Two really strong front courts between Portland and Utah, how do you guys see those matchups going?
Well, that's a question that could mean a couple of different things. If it means "Who wins the battle of the paint when the two teams face each other", that's a wholly different one than "Which teams' front court will perform better against the other 23 teams in the league".
Well both answers are me. But, I digest.
This is a fun one to debate. I like the experience my team has. I am going to go into the playoffs here. I think the playoffs will be too big for Williams at times. Neither Bogut or Big Al has ever played in a playoff game. Amare is overall the best front line player but he is going up against the one guy who will neutralize him the most in KG (best defensive PF). Big Al has the best offensive post game of any of these guys. Offensively he complements KG more than Bogut does Amare.
Ah, its a war you want, eh?
Well lets start with the big boys.
Andrew Bogut V Al JeffersonYou say: 'I see this as more of a tie. They will both score on each other'
I say: Al Jefferson, whenever he has met Andrew Bogut, has consistently played the center position, and Bogut has consistently been the better player by a country mile. You're right, both guys will score on each other. But, one guy will score better (Bogut), one guy will defend better (Bogut), and one guy will be a better facilitator (Bogut).
In their 11 meetings, Bogut has shot 60+% from the field compared to Al Jefferson's 44%. Couple that with exponentially better team defense, and Bogut gets the heavy, heavy nod here.
KG V Amare
You say: "Edge Amare but after this years playoffs it's close."
I say: Amare is better offensively by a very significant margin, but KG is much better defensively. By the numbers rebounding they're even. One thing you might want to ponder though; in the playoff game Amare was actually healthy for, he lit KG up the whole time, and KG could not do squat to stop him. Plus, the added attention Jermaine O'Neal needed to pay to try to slow down Amare (which didn't help) allowed Ronny Turiaf to go 4-5 from the field.
Bench Rotations:
PF: Al Jefferson, Jason Maxiell V Derrick Williams, Jonas JerebkoYou say: Depends on Williams
I say: Well, yes and no. It does not depend on Williams that Maxiell will be able to push him around under the boards, or that Al Jefferson will likely be able to score on him. It also does not really depend on Williams whether or not he'll be able to score on Maxiell or Jefferson, as both guys aren't the best defenders, and Derrick Williams will hold a sizeable quickness advantage on both of them. The other thing that doesn't depend on Williams is how well Jerebko will play. He's already out-played Maxiell for a starting position once. It'll happen again here.
Center: Haywood V STAT, LopezYou say: I give Haywood the edge because he will play consistently with a better PF option unless it's Maxiell (5 mpg)
I say: If it was just Haywood vs Lopez/Tolliver, its a win for Haywood. But, that's not the case. Assuming health, you're looking at 10 minutes tops for Robin Lopez, and hopefully less. And, while Haywood is a pretty decent player, he can't defend Amar'e Stoudemire. Not a chance.