

I don't think I can stress this enough. I think it would be a huge mistake to put the nominating and voting of members into the hands of the membership.

Something that might be interactive for the membership could be the nominating of posts, threads, articles, and interviews and then possibly the voting on the most deserving of those pieces. There could be an area where there would now be posts of the year, thread of the year, article of the year and interview of the year. A thread could remain open all year for people to nominate these pieces. The Hall membership could narrow it down to three and then membership could vote.

Then, each year, just as everyone is returning to CB for opening game, Celticsblog could reveal its newest inductees and the results could be announced for the yearly awards.

Anyway, just a few ideas.

why no voting? i mean thats how all-star teams are decided.

Is that meant in favor of voting?

-sw
LOL, exactly Steve. You just explained why voting from the membership shouldn't be used, zerophase. Perfect example as to why voting for entry should never be used, All-Star game balloting. I couldn't have come up with a better example.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: johnnyrondo on September 10, 2008, 04:56:00 AM
I think there should be a wing in the Celticsblog hall of fame for all the threads that include a trade offer of "Scal, Pruitt, and maybe a 2nd rounder"
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: dark_lord on September 11, 2008, 10:22:35 PM
if there is ever a star wars wing....im a sure lock ;)
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Bob Day on September 12, 2008, 09:06:13 AM
I willing to help anyway I can. Just PM me and anything I can do I will.

Thanks, nick.  For right now, what would be helpful is things like:

1) ideas for the nomination process
2) how voting is done
3) in the event of Hall of Fame threads, are these archived, or kept active?

... and any other ideas people may have. 

What my preliminary thoughts are (building off the ideas of Jeff, Bob, you, and others) is to have a sub-forum dedicated to the Hall of Fame, where only staff members can start new threads.  I'm trying to figure out if we want to do it like our Announcements forum (where only staff members can post in threads) or keep it like a normal interactive forum.  Ideally, I think we'd have some threads that are interactive and some that are not.  The easiest way to do this, of course, is to just lock the threads we don't be interactive.  However, our software purges locked threads after a certain period of time, so that's not necessarily the greatest option.

Anyway, I'm bringing some of these thoughts out into the public to show that just because the staff isn't *acting* on an idea, doesn't meant they're not *thinking* about it.
A note on the locked threads purging. This is something I do manually once a week to keep the database trimmed up some. SMF gets a little cranky when it has over one million records in it and we're way beyond that. I move out all Locked threads and also all Moved Topic notices older than seven days. The way I do it doesn't affect "stickied" threads though. So if you did go with one or more locked threads that were stickied they wouldn't be affected by the database cleanup.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Bob Day on September 22, 2008, 02:02:00 PM
forgive me for forgetting the following

Master PO (just for being himself)
Master PO's interview with Bill Russell

(just wanted to get that down on "paper" before I forgot ...again)
I haven't been around much lately other than to do basic database maintenance and such, but I have to 2nd or 3rd this. Master Po did a masterful job with Mr. Bill. It definitely belongs in the CelticsBlog Classics category.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Redz on June 29, 2009, 04:39:56 PM
Just dredging up some mothballed ideas...Thought of this one while compiling the TP Honor Roll today.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Edgar on June 29, 2009, 06:17:26 PM
Just dredging up some mothballed ideas...Thought of this one while compiling the TP Honor Roll today.
I am with u totally in following this one
We have to use free time this off season to nominate this year class
and then vote for inducteds

I am all in and nominate as usual PO if theres no other nominated yet?

saludos

p.s. I dont remember if theres was already a inducted class, last year
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Redz on June 29, 2009, 07:30:35 PM
Just dredging up some mothballed ideas...Thought of this one while compiling the TP Honor Roll today.
I am with u totally in following this one
We have to use free time this off season to nominate this year class
and then vote for inducteds

I am all in and nominate as usual PO if theres no other nominated yet?

saludos

p.s. I dont remember if theres was already a inducted class, last year

I think it was just sort of left where it was.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: indeedproceed on June 29, 2009, 08:06:30 PM
Po Jeff and Green17 should be the introductory members, for sure. CFanMiss Probably too. That should be enough for one year, yeah?

Hey Chris, how long have you been around? I remember when Roy, WD and Edgar were all made staff, but I don't remember you so I'm guessing it was before then?
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Chris on June 29, 2009, 08:16:31 PM
Po Jeff and Green17 should be the introductory members, for sure. CFanMiss Probably too. That should be enough for one year, yeah?

Hey Chris, how long have you been around? I remember when Roy, WD and Edgar were all made staff, but I don't remember you so I'm guessing it was before then?

Wow, I can barely even remember.  I think it was before all those guys had joined the staff.  I think it was something like 2005 or 2006...I can't believe it's been that long though.

edit: OK, after thinking about it some more, I think I joined the site in 2005 (coincidently, the same time I started working full time), but I am not possitive when I joined the staff...probably 2006.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: nickagneta on June 29, 2009, 08:19:14 PM
As I said when starting this, I think the first few years should just be automatics.

1st year should be Jeff Master and Master Po.
2nd year should be some behind the scenes people Jeff might want to honor.
3rd year through 5th years should be some longtime contributors.

After that, let the CBHOF membership vote on who they think should be inducted. I think the full membership of Celticsblog voting would be wrong. Let the Hall of Fame membership decide who to bring in and why and Jeff gets last say and approval.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: dark_lord on June 29, 2009, 08:57:58 PM
who determines who is nominated?
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: RAcker on June 29, 2009, 09:03:17 PM
What tha?  I'm with Dark Lord of the C's.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Jeff on June 29, 2009, 10:08:05 PM
ahh yes, it is the offseason isn't it?

this may still have to wait (for me at least) until the slower season, but we'll get to it soon enough

please note: there are some missing archives at http://celticsblog.wordpress.com that never made it to the new SBN site (I'm working with the tech team to make that happen) but you can see them at that site for now at least
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Fafnir on June 29, 2009, 11:40:31 PM
ahh yes, it is the offseason isn't it?

this may still have to wait (for me at least) until the slower season, but we'll get to it soon enough

please note: there are some missing archives at http://celticsblog.wordpress.com that never made it to the new SBN site (I'm working with the tech team to make that happen) but you can see them at that site for now at least
Wow that site takes me back....

Good ole' Ricky Davis days. They were good right?  :-X
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Jeff on June 30, 2009, 05:44:29 AM
ahh yes, it is the offseason isn't it?

this may still have to wait (for me at least) until the slower season, but we'll get to it soon enough

please note: there are some missing archives at http://celticsblog.wordpress.com that never made it to the new SBN site (I'm working with the tech team to make that happen) but you can see them at that site for now at least
Wow that site takes me back....

Good ole' Ricky Davis days. They were good right?  :-X

they weren't as bad as some make them out to be - that team with Davis, Walker, Payton etc. did win a division title (for what that was worth) - but they imploded against the Pacers which gave everyone a bad taste in their mouths
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: celticmaestro on June 30, 2009, 06:30:24 AM
As I said when starting this, I think the first few years should just be automatics.

