Pretty bad take here:
Jay King @ByJayKing
4 days ago
I’m sick of everyone acting like Justin Herbert is the toughest guy ever. He could have walked one more yard for a first down and refused to do it because he couldn’t summon the courage. He threw a dart a play later but very clearly wouldn’t commit to doing anything truly painful
Until you’re the guy out there with fractured ribs, it’s probably best to keep your mouth shut. It hurts to breath, let alone throw a football and potentially get hit.
If he punctures a lung diving or getting hit, would it have been worth it?
He is playing you have to assume he is healthy enough to play. So if he is playing, then it is absolutely fair to criticize him for not talking 3 steps and getting the 1st down in that scenario.
I disagree, but the greater point: with the benefit of hindsight, who the hell criticizes the guy for not running for a 1st down, when on literally the next play he threw a strike 35 yards down field? The "very clearly wouldn’t commit to doing anything truly painful" statement is ridiculously stupid, since you can tell just by watching that he was doing something truly painful.
But, for those who disagree about "true pain", let's take a sledge hammer to their ribs, and ask them to run around and throw a football, all while risking being hit by 300 pound athletes.