I have a feeling Brown will be the one averaging 20 points. Brown is more alpha than Tatum and is more likely to lead the team in scoring next year.
I disagree personally.
Tatum is more level headed but is also FAR more skilled offensively.
Jaylen's strengths are his ability to attack the basket and draw fouls, and he is also solid at making open spot up threes. Even when he does get to the line, he shoots FTs at a poor percentage and can't really make the defense pay for it. He's also limited in his ability to create his own offense due to poor very limited handles and a general inability to make difficult/contested shots with any kind of consistency.
Jaylen played well at times last season, but at the same time no NBA ever really gameplanned defensively for Jaylen. Kyrie and Tatum were the focal point of every defense - which is why they were both frequently forced to take difficult contested shots. Brown often got ignored and had a lot of wide open looks, all he really had to do is knock them down.
The special thing about Tatum is that he has a special ability to create shots. He has the quickness and ball handling ability to create space almost any time he wants, and the height/length/elevation to be able to get his shot off even when heavily contested. And if teams close our hard on him he has the quickness and handle to blow by, and is already an impressive finisher around the basket.
For Tatum I think it's just a matter of repetitions. Remember, this kid is only 20 years old.
- Kawhi didn't average 20 PPG until his 5th season, at age of 24
- Jimmy Butler didn't average 20 PPG until his 4h season, at age 25
- Steph Curry didn't average 20 PPG until his 4th season, age 24
- Klay thompson didn't average 20 PPG until his 4th season, age 24
- Kevin Garnett didn't average 20 PPG until his 4th season, age 22
- Kobe didn't average 20 PPG until his 4th season, age 21
Those guys all went on to become bonafide superstars.
Fact is that rookies very rarely come in to the NBA and put up 20 PPG seasons in their first or second years. It happens, but it's incredibly rare.
Some of the guys who did? Kevin Durant, Lebron James, Anthony Davis, Tim Duncan, Dwyane Wade - these are guys who became perennial MVP candidates and guaranteed first ballot future hall of famers.
So you have to have patience - Tatum is a special offensive talent. He entered this league as a 19 year old rookie who already had the type of offensive move-set that a lot of 10 year veterans would be jealous of - and he also came in to the league as a plus defender in his rookie year. It's EXTREMELY rare to find 19 year old rookies who are NBA ready on both ends of the court from day one.
If we look at the Per-36 production of Tatum and Brown (they may well play those minutes this coming season) you get the following:
Brown: 18.1 Pts, 5.9 reb, 1.9 ast, 1.3 stl, 0.6 blk, 46% FG, 34% 3PT, 66% FT
Tatum: 18.2 Pts, 7.0 Reb, 2.0 Ast, 1.2 Stl, 0.8 Blk, 45% FG, 37% 3PT, 85% FT
Those are very nice numbers for two perimeter based players who were 20 and 22 years of age (respectively) and playing in their 2nd and 3rd seasons.
Especially when you consider that they both put up those numbers on a playoff team - this was not your typical case of rookies putting up exaggerated numbers on bad tams (e.g Jahlil Okafor).