1st year should be Jeff, celticmaestro and Master Po.
2nd year should be some behind the scenes people Jeff might want to honor.
3rd year through 5th years should be some longtime contributors.

After that, let the CBHOF membership vote on who they think should be inducted. I think the full membership of Celticsblog voting would be wrong. Let the Hall of Fame membership decide who to bring in and why and Jeff gets last say and approval.

I agree Nick.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Jeff on June 30, 2009, 07:05:50 AM
starting a new thread for year 1 inductees - we'll see how many of you actually remember those days

please forgive me if I missed anyone in those first two years - my memory gets foggy going back 5 years, ...or even 5 minutes
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Moranis on June 30, 2009, 08:43:20 AM
For the life of me I can't remember when I joined.  I think this is the third site platform I have been on, but I don't remember that wordpress site at all (of course that doesn't mean I wasn't going to it then).
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Jeff on June 30, 2009, 08:50:43 AM
For the life of me I can't remember when I joined.  I think this is the third site platform I have been on, but I don't remember that wordpress site at all (of course that doesn't mean I wasn't going to it then).

the wordpress site I've been linking to here is just a place-holder for the content that got lost when I couldn't save the other wordpress site - that is why it doesn't look familiar

long story, but basically we had server crashes, virus infections (the computer kind), overflowing spam, and if memory serves, even a little hacking that went on - all of which made Bob Day that much more of a savior in 2006
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Fafnir on June 30, 2009, 08:57:05 AM
ahh yes, it is the offseason isn't it?

this may still have to wait (for me at least) until the slower season, but we'll get to it soon enough

please note: there are some missing archives at http://celticsblog.wordpress.com that never made it to the new SBN site (I'm working with the tech team to make that happen) but you can see them at that site for now at least
Wow that site takes me back....

Good ole' Ricky Davis days. They were good right?  :-X

they weren't as bad as some make them out to be - that team with Davis, Walker, Payton etc. did win a division title (for what that was worth) - but they imploded against the Pacers which gave everyone a bad taste in their mouths
I remember that playoff series very well. I felt so bad for Perkins in game 6 coming off the bench cold to try and win a game from the line....
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Jeff on June 30, 2009, 08:58:00 AM
visual history lesson

here are some screenshots from all the prior versions

http://www.celticsblog.com/2008/10/20/645420/celticsblog-is-joining-sbn
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Fafnir on June 30, 2009, 09:01:38 AM
visual history lesson

here are some screenshots from all the prior versions

http://www.celticsblog.com/2008/10/20/645420/celticsblog-is-joining-sbn
I only started coming here after my brother pointed me to the KG rumors. So I missed the early days.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Jeff on August 26, 2009, 07:35:59 AM
visual history lesson

here are some screenshots from all the prior versions

http://www.celticsblog.com/2008/10/20/645420/celticsblog-is-joining-sbn

man, I still enjoy looking back at the old screen shots - what a trip down memory lane

and a little bird told me that we might see version 6.0 in a little while - stay tuned!
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: nickagneta on August 26, 2009, 07:43:39 AM
There's just so much stuff to look through and posts to read and contributors to think about to get this all done properly. I remember CB3.0, that's when I started reading but really didn't have the time to contribute until the end of that 2006-07 disaster of a season. Looking back at the older versions definitely does spark some memories.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Champzilla on August 26, 2009, 09:21:08 AM
I would never make it into the Hall. Everyone hates me, even though I have been here for a long time.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: cdif911 on August 26, 2009, 09:25:12 AM
all 5 South Shore fans, what great guys...they're all different right?
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: cdif911 on August 26, 2009, 09:25:39 AM
I would never make it into the Hall. Everyone hates me, even though I have been here for a long time.

I don't hate you, but I hardly feel I know you...

Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Redz on August 26, 2009, 09:43:17 AM
I would never make it into the Hall. Everyone hates me, even though I have been here for a long time.

TY Cobb's in the baseball Hall of Fame.  No one liked him, but his skills were impossible to ignore.  ;D
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Rondo2287 on August 26, 2009, 09:44:13 AM
I couldnt make it because not only was I the GM of a celticblog draft team, but I bet on my own team!
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Redz on August 26, 2009, 09:44:21 AM
I would never make it into the Hall. Everyone hates me, even though I have been here for a long time.

I don't hate you, but I hardly feel I know you...



How well do any of us really know each other?

(http://www.lucylightning.com/images/movies/captain-spaulding-painting.jpg)
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Champzilla on August 26, 2009, 09:48:13 AM
If you were here during the 18 game losing streak you should get in.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Jeff on August 26, 2009, 09:51:25 AM
There should be no shame for people who don't make the HOF

the idea is to appreciate others, not to focus on yourself
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Redz on August 26, 2009, 10:02:56 AM
There should be no shame for people who don't make the HOF

the idea is to appreciate others, not to focus on yourself

Spoken like a Hall of Famer  ;D
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Edgar on August 26, 2009, 10:13:39 AM
There should be no shame for people who don't make the HOF

the idea is to appreciate others, not to focus on yourself

Spoken like a Hall of Famer  ;D


I am confused with 3 threads on the same topic
how this 3 will woork
explanation please. ???
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Champzilla on August 26, 2009, 10:16:12 AM
It would be hard for me to appreciate someone in Hall who came after we traded for KG, just being honest.  If someone was here during the hard years then I would have no problem what so ever.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: indeedproceed on August 26, 2009, 10:19:48 AM
It would be hard for me to appreciate someone in Hall who came after we traded for KG, just being honest.  If someone was here during the hard years then I would have no problem what so ever.

There are some really good posters that have stumbled on to our little community since then. I know I got here by sheer dumb luck..no one told me about it, nobody linked to it..and by that account I can't very well hold a well liked and valuable poster back just because they were unlucky until after KG was traded.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: dark_lord on August 26, 2009, 10:21:26 AM
It would be hard for me to appreciate someone in Hall who came after we traded for KG, just being honest.  If someone was here during the hard years then I would have no problem what so ever.

it takes a lot more than longevity to get into a hall of fame.  it is about the body of work, what one brings to the table with their contributions, and how they treat their peers.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Chris on August 26, 2009, 10:22:43 AM
It would be hard for me to appreciate someone in Hall who came after we traded for KG, just being honest.  If someone was here during the hard years then I would have no problem what so ever.

I understand this thinking, kind of like not thinking a guy who only had 5 great years in the NBA before retiring early or getting injured deserves to be in the hall of fame.  However, I think it is kind of different here.  Some people simply don't find this until later, and it has nothing to do with KG, or anything else.  I know I wish I had found it much earlier than I did, but it wasn't until one of the ESPN guys (either Simmons or Ford, I forget) mentioned it that I ever thought to check it out.  

I think posters should certainly be around a while before entering the hall, but if they have had two years of tremendous posts, then I see no reason why the timing of when they happened to start posting should preclude them from the recognition.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Rondo2287 on August 26, 2009, 10:23:08 AM
Im very proud that there is at least one purist looking to keep the integrity of the CB hall of fame.  Sounds like Jim Rice haha
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Jeff on August 26, 2009, 10:25:48 AM

I am confused with 3 threads on the same topic
how this 3 will woork
explanation please. ???


