I can't argue with BB, but I saw Gilmore get shredded by Brady and Fitzpatrick last year. It's hard to believe the team thinks Gilmore is better, though he did play in a man to man Ryan defense, and I believe it was usually Logan Ryan who matched up with other teams top WRs, even though Butler was our #1 corner. It seems like we have the money to afford a fair deal for Butler and it doesn't seem like we would be able to get a particularly capable replacement for him.