I'm inclined to agree -- any year in which you have multiple All-NBA type talents on your roster is a year in which you should be trying to put the best team out there that you can.
However, I think a few things are true:
1. Ownership was simply not willing to pay luxury tax to prop up a group that just got beaten soundly in the first round
2. Due to the sins / mistakes / bad luck of the past few years, it was not possible to keep open the option of making a big splash next summer and still commit money this summer to improve / fortify the current team.
3. The Celtics have decided that Plan A is to go after a max player next summer. The only max player that really makes sense for that is Beal. The Celtics want Beal. I expect them to make a push to trade for him mid-season this year, but if that doesn't work, they will clear max space and try to sign him next summer.
All of which results in
4. If the Celts don't acquire Beal by next summer, regardless of what happens this year, things are going to get really dark around here.
What if the Celtics just wrote off 2008 off as a bridge year because these super teams usually take a year to gel? They didn't put players around the big three and figured they'd win down the line....
Well the Celtics definitely wrote off 2007 and that worked out.
Not really the same scenario.
This Celtics team has two All-Stars in their early-mid 20s (one of whom is arguiably already tranistioning to superstar status) and was coming off, from memory, three ECF appearances in four years prior to the abomination that was last season.
This is not like the 06-07 team, which hadn't made it past the first round in 3 straight seasons. It made perfect sense for a team like that to throw away a season if need be to bring about drastic change. This team had already improved by adding Horford and Moses in the Kemba trade. They could have added Richardson, resigned Fournier, added maybe one other player to the roster in free agency. Roster would have looked soemthing like:
C: A.Horford, R.Williams, G. Williams
PF: J.Tatum, T.Thompson, J.Parker
SF: J.Brown, E.Fournier, A.Nesmith,
SG: J.Richardson, E.Fournier, R.Langford
PG: M.Smart, P.Pritchard, C.Dunn
Even as it is, that's actually a pretty well rounded team that I think could have hung with pretty much anybody this coming season. That starting 5 would proabably be one of the best defensive units in the league while still be pretty capable offensively, while having Fournier, Thompson and Williams on that second unit could made for one of the strongest benches in the league.
And you could have still added an additional veteran free agent or two using the whatever MLE was available and possibly one of the team's remaining TPE's. Given how wide open the league is right now, that team might have been a genuine title contender in the East with that extra depth, extra toughness, and a new coach to freshen things up.