I created a couple of threads to discuss the early years and provide some long-term perspective.  That's all.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Edgar on August 26, 2009, 10:27:34 AM

I am confused with 3 threads on the same topic
how this 3 will woork
explanation please. ???


I created a couple of threads to discuss the early years and provide some long-term perspective.  That's all.

okis I will check them slowly

thanks Jeff
i just dont wanted to post my point in the wrong thread.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Champzilla on August 26, 2009, 10:30:02 AM
Chris was dead on with what I was trying to say with the NBA analogy.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: JSD on August 26, 2009, 10:30:35 AM
It would be hard for me to appreciate someone in Hall who came after we traded for KG, just being honest.  If someone was here during the hard years then I would have no problem what so ever.

That funny, I actually wanted to merge my old name with my current one (Jsaad) because I didn't want people to think I just showed up after the KG trade. Now it will cost me future consideration?  ;D darn.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Rondo2287 on August 26, 2009, 10:32:55 AM
Personally I think a member should at least have a couple of stars before being considered.

You know how you have to be retired for a certain ammount of years before somebody can be considered??

Do you think we should have a stars/TP level in order to be deemed worthy of consideration?
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: indeedproceed on August 26, 2009, 10:33:06 AM
It would be hard for me to appreciate someone in Hall who came after we traded for KG, just being honest.  If someone was here during the hard years then I would have no problem what so ever.

That funny, I actually wanted to merge my old name with my current one (Jsaad) because I didn't want people to think I just showed up after the KG trade. Now it will cost me future consideration?  ;D darn.
what was your old name?
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: JSD on August 26, 2009, 10:35:51 AM
It would be hard for me to appreciate someone in Hall who came after we traded for KG, just being honest.  If someone was here during the hard years then I would have no problem what so ever.

That funny, I actually wanted to merge my old name with my current one (Jsaad) because I didn't want people to think I just showed up after the KG trade. Now it will cost me future consideration?  ;D darn.
what was your old name?

Why can you merge it? I was more of a lurker during those times. I registered 09/27/2007.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: indeedproceed on August 26, 2009, 10:36:33 AM
no, jw
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: dark_lord on August 26, 2009, 10:36:46 AM
unfortunately, i predict this causes drama.  glad to see nick is running this and i think he will do a really good job monitoring, editing, and all that other good stuff.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Chris on August 26, 2009, 10:37:01 AM
Personally I think a member should at least have a couple of stars before being considered.

You know how you have to be retired for a certain ammount of years before somebody can be considered??

Do you think we should have a stars/TP level in order to be deemed worthy of consideration?

Well, the obvious flaw with this is that it may preclude some people who do most of their work on the front page, and don't rack up the posts and tommy points in the forums.  It definitely should be taken into consideration with nominations though.

And of course it also would be tough with old posters, since I am pretty sure at one point, we all started from zero again.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: JSD on August 26, 2009, 10:37:16 AM
no, jw

Oh, check your PM.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: indeedproceed on August 26, 2009, 10:39:21 AM
unfortunately, i predict this causes drama.  glad to see nick is running this and i think he will do a really good job monitoring, editing, and all that other good stuff.

You know, I imagine Darth Vader was not such a negative nancy. I bet he was a positive polly.

I bet he saw the glass half full. Dark and twisted, but half full.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Edgar on August 26, 2009, 10:40:28 AM
unfortunately, i predict this causes drama.  glad to see nick is running this and i think he will do a really good job monitoring, editing, and all that other good stuff.

You know, I imagine Darth Vader was not such a negative nancy. I bet he was a positive polly.

I bet he saw the glass half full. Dark and twisted, but half full.
well that vader guy is always changing sides... ;D
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Chris on August 26, 2009, 10:42:13 AM
unfortunately, i predict this causes drama.  glad to see nick is running this and i think he will do a really good job monitoring, editing, and all that other good stuff.

You know, I imagine Darth Vader was not such a negative nancy. I bet he was a positive polly.

I bet he saw the glass half full. Dark and twisted, but half full.

Actually, I bet he saw it completely full...or else someone would be very sorry.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: dark_lord on August 26, 2009, 10:44:08 AM
unfortunately, i predict this causes drama.  glad to see nick is running this and i think he will do a really good job monitoring, editing, and all that other good stuff.

You know, I imagine Darth Vader was not such a negative nancy. I bet he was a positive polly.

I bet he saw the glass half full. Dark and twisted, but half full.

just being honest.  the idea is out there and there are already people thinking about themselves rather than the hall.

i hope it works out and feel confident it will with nick at the helm, however, i think the chances of petty drama are high during the process.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Roy Hobbs on August 26, 2009, 10:45:44 AM
i hope it works out and feel confident it will with nick at the helm, however, i think the chances of petty drama are high during the process.

What would Celticsblog be without petty drama?  We need something to take over now that the draft is almost concluded. ;)
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Rondo2287 on August 26, 2009, 10:46:17 AM
unfortunately, i predict this causes drama.  glad to see nick is running this and i think he will do a really good job monitoring, editing, and all that other good stuff.

You know, I imagine Darth Vader was not such a negative nancy. I bet he was a positive polly.

I bet he saw the glass half full. Dark and twisted, but half full.

just being honest.  the idea is out there and there are already people thinking about themselves rather than the hall.

i hope it works out and feel confident it will with nick at the helm, however, i think the chances of petty drama are high during the process.

I dont think there will be drama, I see this being recognition of peoples contributions to the blog and something for new people to strive for not for people to get mad if they arent in.  Course maybe Im a glass half full kind of guy
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: JSD on August 26, 2009, 10:48:04 AM
i hope it works out and feel confident it will with nick at the helm, however, i think the chances of petty drama are high during the process.

What would Celticsblog be without petty drama?  We need something to take over now that the draft is almost concluded. ;)

Well, I don't think there will be any drama when your introduced Roy. When are you eligible?
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Fafnir on August 26, 2009, 10:49:51 AM
Personally I think a member should at least have a couple of stars before being considered.

You know how you have to be retired for a certain ammount of years before somebody can be considered??

Do you think we should have a stars/TP level in order to be deemed worthy of consideration?
How active you are certainly should matter. But quality is more important than quantity.

For example I posted a ton in game threads when I was watching the games on my computer at home. Most of those were one liners like, stupid shot Pierce or nice pass Ray!
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Roy Hobbs on August 26, 2009, 10:50:20 AM
i hope it works out and feel confident it will with nick at the helm, however, i think the chances of petty drama are high during the process.

What would Celticsblog be without petty drama?  We need something to take over now that the draft is almost concluded. ;)

Well, I don't think there will be any drama when your introduced Roy. When are you eligible?

I'm not sure.  I think the staff is going to leave a lot of the criteria / qualifications stuff up to nick. 
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Fafnir on August 26, 2009, 10:51:39 AM
i hope it works out and feel confident it will with nick at the helm, however, i think the chances of petty drama are high during the process.

