How many other team's benches performed better than the Celtics?
How about the teams that played from the second round on:
Cavs? Pistons? Magic? Hornets? Spurs? Lakers? Jazz?
How about shifting the question, how did each team's sixth man fare?
It seems silly to compare Manu to Posey when he should be compared to Ray Allen, so let's take Michael Finley as the Spurs representative. Farmer to represent the Lakers. Pargo for the Hornets. Korver for the Jazz. Bogans for the Magic, weak bench. Stuckey for the Pistons. Who for the Cavs? Could be Joe, Andy or Gibson.
How does Posey's contributions measure up to those players?
My rankings would be:
(1) Stuckey
(2) Posey
(3) Whichever Cav is chosen.
(4) Pargo
(5) Korver
(6) Farmer
[7] Bogans
[8] Finley
Some explanations of why I ranked them in those spots for those who are wondering:
Stuckey for me is the frontrunner. He was sensational when Billups went down and was the best bench player in his final two series. He only shot 38% from the floor but he was dynamic off the dribble regularly forcing opposing defenses to collapse and gave the Pistons a huge lift. He pretty much won the top spot because of how the Pistons closed out Orlando without Billups and how large a threat he was against the Celtics. Started slowly against Phily.
We know
Posey's credentials. By the way he scored a very impressive 1.46 points per shot during those 26 playoff games that the C's played. The 26 games is the most interesting part, he was red hot over the course of the longest playoff run ever. I was interested to see if his hot shooting held up for Miami's championship run, it did, as he scored 1.40 points per shot. Posey probably could go top spot because of his defense but I'm comfortable enough placing him second.
The
Cavs had a very good bench. Gibson was excellent against the Wizards scoring 12ppg on 47%/50% shooting, he dipped a fair bit against the Celtics but was still a good threat. Joe Smith and Varejao were both excellent backup big men who hit the boards hard, played good defense (great defense for Varejao), and Joe hit a bunch of huge shots. I'd go with Joe Smith but it could be any of the three.
Pargo had a great first round series against where he scored almost 15ppg and killed the Jazz whenever he pleased. Against the Spurs he ran into a road block with his scoring halved and shooting only 28% from the floor. His lack of scoring (7ppg) against the Spurs killed the diversity of the Hornets offense and led them down a two-on-five offensive game plan that doomed them.
Korver struggled a bit with his shooting in the playoffs shooting only 41% from the field and 29% from three. He made it up at the line where he shot 92% on 2.1 FTs per game for a 1.29 points per shot. His energy, hustle, defense, movement off the ball, and smarts were all valuable for the Jazz.
Farmer was the leader of the Lakers bench all season. He controlled the tempo, scored the most, and was the most creative player off the dribble. He was very valuable to the Lakers. Unfortunately his playoff run was quite inconsistent and his best moments rarely reached the pinnacles of his teammate Sasha Vujacic. Against Utah he was awful, regularly getting torched by Deron Williams and unable to score on the other end. Against Denver, he was so-so but probably the third best bench player behind Luke Walton and Vujacic. In the Conference Finals Farmer got himself back into the flow of the offense, unfortunately he proved incapable of getting his teammates involved ... he was purely a scorer dropping 8ppg but was easily his best series so far. He had a good run in the Finals where he was very solid and had some good performances. Personally I think Vujacic outdid him. He only scored 5.7ppg despite being the Lakers best offensive player off the bench with only 1.3apg and 38% shooting.
The final two names -
Finley and Bogans - are interesting because both are sharp shooters. Both only scored 1.07 points per shot in the playoffs. Since Finely is only a spot shooter at this stage of his career, that's very poor. Finley shot 40% and 37% from three, Bogans 37% and 33% from three but took 50% more three pointers to even out the true shooting percentages. Bogans is the superior defender and rebounder and contributed in more ways than Finley did. Finley did hit some huge shots, especially against the Hornets, so that could go either way but since Bogans adds more all round game I'll go with him. Finley scored 6.7ppg just like Posey did, Bogans went for 7.3ppg.
There was one other thing I was interesting in, how did the teams acquire their sixth man:
(1) Stuckey - Draft #15 pick from trading Darko #2 pick
(2) Posey - Free agency
(3) Cavs - Gibson, second round. Varajeo late first round. Joe trade.
(4) Pargo - free agency
(5) Korver - trade, second round pick
(6) Farmer - Draft, late first round
(7) Bogans - free agency
[8] Finley - free agency