If Pierce has to guard LeBron and has to give up some offense and that results in a net gain for Cleveland, I have no problem with that. No matter who we put on leBron, no matter who anyone puts on LeBron the net effect is advantage Cleveland. That is the same with every team in the league.
But, Pierce minimizes that effect better than any player in the league and unlike any other player in the league, forces LeBron to expend huge amounts of energy guarding Pierce. He's as close to a physical matchup as there is in the league and he's a deadly scorer in big game situations. The netyeffect is advantage Cleveland but isn't it less of an advantage than thinking Walker or Giddens will be able to guard LeBronfor 8-15 MPG? My guess is that Walker and Giddens can't guard Pierce in practice. How then can the coaching staff expect these guys to guard LeBron in the playoff game atmosphere that is being proposed?
As for foul trouble then let's hope Scal and Tony are healthy because I would trust either of those guys before either of the rookies. Sorry mates but Danny made his bed and now Doc has to sleep in it. Danny has two days of waiting to see who shakes loose to come up with a solution for the back up SF spot. It's not going to happen.
Danny traded Cassell and POB the way he did so that he could add two bodies without eating contract cash by simply cutting the two players that were already in place. I firmly believe the roster is done and Danny is adding no one else. Doc better hope the team gets healthy and that he gets to rest Pierce because of some blowouts because, like it or not, Pierce will be guarding LeBron 40-42 MPG in any series we play the Cavs in.
As for some of the other wing players Ray guards Johnson, Carter, and Wade and I have no problem whatsoever with Pierce matching up on Iguodala, Deng, Wallace, Turkoglu, or Granger. That is a match that favors the Celtics in every case and we still have the other wing, PF, and PG match ups that are hugely in favor of the Celtics in most of those cases with those teams.
I'm sorry but I think your problems aren't with Doc playing and developing players that just aren't ready or perhapsd talented enough to contribute. I think your problem is with Danny not putting together a club that is as well balanced and experienced as you believe we need it to be.
The time for addressing these concerns was last off season. Danny instead decided to go with the "second-round-talent-and-crippled-player-and-no-talent-7-footer-player-and-oft-injured-returning-2-guard-that-is-stupid-and-can't-shoot" philosophy of backinmg up the wing position. Dumb, dumb, dumb move. He should have addressed his bench concerns with proven vets with proven skills.
Stop trying to stick this on Doc not developing players that weren't good enough to develop. The fault here lies with the team Mr. Ainge put together not with Doc's not trusting a mid-second round talent to play big important minutes versus the best player in the league.