What would Celticsblog be without petty drama?  We need something to take over now that the draft is almost concluded. ;)
I vote we put all mods in immediately. Thus paving the way for mod conspiracy drama to carry us through to opening day!

 8)
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Roy Hobbs on August 26, 2009, 10:52:44 AM
i hope it works out and feel confident it will with nick at the helm, however, i think the chances of petty drama are high during the process.

What would Celticsblog be without petty drama?  We need something to take over now that the draft is almost concluded. ;)
I vote we put all mods in immediately. Thus paving the way for mod conspiracy drama to carry us through to opening day!

 8)

We should put all mods in but one, and not tell him why he was excluded.  That would *really* cause some drama. ;)
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: indeedproceed on August 26, 2009, 10:53:59 AM
i hope it works out and feel confident it will with nick at the helm, however, i think the chances of petty drama are high during the process.

What would Celticsblog be without petty drama?  We need something to take over now that the draft is almost concluded. ;)

Well, I don't think there will be any drama when your introduced Roy. When are you eligible?

I'm not sure.  I think the staff is going to leave a lot of the criteria / qualifications stuff up to nick. 

I'm really campaigning hard for the "Automatic disqualifications for Norman Dale as your avatar or a user name based on a Robert Redford movie" rule. It's received mixed reviews.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: dark_lord on August 26, 2009, 10:55:40 AM
an idea for nick and others.....when someone is in the hall, they should have some type of logo or indicator next to their name, signifying their accomplishment.  just a classy touch if u ask me
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: JSD on August 26, 2009, 10:55:53 AM
Yeah, what's the story behind "Roy Hobbs" Do you just love that movie?
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: nickagneta on August 26, 2009, 10:57:01 AM
I have a vision for how this could work and in time it will come about with some hard work and of course the blessings of jeff and the rest of the staff. I love Jeff's idea at looking back at each year and picking out some of his most memorable stuff from those years. That can and will be continued.


I would also like to think that will will have separate child boards for permanent members in the HOF that might include a brief CB biography on that person(if they care to add any real biographic information that will of course be welcomed but never expected), some of their best and most famous pots, threads, and contributions. Another child board for HOF quality posts, interviews, front page articles, threads, and so forth I think will also available. And off course their will be an interactive area for member and guest comments.    

As for the question I think many will be wondering about, who makes it into the HOF, that I believe is still very much up in the air and probably should not be worried about. There are still so many who have come before us that still need mentioning that we probably have years worth of inductees to bring in that we of the current membership probably don't have to worry about our induction anytime soon.

I will probably be opening threads for suggestions for nominations for thread of the year, front page story of the year, fanpost of the year, post of the year and so on so look for those in the future.

There will be a lot of work to be put into this to get it going properly and it will be a work in progress for some time, so I ask some patience and cooperation. Do know that when it is done, it will be something Celticsblog will be proud of and should give even the most casual of observer hours of entertainment and knowledge.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: JSD on August 26, 2009, 10:57:17 AM
an idea for nick and others.....when someone is in the hall, they should have some type of logo or indicator next to their name, signifying their accomplishment.  just a classy touch if u ask me

Hmm... A lightsaber perhaps?
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Roy Hobbs on August 26, 2009, 10:57:19 AM
Yeah, what's the story behind "Roy Hobbs" Do you just love that movie?

It's a great movie, but "Roy Hobbs" is Paul Pierce's nickname among the training staff, and it's also the name he uses at hotels on the road. 
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: JSD on August 26, 2009, 10:58:01 AM
Yeah, what's the story behind "Roy Hobbs" Do you just love that movie?

It's a great movie, but "Roy Hobbs" is Paul Pierce's nickname among the training staff, and it's also the name he uses at hotels on the road. 

Really? haha. How'd you find that out?
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Rondo2287 on August 26, 2009, 10:58:47 AM
Yup, I think this probably just more a part of the Mod conspiracy adding HOF to their titles to give them even more power for next years CB Draft.  

I also suggest winners of the CB draft get an auto induction into the HOF.  Because next year we need to add more of a reward to the league because I feel like the competitive juices werent really goin this year
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Roy Hobbs on August 26, 2009, 11:00:17 AM
Yeah, what's the story behind "Roy Hobbs" Do you just love that movie?

It's a great movie, but "Roy Hobbs" is Paul Pierce's nickname among the training staff, and it's also the name he uses at hotels on the road. 

Really? haha. How'd you find that out?

A couple different articles.  I think they were both in SI, but one may have been in ESPN the Magazine.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Chris on August 26, 2009, 11:01:29 AM
I would also like to think that will will have separate child boards for permanent members in the HOF that might include a brief CB biography on that person(if they care to add any real biographic information that will of course be welcomed but never expected), some of their best and most famous pots, threads, and contributions. Another child board for HOF quality posts, interviews, front page articles, threads, and so forth I think will also available. And off course their will be an interactive area for member and guest comments.    


Jeff, I know this has been asked a million times, but are any of the old forums from the old sites still available?  I know I saw some of the archived blog posts, but wasn't sure if the forums survived at all?  
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Fafnir on August 26, 2009, 11:02:16 AM
i hope it works out and feel confident it will with nick at the helm, however, i think the chances of petty drama are high during the process.

What would Celticsblog be without petty drama?  We need something to take over now that the draft is almost concluded. ;)
I vote we put all mods in immediately. Thus paving the way for mod conspiracy drama to carry us through to opening day!

 8)

We should put all mods in but one, and not tell him why he was excluded.  That would *really* cause some drama. ;)
I say we do it with Edgar, the scrolling cries for an explanation would be glorious.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: JSD on August 26, 2009, 11:03:40 AM
Yeah, what's the story behind "Roy Hobbs" Do you just love that movie?

It's a great movie, but "Roy Hobbs" is Paul Pierce's nickname among the training staff, and it's also the name he uses at hotels on the road. 

Really? haha. How'd you find that out?

A couple different articles.  I think they were both in SI, but one may have been in ESPN the Magazine.

It's so weird, up until about 6 months ago I thought that was your real name. Good stuff.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: JSD on August 26, 2009, 11:04:39 AM
I would also like to think that will will have separate child boards for permanent members in the HOF that might include a brief CB biography on that person(if they care to add any real biographic information that will of course be welcomed but never expected), some of their best and most famous pots, threads, and contributions. Another child board for HOF quality posts, interviews, front page articles, threads, and so forth I think will also available. And off course their will be an interactive area for member and guest comments.    


Jeff, I know this has been asked a million times, but are any of the old forums from the old sites still available?  I know I saw some of the archived blog posts, but wasn't sure if the forums survived at all?  

Yeah, I can't find a lot of my old posts from my previous poster name.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: nickagneta on August 26, 2009, 11:05:17 AM
Excessive use of scrolling text is an automatic disqualifier for ever being voted into the CBHOF.  ;D

 ;) Just kidding Edgar.   Or am I!!!???
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: JSD on August 26, 2009, 11:06:03 AM
Excessive use of scrolling text is an automatic disqualifier for ever being voted into the CBHOF.  ;D

 ;) Just kidding Edgar.   Or am I!!!???

