Simmons made 3 all star games as basically a 16/8/8 player with 1st team all defense level play with a respectable 59% or so TS%. He made the All NBA 3rd Team one year and the writers don't care about a guys draft position (neither do the coaches who put him on the all star team). He is not and never will be a massive scorer but his overall play absolutely warranted an all star birth those seasons. His defense alone warranted consideration, but his solid rebounding and passing numbers made it a no brainer. He is significantly better than someone like Smart basically across the board and there were a lot of people on here claiming Smart was playing like an all star and deserved consideration for the game.
I don't get the love for Ben Simmons. He is seriously over-rated imho. Smart has his issues (bone head plays at time, some over-shooting at times), but for 3 point shooting, FT shooting, coming up clutch with play after play in the biggest of moments he just smokes Simmons so bad it isn't even a question. Simmons actively doesn't want the ball in his hands during crunch time. Do we not remember the last times Simmons was on the court for the 76ers? Simmons basically refuses to shoot any shot that isn't a layup.
why don't we compare the lastest playoff stats? You know when games really start to matter. Does this show BS as 'significantly better'? No way.
Ben Simmons 20-21 FG: 62%, 3 point FG: 0%, FT 34%, Reb 7.9, St 1.3, TO 2.3, Points 11.9
Marcus Smart 21-22 FG: 43%, 3 point FG: 37%, FT 77%, Reb 3.3, St 1.1, TO 2.4, Points 15.4
Simmons gets more boards - he is a forward, no surprise. Simmons is terrible from 3 (ie so bad he refuses to shoot them, and that makes a huge problem for what ever team he plays for in today's NBA), and is a huge liability from the FT line. Almost unplayable. Steals, turnovers about even. Smart hits 3s, is a good FT shooter, and scores more. Smart has a way higher intangible quotient. I don't see how Simmons is significantly better than Smart. It just isn't true.