If we’re talking best seasons from these players, then that is certainly a playoff team. There are fit issues, but you guys are also constructing poor starting lineups. The ideal lineup would be, with everyone in their prime, -
Rose / Lawson / Jennings
D Will / Henderson / Ellis
Dunleavy / Allen / Crawford
J Smoove / Sully / Williams
Hibbert / Bogut / Bass
Rose and Williams would destroy backcourts together, Dunleavy is the perfect 3 and D guy, and Roy Hibbert was a defensive monster back when the Pacers were really good. He was a huge reason why they took the Heat to 7 games, and was one of the best rim protectors in the league. And prime Josh Smith was a beast too. He was a good defender and super athletic. A prime Rose/Smith pick and roll would be very hard to stop.
Plus that would easily be the deepest team in league. You’ve got all star level players coming off the bench. We would take David Fizdale as coach too, as he is a great players coach, and we would be the Seattle Supersonics, so we’d have an excited new fan base.