Someones gotta pay for those headaches.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Edgar on August 26, 2009, 11:06:47 AM
I would also like to think that will will have separate child boards for permanent members in the HOF that might include a brief CB biography on that person(if they care to add any real biographic information that will of course be welcomed but never expected), some of their best and most famous pots, threads, and contributions. Another child board for HOF quality posts, interviews, front page articles, threads, and so forth I think will also available. And off course their will be an interactive area for member and guest comments.    


Jeff, I know this has been asked a million times, but are any of the old forums from the old sites still available?  I know I saw some of the archived blog posts, but wasn't sure if the forums survived at all?  

Yeah, I can't find a lot of my old posts from my previous poster name.


You want to edit that Gerald Green,Mark blount love ..huh... ;D
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Jeff on August 26, 2009, 11:12:11 AM
I would also like to think that will will have separate child boards for permanent members in the HOF that might include a brief CB biography on that person(if they care to add any real biographic information that will of course be welcomed but never expected), some of their best and most famous pots, threads, and contributions. Another child board for HOF quality posts, interviews, front page articles, threads, and so forth I think will also available. And off course their will be an interactive area for member and guest comments.    


Jeff, I know this has been asked a million times, but are any of the old forums from the old sites still available?  I know I saw some of the archived blog posts, but wasn't sure if the forums survived at all?  

server issues, virus issues, and various other tragic events caused us to lose a lot of archived posts - so the short answer is no, sorry
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Chris on August 26, 2009, 11:16:19 AM
I would also like to think that will will have separate child boards for permanent members in the HOF that might include a brief CB biography on that person(if they care to add any real biographic information that will of course be welcomed but never expected), some of their best and most famous pots, threads, and contributions. Another child board for HOF quality posts, interviews, front page articles, threads, and so forth I think will also available. And off course their will be an interactive area for member and guest comments.    


Jeff, I know this has been asked a million times, but are any of the old forums from the old sites still available?  I know I saw some of the archived blog posts, but wasn't sure if the forums survived at all?  

server issues, virus issues, and various other tragic events caused us to lose a lot of archived posts - so the short answer is no, sorry

OK, that's what I thought, just thought I would check though. 
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Champzilla on August 26, 2009, 12:07:56 PM
I'm 50/50 basing it on stars and TPs.  There should be a side thing for people who were here when it was celticsblog.net.  Maybe not the hall, but something.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: dark_lord on August 26, 2009, 12:11:03 PM
  There should be a side thing for people who were here when it was celticsblog.net.  Maybe not the hall, but something.

why  ???

someone could be the worse poster on the blog, but been here a long time.

sounds like ur attempting to get personal recognition, rather than just embracing the idea of the hall of fame, which is a celebration of the blog and others.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Jeff on August 26, 2009, 12:18:42 PM
I think it is up to nick how to handle this, but if it were me I'd dedicate a wing (a thread) to statistical accomplishments (members of the 5 star club, the billion TP club, etc.)

longevity will be hard to prove though, because of the prior forum resets and stuff like that

I suppose everything is up for debate though, which is the point of the forums
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Roy Hobbs on August 26, 2009, 12:19:41 PM
. . . (members of the 5 star club, the billion TP club, etc.)

What about the 25 star club?  ;)

(Give me a few days.)
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: indeedproceed on August 26, 2009, 12:27:28 PM
. . . (members of the 5 star club, the billion TP club, etc.)

What about the 25 star club?  ;)

(Give me a few days.)

Is it true that everytime you get a star, an angel gets his wings?
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Roy Hobbs on August 26, 2009, 12:30:02 PM
Is it true that everytime you get a star, an angel gets his wings?

See below:

Quote from: Celticsblog Rules
Discussion of . . .  religion . . .  should be confined to the Current Events Forum, a child board of the Off Topic Forum.

 :D
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Champzilla on August 26, 2009, 12:33:51 PM
With voting I know I won't get into the HALL.  I am the scott the engineer of celtics blog. (Howard Stern fans will get that)Is the hall of fame a popularity contest? I mean just because no one likes me means I can't get in?  
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: dark_lord on August 26, 2009, 12:35:48 PM
With voting I know I won't get into the HALL.  I am the scott the engineer of celtics blog. (Howard Stern fans will get that)Is the hall of fame a popularity contest? I mean just because no one likes me means I can't get in?  

it isnt about champzilla....its about celticsblog!
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Roy Hobbs on August 26, 2009, 12:35:50 PM
With voting I know I won't get into the HALL.  I am the scott the engineer of celtics blog. (Howard Stern fans will get that)Is the hall of fame a popularity contest? I mean just because no one likes me means I can't get in?  

It shouldn't be a popularity contest.  The more important question for all members to ask (if they ever feel slighted) is, "What am I contributing to Celticsblog that makes me deserving of extra recognition by my peers?"
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: indeedproceed on August 26, 2009, 12:37:35 PM
With voting I know I won't get into the HALL.  I am the scott the engineer of celtics blog. (Howard Stern fans will get that)Is the hall of fame a popularity contest? I mean just because no one likes me means I can't get in?  

We haven't even officially put Jeff in the HOF thing yet. If you want to be dejected about not getting in, at least wait until you don't actually get in.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Hoyo de Monterrey on August 26, 2009, 12:44:56 PM
Champzilla, this seems even more appropriate on a day like today:

"Ask NOT what Celticsblog can do for you, ask what you can do for Celticsblog."
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: dark_lord on August 26, 2009, 12:45:52 PM
Champzilla, this seems even more appropriate on a day like today:

"Ask NOT what Celticsblog can do for you, ask what you can do for Celticsblog."

LOL....TP for u!
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: ChampKind on August 26, 2009, 12:57:05 PM
With voting I know I won't get into the HALL.  I am the scott the engineer of celtics blog. (Howard Stern fans will get that)Is the hall of fame a popularity contest? I mean just because no one likes me means I can't get in?  

The people who are the most popular also generally contribute the most. 
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Rondo2287 on August 26, 2009, 01:00:10 PM
With voting I know I won't get into the HALL.  I am the scott the engineer of celtics blog. (Howard Stern fans will get that)Is the hall of fame a popularity contest? I mean just because no one likes me means I can't get in?  

The people who are the most popular also generally contribute the most. 

not just in quantity but in quality of their posts.  So posts IMO posts that are insightful and show thought are better than those that just poo-poo others ideas
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Edgar on August 26, 2009, 01:01:15 PM


“When you’re in town wearing some kind of a uniform is helpful. Policeman, priest, etc. Driving a tank is very impressive or a car with official lettering on the side. If that isn’t to your taste, you could join the revolution, wear an armband, carry a home-made flag tied to a broom handle or placard bearing an incendiary slogan. At the very least, you should wear a suit and carry a briefcase and a cellphone. Or a team jacket, a baseball cap, and a cell phone. If you’re in the woods, the back country, some place far from any human habitation, it is a good idea to wear orange…and carry a gun and, or depending on the season, a fishing pole or a camera with a big lens. Otherwise…I will wrap it up now very quickly…otherwise it might appear that you don’t know what you’re doing and you’re just wandering the earth, no particular reason for being here, no particular place to go. Thanks very much for this.”



see.....I am ready.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: RAcker on August 26, 2009, 01:16:31 PM
My goal is just not to become the CelticsBlog equivalent of Pete Rose.  I will not bet on posts.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: KCattheStripe on August 26, 2009, 01:17:57 PM
My goal is just not to become the CelticsBlog equivalent of Pete Rose.  I will not bet on posts.

I bet you will... oops.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Rondo2287 on August 26, 2009, 01:18:07 PM
My goal is just not to become the CelticsBlog equivalent of Pete Rose.  I will not bet on posts.

Haha I already declared myself inelligable because I bet on my team this year in the CB draft!
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: cdif911 on August 26, 2009, 05:13:07 PM
does getting into the HOF have any perks? free rounds of mini-golf wednesdays on Rt 1 or anything?
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: RebusRankin on August 26, 2009, 05:25:47 PM
Excessive use of scrolling text is an automatic disqualifier for ever being voted into the CBHOF.  ;D

 ;) Just kidding Edgar.   Or am I!!!???

Does voting for the Boxers help? I just want to point I had them in the play-offs and voted for them in the runoff vote.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: nickagneta on August 26, 2009, 05:28:45 PM
Excessive use of scrolling text is an automatic disqualifier for ever being voted into the CBHOF.  ;D

 ;) Just kidding Edgar.   Or am I!!!???

Does voting for the Boxers help? I just want to point I had them in the play-offs and voted for them in the runoff vote.
No, it does show what great taste and intelligence one has but unfortunately it does not get one into the CBHOF!
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: RebusRankin on August 26, 2009, 05:33:21 PM
Excessive use of scrolling text is an automatic disqualifier for ever being voted into the CBHOF.  ;D

 ;) Just kidding Edgar.   Or am I!!!???

Does voting for the Boxers help? I just want to point I had them in the play-offs and voted for them in the runoff vote.
No, it does show what great taste and intelligence one has but unfortunately it does not get one into the CBHOF!

Fair enough, intelligence and great taste is good too.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: bdm860 on August 26, 2009, 06:22:52 PM
an idea for nick and others.....when someone is in the hall, they should have some type of logo or indicator next to their name, signifying their accomplishment.  just a classy touch if u ask me

I definitely agree with this.  We have TP's and stars, maybe add a little banner (you know like championship banner) for someone who's made it in the hall, if that's at all possible.

FLCeltsFan needs to be in there.  Don't take the daily links for granted!

And if you have a sig from Reggie's Ghost, then you definitely know he deserves the recognition!
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Hoyo de Monterrey on August 26, 2009, 06:27:21 PM
an idea for nick and others.....when someone is in the hall, they should have some type of logo or indicator next to their name, signifying their accomplishment.  just a classy touch if u ask me

I definitely agree with this.  We have TP's and stars, maybe add a little banner (you know like championship banner) for someone who's made it in the hall, if that's at all possible.

FLCeltsFan needs to be in there.  Don't take the daily links for granted!

And if you have a sig from Reggie's Ghost, then you definitely know he deserves the recognition!

Agree with everything here. Obviously some sort of logo would be awesome, a mini banner or retired number thing...

How about a glorified shamrock of some sort? Simple enough, yet recognizable and appreciated site-wide.

I like the work Reggie's Ghost is doing, but between game threads and daily links, if there's a CB Hall of Fame that doesn't include FLCeltsFan, then it's not a real CB Hall of Fame. 
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Roy Hobbs on August 26, 2009, 06:33:34 PM
an idea for nick and others.....when someone is in the hall, they should have some type of logo or indicator next to their name, signifying their accomplishment.  just a classy touch if u ask me

I definitely agree with this.  We have TP's and stars, maybe add a little banner (you know like championship banner) for someone who's made it in the hall, if that's at all possible.

FLCeltsFan needs to be in there.  Don't take the daily links for granted!

And if you have a sig from Reggie's Ghost, then you definitely know he deserves the recognition!

Agree with everything here. Obviously some sort of logo would be awesome, a mini banner or retired number thing...

How about a glorified shamrock of some sort? Simple enough, yet recognizable and appreciated site-wide.

We'll look into what the options are, but there may be limitations due to our forums software.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: cdif911 on August 26, 2009, 08:42:09 PM
10% off at Panera bread for all HOFers... I demand it
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Redz on August 26, 2009, 08:51:17 PM
an idea for nick and others.....when someone is in the hall, they should have some type of logo or indicator next to their name, signifying their accomplishment.  just a classy touch if u ask me

I definitely agree with this.  We have TP's and stars, maybe add a little banner (you know like championship banner) for someone who's made it in the hall, if that's at all possible.

FLCeltsFan needs to be in there.  Don't take the daily links for granted!

And if you have a sig from Reggie's Ghost, then you definitely know he deserves the recognition!

Agree with everything here. Obviously some sort of logo would be awesome, a mini banner or retired number thing...

How about a glorified shamrock of some sort? Simple enough, yet recognizable and appreciated site-wide.

We'll look into what the options are, but there may be limitations due to our forums software.

Something subtle like this perhaps

(http://www.allstarcheerleaders.co.nz/shop/images/uploads/Hall%20of%20Fame%20Pink(1).jpg)
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Hoyo de Monterrey on August 26, 2009, 10:24:35 PM
an idea for nick and others.....when someone is in the hall, they should have some type of logo or indicator next to their name, signifying their accomplishment.  just a classy touch if u ask me

I definitely agree with this.  We have TP's and stars, maybe add a little banner (you know like championship banner) for someone who's made it in the hall, if that's at all possible.

FLCeltsFan needs to be in there.  Don't take the daily links for granted!

And if you have a sig from Reggie's Ghost, then you definitely know he deserves the recognition!

Agree with everything here. Obviously some sort of logo would be awesome, a mini banner or retired number thing...

How about a glorified shamrock of some sort? Simple enough, yet recognizable and appreciated site-wide.

We'll look into what the options are, but there may be limitations due to our forums software.

Something subtle like this perhaps

(http://www.allstarcheerleaders.co.nz/shop/images/uploads/Hall%20of%20Fame%20Pink(1).jpg)

Redz that is EXACTLY what i had in mind ;)
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Redz on August 26, 2009, 10:28:24 PM
an idea for nick and others.....when someone is in the hall, they should have some type of logo or indicator next to their name, signifying their accomplishment.  just a classy touch if u ask me

I definitely agree with this.  We have TP's and stars, maybe add a little banner (you know like championship banner) for someone who's made it in the hall, if that's at all possible.

FLCeltsFan needs to be in there.  Don't take the daily links for granted!

And if you have a sig from Reggie's Ghost, then you definitely know he deserves the recognition!

Agree with everything here. Obviously some sort of logo would be awesome, a mini banner or retired number thing...

How about a glorified shamrock of some sort? Simple enough, yet recognizable and appreciated site-wide.

We'll look into what the options are, but there may be limitations due to our forums software.

Something subtle like this perhaps

(http://www.allstarcheerleaders.co.nz/shop/images/uploads/Hall%20of%20Fame%20Pink(1).jpg)

Redz that is EXACTLY what i had in mind ;)

Sweet.  We'll get to work on that,  RG?  ;)
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Hoyo de Monterrey on August 26, 2009, 10:29:12 PM
an idea for nick and others.....when someone is in the hall, they should have some type of logo or indicator next to their name, signifying their accomplishment.  just a classy touch if u ask me

I definitely agree with this.  We have TP's and stars, maybe add a little banner (you know like championship banner) for someone who's made it in the hall, if that's at all possible.

FLCeltsFan needs to be in there.  Don't take the daily links for granted!

And if you have a sig from Reggie's Ghost, then you definitely know he deserves the recognition!

Agree with everything here. Obviously some sort of logo would be awesome, a mini banner or retired number thing...

How about a glorified shamrock of some sort? Simple enough, yet recognizable and appreciated site-wide.

We'll look into what the options are, but there may be limitations due to our forums software.

Something subtle like this perhaps

(http://www.allstarcheerleaders.co.nz/shop/images/uploads/Hall%20of%20Fame%20Pink(1).jpg)

Redz that is EXACTLY what i had in mind ;)

Sweet.  We'll get to work on that,  RG?  ;)

Time is a factor, hombres.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: mgent on August 26, 2009, 10:30:05 PM

"What am I contributing to Celticsblog that makes me deserving of extra recognition by my peers?"
I'm cute.
My good looks would contribute more if we had a big picture of me somewhere on the site.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: BASS_THUMPER on October 15, 2009, 06:27:36 PM
i been around for awhile..before the move..i dont have tons of post or tommys like many new folks

reconize me
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: RebusRankin on October 15, 2009, 06:30:05 PM
I thinking I'll have to wait until CelticsBlog decided it needs to beef up the International members of the HOF, sort of like what happened with hockey. ;D
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: BASS_THUMPER on October 15, 2009, 06:48:58 PM
http://forums.celticsblog.com/index.php?topic=28374.msg502710#msg502710

anutha reason
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: youcanthandlethetruth113 on October 15, 2009, 07:13:35 PM
I had to create a new account when the site switched interfaces/servers one time.

I had a nice account going with lots of posts and TP's, but it all got flushed down the tube >:(

I've built my account back up to soemthing respectable, but I wish all my stats (from old and new accounts) could be combined.

Hopefully I"ll be a part of the CBHOF one day
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: BASS_THUMPER on October 15, 2009, 07:42:59 PM
I had to create a new account when the site switched interfaces/servers one time.

I had a nice account going with lots of posts and TP's, but it all got flushed down the tube >:(

I've built my account back up to soemthing respectable, but I wish all my stats (from old and new accounts) could be combined.

Hopefully I"ll be a part of the CBHOF one day

cosign
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: BASS_THUMPER on October 15, 2009, 09:28:35 PM
i really dont mean to go on and on....really?


i remember me and jeff goin back and forth on how to to setup my new profile...

i was sippin on a 40oz and it made a delay in the project?


*sippin 40oz*
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: JSD on October 15, 2009, 10:27:44 PM
I'd like to gas myself up a bit and nominate my thread because I was way ahead of the curve on this Pierce "opt out" discussion. Now it's on the front page.  8)

http://forums.celticsblog.com/index.php?topic=32112.0
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Roy Hobbs on October 15, 2009, 10:50:08 PM
I'd like to gas myself up a bit and nominate my thread because I was way ahead of the curve on this Pierce "opt out" discussion. Now it's on the front page.  8)

http://forums.celticsblog.com/index.php?topic=32112.0

Not for nothing, but haven't people been talking about Pierce opting out since at least last season? 
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: JSD on October 16, 2009, 08:39:40 AM
I'd like to gas myself up a bit and nominate my thread because I was way ahead of the curve on this Pierce "opt out" discussion. Now it's on the front page.  8)

http://forums.celticsblog.com/index.php?topic=32112.0

Not for nothing, but haven't people been talking about Pierce opting out since at least last season? 

Link me up.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: JSD on October 16, 2009, 09:01:59 AM
Also Roy, Look at the 82.4% who voted something like this would never happen. You were part of that 82.4%...
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: celticmaestro on October 16, 2009, 09:08:17 AM
So the HOF became official I see. Nice touch.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: RebusRankin on October 16, 2009, 09:15:19 AM
So the HOF became official I see. Nice touch.

He's back! With the classic avatar!
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Roy Hobbs on October 16, 2009, 09:22:49 AM
Also Roy, Look at the 82.4% who voted something like this would never happen. You were part of that 82.4%...

Um...  it hasn't happened yet.

However, it's not like you invented the possibility, you know?  I mean, heck, I talked about it in my FAQs at the beginning of the off-season, and I wasn't the first person to think of it, either.

Anyway, back to all things HOF:  welcome back, maestro.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: JSD on October 16, 2009, 10:06:59 AM
Also Roy, Look at the 82.4% who voted something like this would never happen. You were part of that 82.4%...

Um...  it hasn't happened yet.

However, it's not like you invented the possibility, you know?  I mean, heck, I talked about it in my FAQs at the beginning of the off-season, and I wasn't the first person to think of it, either.

Anyway, back to all things HOF:  welcome back, maestro.

I made the thread and it got shot down by many (including you) as a highly unlikely scenario. Pierce was asked about it soon after I posted and said it's something he'd be willing to discuss. That in itself feels pretty good... I'm not claiming to be the first to realize he has a player option, but I don't recall a thread on these forums about this specific topic and the likelihood of him opting out.

If it goes down I will be right and you will be wrong and the opposite is true if it doesn't. There's no gray area for either one of us to argue or persuade.

Is that about right?
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Redz on October 16, 2009, 10:10:20 AM
Also Roy, Look at the 82.4% who voted something like this would never happen. You were part of that 82.4%...

Um...  it hasn't happened yet.

However, it's not like you invented the possibility, you know?  I mean, heck, I talked about it in my FAQs at the beginning of the off-season, and I wasn't the first person to think of it, either.

Anyway, back to all things HOF:  welcome back, maestro.

I made the thread and it got shot down by many (including you) as a highly unlikely scenario. Pierce was asked about it soon after I posted and said it's something he'd be willing to discuss. That in itself feels pretty good... I'm not claiming to be the first to realize he has a player option, but I don't recall a thread on these forums about this specific topic and the likelihood of him opting out.

If it goes down I will be right and you will be wrong and the opposite is true if it doesn't. There's no gray area for either one of us to argue or persuade.

Is that about right?

So let's put it in the CB Hall of Fame? (on your own account)

Is that about right?  ::)
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: indeedproceed on October 16, 2009, 10:11:54 AM
Also Roy, Look at the 82.4% who voted something like this would never happen. You were part of that 82.4%...

Um...  it hasn't happened yet.

However, it's not like you invented the possibility, you know?  I mean, heck, I talked about it in my FAQs at the beginning of the off-season, and I wasn't the first person to think of it, either.

Anyway, back to all things HOF:  welcome back, maestro.

I made the thread and it got shot down by many (including you) as a highly unlikely scenario. Pierce was asked about it soon after I posted and said it's something he'd be willing to discuss. That in itself feels pretty good... I'm not claiming to be the first to realize he has a player option, but I don't recall a thread on these forums about this specific topic and the likelihood of him opting out.

If it goes down I will be right and you will be wrong and the opposite is true if it doesn't. There's no gray area for either one of us to argue or persuade.

Is that about right?

Would you say its about right that most people frown on self nomination for hall of fame honors?
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: JSD on October 16, 2009, 10:12:24 AM
Also Roy, Look at the 82.4% who voted something like this would never happen. You were part of that 82.4%...

Um...  it hasn't happened yet.

However, it's not like you invented the possibility, you know?  I mean, heck, I talked about it in my FAQs at the beginning of the off-season, and I wasn't the first person to think of it, either.

Anyway, back to all things HOF:  welcome back, maestro.

I made the thread and it got shot down by many (including you) as a highly unlikely scenario. Pierce was asked about it soon after I posted and said it's something he'd be willing to discuss. That in itself feels pretty good... I'm not claiming to be the first to realize he has a player option, but I don't recall a thread on these forums about this specific topic and the likelihood of him opting out.

If it goes down I will be right and you will be wrong and the opposite is true if it doesn't. There's no gray area for either one of us to argue or persuade.

Is that about right?

So let's put it in the CB Hall of Fame? (on your own account)

Is that about right?  ::)

Well, if it goes down I think it would be a solid "I called it" thread and HOF worthy. Especially considering I got murdered for it.  ::) :P
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: JSD on October 16, 2009, 10:14:04 AM
Also Roy, Look at the 82.4% who voted something like this would never happen. You were part of that 82.4%...

Um...  it hasn't happened yet.

However, it's not like you invented the possibility, you know?  I mean, heck, I talked about it in my FAQs at the beginning of the off-season, and I wasn't the first person to think of it, either.

Anyway, back to all things HOF:  welcome back, maestro.

I made the thread and it got shot down by many (including you) as a highly unlikely scenario. Pierce was asked about it soon after I posted and said it's something he'd be willing to discuss. That in itself feels pretty good... I'm not claiming to be the first to realize he has a player option, but I don't recall a thread on these forums about this specific topic and the likelihood of him opting out.

If it goes down I will be right and you will be wrong and the opposite is true if it doesn't. There's no gray area for either one of us to argue or persuade.

Is that about right?

Would you say its about right that most people frown on self nomination for hall of fame honors?

Right, because I'm the very first to nominate myself...
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Roy Hobbs on October 16, 2009, 10:14:04 AM
Also Roy, Look at the 82.4% who voted something like this would never happen. You were part of that 82.4%...

Um...  it hasn't happened yet.

However, it's not like you invented the possibility, you know?  I mean, heck, I talked about it in my FAQs at the beginning of the off-season, and I wasn't the first person to think of it, either.

Anyway, back to all things HOF:  welcome back, maestro.

I made the thread and it got shot down by many (including you) as a highly unlikely scenario. Pierce was asked about it soon after I posted and said it's something he'd be willing to discuss. That in itself feels pretty good... I'm not claiming to be the first to realize he has a player option, but I don't recall a thread on these forums about this specific topic and the likelihood of him opting out.

If it goes down I will be right and you will be wrong and the opposite is true if it doesn't. There's no gray area for either one of us to argue or persuade.

Is that about right?

So let's put it in the CB Hall of Fame? (on your own account)

Is that about right?  ::)

Well, if it goes down I think it would be a solid "I called it" thread and HOF worthy. Especially considering I got murdered for it.  ::) :P

http://forums.celticsblog.com/index.php?topic=29361.0

LarBrd33 for the Hall of Fame! 

 ::)
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: JSD on October 16, 2009, 10:18:20 AM
Also Roy, Look at the 82.4% who voted something like this would never happen. You were part of that 82.4%...

Um...  it hasn't happened yet.

However, it's not like you invented the possibility, you know?  I mean, heck, I talked about it in my FAQs at the beginning of the off-season, and I wasn't the first person to think of it, either.

Anyway, back to all things HOF:  welcome back, maestro.

I made the thread and it got shot down by many (including you) as a highly unlikely scenario. Pierce was asked about it soon after I posted and said it's something he'd be willing to discuss. That in itself feels pretty good... I'm not claiming to be the first to realize he has a player option, but I don't recall a thread on these forums about this specific topic and the likelihood of him opting out.

If it goes down I will be right and you will be wrong and the opposite is true if it doesn't. There's no gray area for either one of us to argue or persuade.

Is that about right?

So let's put it in the CB Hall of Fame? (on your own account)

Is that about right?  ::)

Well, if it goes down I think it would be a solid "I called it" thread and HOF worthy. Especially considering I got murdered for it.  ::) :P

http://forums.celticsblog.com/index.php?topic=29361.0

LarBrd33 for the Hall of Fame! 

 ::)

That's a reach Roy.

1) He made no prediction.
2) He was speculating what Wyc was talking about over the Summer when he announced cap space for 2010 is possible.


Again, I'm not claiming to be the first you realize Pierce has an option...
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: KCattheStripe on October 16, 2009, 10:52:10 AM
I nominate myself, for overall awesomeness.  ;)
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Roy Hobbs on October 16, 2009, 10:53:26 AM
I nominate myself, for overall awesomeness.  ;)

I second that, and hereby suggest that everybody nominate themselves for the same reasons.
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: KCattheStripe on October 16, 2009, 11:03:31 AM
Also I deserve to be here for trying to educate Celtics nation in advance of a player who, though undrafted, is starting for the Utah jazz right now:
http://forums.celticsblog.com/index.php?topic=29226.0 (http://forums.celticsblog.com/index.php?topic=29226.0)

http://forums.celticsblog.com/index.php?topic=25302.0 (http://forums.celticsblog.com/index.php?topic=25302.0)

Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: dark_lord on October 16, 2009, 12:15:40 PM
So the HOF became official I see. Nice touch.


ur back?!?! 

(http://content.ytmnd.com/content/a/c/b/acb80476744bb439e87a33dac8f7219c.jpg)
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: ACF on October 16, 2009, 01:00:10 PM
So the HOF became official I see. Nice touch.


ur back?!?! 

(http://content.ytmnd.com/content/a/c/b/acb80476744bb439e87a33dac8f7219c.jpg)

http://forums.celticsblog.com/index.php?topic=31771.msg593228#msg593228

 :)
Title: Re: The Celticsblog Hall of Fame
Post by: Rondo2287 on October 16, 2009, 01:01:48 PM
I would like to nominate myself for the category of, "Uses the most hyperbole."  I believe fafnir and probably some others will support such a nomination.